I read the NHInsider regularly to follow the doings of the libertarians and rightwing Republicans who currently control the state. The education articles are written by veteran journalist Gary Rayno. I was very impressed by this article posted yesterday, which aptly summarizes the mess the world is in today, relying on the wisdom of William Butler Yeats. Religious zealots and intolerance are steering events.
He writes:
Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
This quote from the William Butler Yeats poem “The Second Coming” — written in 1919 just after World War I — often appears in times like these when the world’s moral order crumbles and more resembles “Lord of the Flies.”
Today human tragedy is on the front pages of newspapers, on television and radio news programs, on Twitter (X) and other social media.
The world is teetering on the edge of World War III as some nations try to pull the world’s superpowers into a conflict that millions of people will not survive.
Today’s conflicts in the Mid East and Europe are made more dangerous by technology that can pinpoint artillery shells to blow up a tank or to kill civilians in large numbers depending on the depravity of the shooters.
The Mid East is the founding place of three of the world’s major religions and has seen its share or wars in the last century not just between Arabs and Israelites, but among Arab nations as well.
The region’s long history of conflicts did not prepare anyone for what happened last week on a Jewish holy day when the terrorist group Hamas, which has controlled the Gaza Strip for years, invaded Israel, killed nearly a thousand people, including families with young children, beheaded some, tortured others and took about 150 hostages back to Gaza to use as bargaining chips.
They not only killed, tortured and maimed Israeli citizens, they used their own citizens as human shields by preventing them from leaving Gaza.
The absence of respect for human life and suffering is inconceivable but all too common in today’s polarized world as the Marjorie Taylor Greenes of the world talk about killing Democrats and Hamas leaders talk about eliminating all Jews.
The Israeli government, as it often does, retaliates with even more force than used against it, and has the stated goal of eliminating Hamas. That objective means lost Palestinian civilian lives seen as collateral damage.
Once the fighting begins, war produces few white hats.
The wars in the Mideast are often both ethnically and religiously driven pitting the Muslim Palestinians against the Jewish Israelites with centuries of history to solidify the beliefs of both sides.
While religion is not the biggest driver for war, intolerance is, it is in the Mideast.
And the problem with religious wars was aptly stated by former President Richard Nixon when he said “In the long term we can hope that religion will change the nature of man and reduce conflict. But history is not encouraging in this respect. The bloodiest wars in history have been religious wars.”
The Mideast conflict has taken the focus away from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the atrocities the Russians have inflicted on the Ukrainians and their country.
The war in Eastern Europe is more ethnically driven than religious.
Until Putin decided to expand the Russian empire, Europe had been largely free of conflicts since World War II, but like the Mideast conflict, attempts are to draw the superpowers into the chaos and expand the carnage.
While the world’s eyes are on the Mideast and Eastern Europe, the United States government is being held hostage by a couple dozen extremists, particularly in the US House, but also the Senate, who want to see chaos and ensure the dysfunction of government as we know it.
The Christian Nationalist movement is the foundation of some of the extremists, but not all of them.
The House decided to remove Speaker Kevin McCarthy, and since that time more than a week ago, nothing is moving and that prevents any help to fund the nation’s allies in the two conflicts or to keep government functioning beyond the middle of November.
Republicans and their slim majority in the House cannot agree on a new Speaker and probably won’t until the crisis threatens to explode and Republicans realize they will pay politically for their inability to solve the civil war within their ranks.
One member of the House Republican caucus called it a clown show.
In the Senate a former football coach, Tommy Tuberville, is holding up hundreds of military appointments at this crucial time over the abortion issue, while others like Rand Paul and Ted Cruz are holding up key appointments like ambassadors etc. that will have a direct effect on what is happening in the world’s hot spots, mostly to create chaos and hits on their Twitter accounts.
The Grand Old Party appears to be more interested in creating chaos than governing.
At the state level, 19 Republican governors, and we all know governors are experts in foreign policy, criticize President Biden’s handling of the attacks on Israel including New Hampshire’s own Chris Sununu.
