Like many other states, South Carolina has been wooing foreign corporations, hoping to create new jobs and stimulate the economy.
When a German firm relocated to produce heavy engines, it was unable to find enough skilled workers.
So the company leader “did what he would have done back home in Germany: He set out to train them himself. Working with five local high schools and a career center in Aiken County, S.C. — and a curriculum nearly identical to the one at the company’s headquarters in Friedrichshafen — Tognum now has nine juniors and seniors enrolled in its apprenticeship program.”
“South Carolina offers a fantastic model for what we can do nationally,” said Ben Olinsky, co-author of a forthcoming report by the Center for American Progress, a liberal Washington research organization, recommending a vast expansion in apprenticeships.
“Despite South Carolina’s progress and the public support for apprenticeships from President Obama, who cited the German model in his last State of the Union address, these positions are becoming harder to find in other states. Since 2008, the number of apprentices has fallen by nearly 40 percent, according to the Center for American Progress study.
“As a nation, over the course of the last couple of decades, we have regrettably and mistakenly devalued apprenticeships and training,” said Thomas E. Perez, the secretary of labor. “We need to change that, and you will hear the president talk a lot about it in the weeks and months ahead.”
“In November, the White House announced a new $100 million grant program aimed at advancing technical training in high schools. But veteran apprenticeship advocates say the Obama administration has been slow to act.
“The results have not matched the rhetoric in terms of direct funding for apprenticeships so far,” said Robert Lerman, a professor of economics at American University in Washington. “I’m hoping for a new push.”
“In Germany, apprentices divide their time between classroom training in a public vocational school and practical training at a company or small firm. Some 330 types of apprenticeships are accredited by the government in Berlin, including such jobs as hairdresser, roofer and automobile electronics specialist. About 60 percent of German high school students go through some kind of apprenticeship program, which leads to a formal certificate in the chosen skill and often a permanent job at the company where the young person trained.
“If there is a downside to the German system, it is that it can be inflexible, because a person trained in a specific skill may find it difficult to switch vocations if demand shifts.
“In South Carolina, apprenticeships are mainly funded by employers, but the state introduced a four-year, annual tax credit of $1,000 per position in 2007 that proved to be a boon for small- to medium-size companies. The Center for American Progress report recommends a similar credit nationwide that would rise to $2,000 for apprentices under age 25.
The emphasis on job training has also been a major calling card overseas for South Carolina officials, who lured BMW here two decades ago and more recently persuaded France’s Michelin and Germany’s Continental Tire to expand in the state.”
South Carolina has 28,000 people working for German corporations.
What’s the lure?
“Of course, there are other reasons foreign companies have moved here. For starters, wages are lower than the national average. Even more important for many manufacturers, unions have made few inroads in South Carolina.”
Interesting, since Germany itself has strong unions.
Just as the textile industry fled South Carolina for nations where wages were lower and there were no unions, South Carolina now meets that need for European nations.

Those textile factories were once in New England… maybe SC will learn the lesson MA learned and upgrade their public schools…
LikeLike
That will be the day!
LikeLike
SC is a right to work for less state.
LikeLike
The US has given lip service to the importance of German apprenticeship programs for years, recognized their value, but went right on pretending that EVERYONE in the US should go to college, could go to college if they are working hard enough, want to go to college and ignore the fact that this is not so. The CorpEdReformer$ and the politicians make sure that this myth continues by mandating college prep for 3 year olds, ignore children in poverty and punish those who picked the wrong IQ at birth, had head injuries or have an extra chromosome. And, if that isn’t enough, we fire their teachers for it.
We tend to want what we want, when we want it, but have the shortest attention span, patience, disrespect for those who know something about education…and continue the lip service of German apprenticeship programs. Those programs have been in existence in Germany for many years and for generations. We will never be able to do so with shortsightedness, political turnover, lack of funds and commitment.