Not that long ago, politics was put aside when the nation faced serious threats such as the terrorist attacks on New York City and Washington DC or the beginning of Desert Storm, but no more.
The head of the National Republican Committee, Ronna McDaniel, referred to the latest conflict in the Mideast as a “great opportunity” to attack Biden.
You did not hear Democrats criticizing President George W. Bush after the 9/11 attack, or President George H. W. Bush after he began Desert Storm.
The nation came together to support their leaders’ actions. And you did not see the demonstrations on college campuses and city streets that happened this weekend pitting Palestinian supporters against those backing Israel.
Like the Palestinians and Israelites, much of what divides the United States has a religious undertone incorrectly based on the notion the United States was established as a Christian country.
That would be very interesting because many early settlers to the “new world” came here to escape religious persecution in nations with state religions.
The Constitution guarantees religious freedom as well as the founding principle of “all men (women) are created equal.”
Many on the right are trying to impose their religious beliefs on issues like abortion or LGBTQ+ rights or what young people can read or watch.
And you don’t have to look to the Mideast to see what can happen when religious beliefs become a driving force in politics.
In Littleton, Theater Up received a $1 million grant to help fix up the town’s aging Opera House, which is on the National Historic Building list, through a long-term lease. The group currently uses the building, but its lease ends in May.
After discussions with the town’s selectmen, one of whom is the state Senator for District 1, Carrie Gendreau, and who objected to murals painted on a private building in town earlier this year saying she objected to its LGBTQ+ theme, the theater group was informed the selectmen were not inclined to help pay for a $2,500 building study to determine what could and could not be done in the historic building.
The decision was due to the group’s affiliation with the LGBTQ+ community and complaints about its production of La Cage aux Follies, the award-winning play about a gay couple, the group was told.
Theater Up was also informed the selectmen continue to explore a ban on public art in the community which would certainly impact the group’s ability to continue its mission.
This is religious oppression in reverse, much like the group that tried to block the state from distributing COVID-19 in a new program serving the elderly two years ago.
This is imposing one’s beliefs on those who do not share them.
The second half of Yeats poem is not so well known as the first, but is more telling about where we might be headed and what a “second coming” could really mean.
Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?
Garry Rayno may be contacted at garry.rayno@yahoo.com.
Distant Dome by veteran journalist Garry Rayno explores a broader perspective on the State House and state happenings for InDepthNH.org. Over his three-decade career, Rayno covered the NH State House for the New Hampshire Union Leader and Foster’s Daily Democrat. During his career, his coverage spanned the news spectrum, from local planning, school and select boards, to national issues such as electric industry deregulation and Presidential primaries. Rayno lives with his wife Carolyn in New London.

It has been extremely upsetting to see and read about from a great distance and I can’t imagine the horror of experiencing it.
I have no answers. This will never stop.
Closer to home, it’s been disturbing to see how many non-fringe groups and individuals on the left cheered the news of the initial massacres. Stomach-turning. The only upside is that perhaps people will remember when these groups told the world what they are.
LikeLike
So who says these are not fringe groups. Or more correctly fringe members of various groups. Even if that includes some of the leadership of those groups.
LikeLike
The DSA, for one example, is not a fringe group in New York (9 members in the state legislature). It should be and I hope it becomes one.
LikeLike
FLERP!
Were all 9 members of the State Legislature at any of the Demonstrations. How many were? Was AOC at the demonstration. Were her comments on the attack a support of Hamas or terrorism.Now this Albany Times Union piece comes out with a lot of comments from Democrats and Republicans condemning the Rally last week. What I could not find is on elected official affiliated with DSA who attended the rally. We do have one rather vanilla Statement from one legislature. My google machine must be broken. And the Albany Times Union must have laid off reporters capable of finding State legislators.
“The only DSA member in the state Legislature to issue a statement was Assemblyman Zohran K. Mamdani of Queens.”