LikeLike
I tend to agree with you, unfortunately. College isn’t right for everyone and it is very expensive. I could go on and on about what a tragedy it was to dismantle voc Ed programs only to leave such students to mediocre for-profit trade programs or to take out loans for BA degrees at lower tier schools. If you look at the difference between people with “some college” and only a HS diploma in most studies, there isn’t much to show for that lost time and money and maybe a huge hidden opportunity cost. Trying college but not completing it has to take a big toll on a person.
LikeLike
Great intentions, but only nine are enrolled?
What is missing is that these programs are not for the academically challenged kids, but attract bright, motivated students who don’t want or are turned off by the traditional college prep pay.
LikeLike
I hope apprenticeships work out better than internships.
Internship programs provide free labor rather than training. Very few internships meet federal guidelines, yet interning has become an essential stepping stone into many desirable professions. I’d like to see unpaid internships outlawed.
If apprenticeships become more commonplace, they should have better regulation and oversight than the current internship system.
LikeLike
Exactly what I was thinking.
LikeLike
What are now internships used to be entry level positions. People are so desperate to work now, companies don’t have to pay or even promise a job. Just being able to add experience to a resume has become enough. Then you work a couple of minimum wage, part-time gigs to get by.
LikeLike
German Apprenticeship programs in Germany are highly respected, regulated as of quality, certification, exit exams and the industries seek out their future employees of carpenters, builders, land scape architects, tool and dye makers, tech and machine specialists and so forth. Trades, in Germany are respected and citizens can count on a level of competence and quality.
In the US, the market regulates all that and some people get the training on the job, and others pretend to know their stuff. It’s a crapshoot.
However, US students have little options if they are not attending college. Flipping burgers, roofing, babysitting, low paying options for a long time. How well is that going?
We need to respect all levels of work and workers in this country, and not send messages that one is worth zip if one did not attend college. Universities, loans and the entire higher-ed industry along with the CorpEdReformer$… Nothing will change anytime soon.
Mr. Obama, stop the misleading talk out of one corner of your mouth, while doing something so harmful as ToxicTesting & dismantling public education.
Are we stupid, do we look stupid?
LikeLike
My only concern is that German apprenticeship programs leave students with no other options than the careers/vocations for which they test at a given time in their development. Example: If a student does not show tendencies for biology or life science at the time of the test, what happens if they grow into an interest later down the road after they’ve been put in a photography program? The thoughts of having little to no freedom to train for a profession of one’s own choosing seems rather anti-American to me.
LikeLike
I cannot speak for the Germans other than to say they are not Americans (nor do they want to be!). We value the self-made man myth to such an extent that we suspect any communal input as suspect. We all deal with societal constraints of one sort or another. To some that interference is stifling; to others it is reassuring.
LikeLike
I just turned 43, and now, more than ever, I have an immense interest in medicine (probably because I have more medical issues now than I did before). I do not have the funds to go back to school for a degree in medicine and perhaps I even lack the brain-power I once had to learn so much that is new, but if I could have this epiphany now, what’s to stop a younger person from having the same at 18 or 25? Just as standardized tests do not define a person, student internships do not. This is my argument against the specialized high school learning center programs in my regional district. What happens when a culinary arts student changes his mind in 11th grade and instead wants to specialize in communications or marine biology? Too bad…he’s already committed to running the student cafe at the culinary high school.
LikeLike
“What happens when a culinary arts student changes his mind in 11th grade and instead wants to specialize in communications or marine biology?”
I can only speak to this issue case by case. I recommended to one student that he think about quitting a program in which he was obviously not invested and take a more academic course. I don’t know if those academic skills will or did translate into a path with which he is satisfied or not. He graduated, and I lost my job. Do I encourage a bright student with limited resources to reach beyond his expectations, or do I advise him to be realistic?
LikeLike
A little realism should not dissolve the dream, and to pigeon-hole people with no way out is not productive. I would say that your counsel was sound. I hope you didn’t lose your job because of it.
LikeLike
I`m supportive of german-style apprenticeship programs for americans,but we need to bring our own industries back home,rather than “wooing” foreign corporations to bring their operations here.We also need to stop importing more non-white aliens(from the same countries to which our industries have been exported)who may encroach on the opportunities being provided by these programs.
LikeLike