“The path toward a just and lasting peace can only begin by ending the occupation and dismantling apartheid,”
https://www.timesunion.com/state/article/hochul-dems-denounce-pro-palestine-times-square-18415341.php
LikeLike
oops -one legislator
LikeLike
I don’t care who was at the demonstrations. The point is that this is a disgusting organization and anyone running under its banner should be ostracized. It was good news, for example, to hear that Jamaal Bowman has left the DSA.
LikeLike
FLERP!
So by your standards the entire Republican Party who has supported Neo Nazis and insurrectionists or is supported by the same ,”is a disgusting organization and anyone running under its banner should be ostracized”
Well we have some agreement.
LikeLike
The national Republican Party is an embarrassment. I have nothing good to say about them. But as a matter of mechanics, my opinion of the DSA doesn’t require me to take stock of my opinion of the Republican Party.
LikeLike
The action by the DSA was disgusting. I am a Social Democrat. I strongly condemn the DSA support of the Hamas child murderers.
LikeLike
Gre
LikeLike
The carnage, bloodshed and thousands of casualties in Israel and Gaza are appalling and horrendous. Hamas committed horrible war crimes in Israel and thus Israel had to respond in a strong and forceful way. The destruction of so much infrastructure in Gaza has lead to a frightening humanitarian crisis. Innocent Palestinians, who had nothing to do with the brutal attack on Israel, are being punished and killed for the sins of Hamas. This is laying the groundwork for future iterations and versions of Hamas. It appears that there will never be peace in the Middle East, just periodic rounds of massacres and slaughters. I’m hoping for some kind of miracle in the future but things are not looking good for years to come.
LikeLike
Hamas is the enemy of the Palestinian people. They want them to be human shields. The more deaths, the better for Hamas.
LikeLike
Sadly that is only partially true. In every conflict many if not most civilians fully support the Government. Whoever that might be, as long as there is little cost to pay. The bill often comes due with interest and penalties.
LikeLike
Hamas was elected to govern the Gaza Strip in 2006 or 2007. Since then, there has not been another election. Hamas carried out its savage plan knowing full well that the Israelis would respond with maximum force. Hamas wants many deaths so they can claim the high ground. They are using the Palestinians as human shields. They even urged civilians not to leave the area that Israel warned would be targeted. That’s a brutal use of their own people.
LikeLike
dianeravitch
Do I disagree?
However from 2021:
https://thehill.com/policy/international/middle-east-north-africa/558549-support-for-hamas-surges-among-palestinians/
LikeLike
Joel, I would be more impressed with “Palestinian support for Hamas” if Hamas held an election. They won an election in 2006 and there have been no elections since then. Israel assumed that Hamas was transforming into a reasonable governing party. They assumed wrong.
LikeLike
Israel is in serious trouble right now. Hamas saw that Saudi Arabia was about to normalize relations with Israel which would cut off Hamas’ funding. They saw that the U.S. House of Representatives was paralyzed. They attacked, and Saudi Arabia backed out of the deal with Israel. Hamas has already won its war. They secured their money.
Iran and Hezbollah are empowered by the scuttling of the deal. The Shiites don’t have to compete against the Sunnis for terrorist funding. They likely see the opportunity in Lebanon and Syria that everyone else sees. Another attack appears imminent. Russia is also interested. The U.S. needs to flood the region with money and military resources to prevent it. But the U.S. is paralyzed by rightwing extremism and isolationism. And by the way, don’t forget that Egypt is now faced with a massive immigration and security problem. They’re not happy. That brings to bear a key oil shipping passage.
Very serious.
The people who weakened the U.S., however, will not take blame and will not be concerned. They are too busy paying six CEOs six figure salaries to run two charter schools.
LikeLike
Hamas is funded by Qatar and armed by Iran. Saudi Arabia does not subsidize Hamas. Iran and the Saudis are enemies. Iran wanted to scuttle the pending deal to normalize relations between Israel and Saudi Arabia.
LikeLike
That’s impossible because I never make mistakes. Just kidding. I erred in a moment of impatience. One of the most significant reasons I’m a Ravitch fan is your forthright integrity and willingness to admit mistakes, especially the big one about supporting standardization. If only Bill Gates could admit to being wrong once in a while. I was wrong.
LikeLike
Intolerance and greed are behind a lot of the unrest in the world. We can and must do better if we are to ever live in a peaceful world. Apropos of this theme I have my DVR set to record “World on Fire” on PBS.
LikeLike
Carrie Gendreau, referenced in the post, went to Bob Jones University.
On an atrocity scale, compare families killed in their homes in Israel by Hamas and, 12 year old girls raped by their stepfathers, forced into 9 months of pregnancy and delivery of a baby that nearly 1/2 of Americans (the GOP) don’t provide aid for. And, the same religious right believes they are justified in condemning the girl for being a single mother.
Hamas’ latest atrocities are a half a world away. The atrocities of right wing Catholics and evangelicals are outside of our doors. In the “Christian” world they created they demand and expect us to respect them. Absolutely, not going to do it.
LikeLike
Sorry, Linda, you didn’t make clear what you conclude from comparing support by American Catholics for anti-abortion laws and the murders of civilians by Hamas. These are equivalent in your view? Or are the Catholics worse in your view?
LikeLike
FLERP,
You’re wasting your time trying to reason with the anti-Christian fanatic “Linda”. In her mind everything results from the evils of Christians, especially of Catholics. She says the same things many times every month. She draws an absurd moral equivalence between mass murderers and people who oppose abortion. A total nut, just one of several who comment frequently on this blog.
LikeLike
Linda goes after Catholics in particular, not Christians generally. I have tried several times to ask her why the particular focus on the Catholic church, but she never answers the question. I, too, am no fan of the Catholic church, though I am fond of the current Pope. If you want to expostulate about someone being anti-Christian GENERALLY, I’m probably a better target:
LikeLike
I never cease to be amazed at how little most Christians I meet know about their own religion, their own scriptures, and about religion generally. For example, few seem to understand that humans existed for hundreds of thousands of years before the Hebrews invented monotheism.
LikeLike
I have a little more charitable view. Linda is certainly monomaniacal in her focus, at least here. But her underlying argument, that Catholic policy has a deleterious and perhaps undercovered impact in American life, is at a minimum not frivolous. I’m just trying to understand how she views the comparison she posed, i.e. the comparison of Catholics who support anti-abortion legislation and people who murder and rape civilians. I’m pro-choice but my mother is not, and I’d hate to be associated with anyone as bad or worse than Hamas.
LikeLike
Flerp-
I’m missing something here. A commenter falsely labels me and calls me names and, you think or feel that you have to invoke your charitable impulses in order to follow up with a question for me?
I’ll try to add/fill in some pieces about a scenario I posed for reflection at 1:45.
If a religious sect sacrificed 4 women/ children a day over a year of time, it would approximate the number of Israelis killed in the Hamas attack in one day. The Hamas attack was acute as in sudden. The impact of religious political policy is chronic, marked by long duration.
I asked readers to weigh consequences when they reasoned about relative moral outrage. We know the nature of media is to go for the ratings they get from catastrophic events.
We could look at numbers, how many LGBTQ commit suicide. How many are injured by bullying, what are their rates of alcohol and drug abuse as contrasted with heterosexuals, etc.
We could look at maternal deaths. In the US, the rate has significantly increased over the past few years. It jumped dramatically from 2020 to 2021. We might consider factoring into the numbers the lack of access to abortion. The death rate associated with abortion is substantially less.
We could look at child/ woman murders and injuries linked to cited motives of religious beliefs.
Some may want to make the case that the man who beats his daughter to death in an honor killing is solely responsible. Some may say only the rapist is responsible when the 10 year old girl in Ohio dies during her pregnancy after being denied an abortion. Some may make the case that the mother and her fellow church goers who watched the honor killing and did nothing have no blame. Some may say those who vote for politicians knowing they will prohibit abortion have no reason to feel guilty about the ten year old.
My answers to the scenario I present have no importance. The answers of the majority mean everything.
LikeLike
Bob-
I focus almost exclusively on political Catholic influence because no mainstream media nor major influencer does. The general public interprets the plethora of articles about tax money for Christian schools, what Hillsdale does in K-12, what Christian nationalists did on Jan. 6, the successes of organizations like CNP and EPPC, what SCOTUS does relative to religion’s wins, and, what law firms like Becket Law, Jones Day and ADL do, etc., as driven by evangelical protestants.
That is a huge false understanding that imperils the nation’s democracy.
As example, which education blog post or msm education reporter’s article has described the most influential legal scholar advancing religious charter schools?
Because you choose not to believe the answer I cite repeatedly ( I deduce you want a personal story when there is none) it is not equivalent to me refusing to answer.
LikeLike
Bob,
My answer is in moderation.
LikeLike
My point is that the Catholic church is not the radix malorum. Somehow, whatever the topic, Linda, you find some way, however tenuous, to tie that topic to something bad thought or done by some Catholic somewhere. This is a bit over the top, to say the least.
LikeLike
Linda, comparison of the brutal Hamas to other matters has the rhetorical effect of lessening them. Not acceptable. What if, for example, I compared 9/11 to this?
https://agsjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1532-5415.2007.01255.x
LikeLike
The public outrage, on a huge scale, that Hamas is getting is deserved. How women’s lives are cut short and diminished by right wing religious policy in the US, doesn’t get much push back, as evidence, the number of states that have limited or banned abortion.
One comparison that could be made is if Hamas’ attacks, last week, or the suicide bombers on 9/11, had intentionally singled out women for potential death.
Btw- If Catholics and evangelicals want to enact public policy that forces the elderly to take baths that put them in unsafe conditions (your link), I’m opposed to it and we could hope there would be pushback.
LikeLike
Don’t get me wrong, Linda. I am horrified by Catholic and evangelical sexism with regard to staffing the ministry and even more so by the policies they espouse, such as banning abortion, that deprive women and girls of essential health care and put their lives, often, at risk even unto death.
LikeLike
We should have placed have the Executive Branch under the aegis of a Department of Bathroom Security!
LikeLike
Key phrase…Gary Rayno is a “veteran journalist”.
Thanks to all of the journalists out there, especially those on the front lines in the Mideast and other war zones. The facts have to be nailed down; the truth has got to be told.
LikeLike
Those seeking to use the mess in the Middle East to undermine the Biden image are heirs to that fortune. The Republican Party was so adept at blaming Democrats for world events in the Truman administration that they placed blame for the success of the communist insurgency in China at the door of Truman, saying that the Democrats “lost China.” President Johnson told Doris Kearns that he knew that a loss of Vietnam to the communist would ruin his presidency (he put it a bit more earthy).
Meanwhile, Democrats mourned with Reagan over the attack on American troops who were celebrating an imminent return home a and supported Bush 1 and 2 in their adventures.
But this new breed of Republicans has a new goal that was stated plainly by McConnel during the Obama administration: even if a policy was good for the country, the Republican Party would oppose it so that no credit would go to his presidency. The GOP is now the party of destroy.
LikeLike
Roy, it’s crazy that the Republicans blame Biden for Hamas’ brutal attack on Israel. Biden is not in charge of Israel’s intelligence or security. I read that McCarthy was also blaming Biden for the chaos in the GOP. They never accept accountability. Children.
LikeLike
“Until Putin decided to expand the Russian empire, Europe had been largely free of conflicts since World War II…” That’s not even close to being true!
LikeLike
There weee no full-scale wars in Europe since WW2, no hand to hand conflict or trench warfare as in WW 1.
LikeLike
The pugs are just fine with burning it all down.
Three births in the poetry of William Butler Yeats, from my book Notes to Krystalina:
14.7 Possibly the greatest poet of the twentieth century, after Wallace Stevens, was William Butler Yeats. He saw history as proceeding according to punctuated equilibria–periods of normality followed by periods of cataclysmic change like the establishment and fall of empires. Among his many other accomplishments, Yeats wrote major works about apocalyptic “births,” i.e., cataclysmic shifts in human history.
To Yeats’s mind, the birth of Helen of Troy, conceived by Leda in a rape by Zeus, marked the beginning of one of these eras of rapid change. Her birth ushered in what we sometimes refer to as the Heroic Era of ancient Greece. We still call it this because of the heroic tales written about the period and because some of us are crazy enough, still, to think that burning a city to the ground and slaughtering its inhabitants is heroic. It was her abduction by Paris that led to the Trojan War, recounted in the Iliad. The Odyssey is, ofc, the epistodic story of the return of one of the heros of that war, the guy who conceived of the Trojan Horse. Yeats writes in “Leda and the Swan”:
A shudder in the loins engenders there
The broken wall, the burning roof and tower
And Agamemnon dead.
14.8 Another birth signaled the beginning of the next age, the Christian one. But as Yeats explained in another poem received in vision, the turbulence that destroyed the Classical world and gave birth to the Christian one was not the last. This second poem about this intersection of the spiritual and physical words is called “The Magi.” In it, he recounts from the vantage point of today (Yeats’s today) a vision of the Magi looking at world events, recalling the hope they had at the birth of Christ (and of the Christian Era), and being “unsatisfied”:
Now as at all times I can see in the mind’s eye,
In their stiff, painted clothes, the pale unsatisfied ones
. . . hovering side by side,
And all their eyes still fixed, hoping to find once more,
Being by Calvary’s turbulence unsatisfied,
The uncontrollable mystery on the bestial floor
14.9 Toward the end of his life, Yeats wrote of the coming immanent, world-changing birth in another vision report, “The Second Coming.” . . .
14.11 Yeats was a visionary and throughout his life practiced and wrote books about Theosophy and spiritualism, something that embarrasses contemporary scholars who idolize him. Yeats often wrote employing symbols derived from visionary states intentionally entered into by his wife to supply him with such symbols. During most of our human history, the term visionary poet would have been considered redundant. Today, when poetry has largely become a kind of refined diary writing or confessional, I feel obliged to use the whole term, despite its redundancy, to describe what Yeats was doing.
14.12 What Yeats foresaw in 1919, shortly after the First World War, when he wrote “The Second Coming” was not the Second World War (though that would come, inevitably, the seed being planted at the end of the first) but something far, far, far more consequential, even, that that.
We have a rough time ahead of us, Krystal-chan, but in that time, despite and because of the disruptions, something incredibly beautiful will be born.
LikeLike
Lately, I’ve been having anxiety dreams again. In these, I am lost in a vast, maze-like space or I am trying to get too much luggage from Point A to Point B or it’s exam time and there’s a class I forgot I had and that I haven’t attended. I had similar dreams when I was a kid. Not to get all Freudian about this, I suspect that these dreams are sublimations of anxiety about aging that I generally push to the background of my thoughts. This is odd because I think of myself as being a low-anxiety person. Zen mind.
So, I just woke from such a dream. In it, I was teaching a seminar at Indiana University on the Deconstructionist critic and philosopher Jacques Derrida, and I had just handed out course packets for a big paper that was due from the group in two weeks. The class and I had agreed to hold one long session, with a lunch break, on Tuesdays instead of meeting twice a week, as was standard. So, we arrived back in class after break only to find that the seminar room had been taken over by Chris Rufo and a bunch of “Moms for Liberty.” They had placed a large wooden cross upright on the seminar table, and Rufo was reading aloud from the course packet and commenting about how “This says that language means one thing AND another thing. Like the Bible’s not literal. See how subtle The Beast is? This doesn’t even make sense, but you can tell that it is anti-American and anti-God.” And the Moms are chiming in, saying, “Yes, Jesus” and the like. So, I say to Rufo, “I can explain exactly what that passage means if you would actually like to learn, and btw, Christ himself said that he spoke in parables so that those with ears to hear could hear and those without them could not.” At which point the Moms chased me and the other seminar folk out of the room, and the students were all upset because their papers were going to be due soon and their notes and packets were inside, with the nutcases. And at that point I woke up.
LikeLike