I have been saving this lovely tribute for the right moment. It’s now, as red state legislatures rev up their attacks on teachers and on the profession. North Carolina leads the pack in its current effort to lower entry standards for teachers (only an associate degree needed to enter the field—two years of college), and pay tied to student test scores, a practice that has failed everywhere tried. In the background is the Gates Foundation, repeating its well-established practice of funding failure. Florida, too, is lowering its standards for teachers and welcoming non-professionals into the classroom. Think of it: Do you want your next air flight to be piloted by someone with six weeks training? Do you want a surgery performed by a medical student?
Dan Rather, a graduate of the Houston public schools (like me), remembers his teachers with gratitude:
One of the great sadnesses of our current age is how politics has polluted so much of our public discourse and spread into realms that once seemed free of partisanship. That this occurs at a time when much of the Republican Party has adopted the posture of a bully and is gripped by extremist ideology and attacks on truth and justice makes it all the more dangerous and dispiriting.
Perhaps nowhere is this more true than in the battlegrounds that our schools have become. We are living in an age when the number of books being banned is on the rise and the willingness to confront America’s complicated history is on the decline. We see intolerance worn as a badge of toughness, while inclusion, the great promise of what public education can be, is treated as weakness. We see a concerted effort to take over school boards, especially in deeply conservative areas, with true believers in the culture wars eager to inflict their small-mindedness, bias, and mean-spirited ideology on shaping how young minds are taught.
Teaching, already an underappreciated profession in this country, is becoming an even less appealing line of work. We have educators who have spent decades in the classroom now forced to look over their shoulders, wondering whether the books on their shelves or their carefully honed lesson plans will run afoul of the new draconian mandates. And we have young idealists with freshly minted teaching certificates wondering whether they can impart their excitement and new ideas into the students before them.
Some of these concerns are not new. When I was a student, for example, racial injustice in the form of legally segregated schools was a hallmark of public education. Schools have always been shaped by the larger societal forces that whip around them. Public education is, after all, about molding the minds and the mores of future citizens. Few institutions have more power in determining what this country will become than our schools.
But there have been decades of progress on what and how our children are taught, and today that wave of advancement is retreating in many parts of America. Sadly, there are so many examples of far-right ideology shaping curricula, on issues ranging from race to LGBTQ rights to science, that to call them all out individually is an impossible task. This is a broad movement not confined by school or district; much of the effort is being directed at the state level.
Republican politicians have learned that they can rally their base through bad-faith misrepresentations of school culture, which they depict as out of control with so-called “woke” ideology (which we wrote about in Steady here) and the bogeyman of “critical race theory,” which they totally mischaracterize — and which is taught in almost none of the schools where they have made it an issue. Nearly every parent wants good schools for their children, and Republicans are playing to fears they have carefully fanned to lure in voters even beyond their base. This was notably true in the last gubernatorial election in Virginia. Meanwhile, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has cultivated his political reputation (and a likely presidential run) by attacking professional educators — and indeed the very idea that schools should be welcoming, tolerant learning environments.
The elections that lie ahead — not only the big, marquee ones, but more importantly, those for school boards and other local offices — will do a lot to shape what will happen in our schools in the years to come. But there is another force that is even more powerful, and as we mark the beginning of a new school year, let us recognize it: teachers.
While we should grapple with the political context laid out above, let us shift the tone of this piece now to one of celebration. Writing about teachers, singing their praises, honoring them as American heroes has long been one of my favorite activities. It never gets old, and it never gets less important.
I would like to use whatever platform I have to shine a spotlight of deep respect on these invaluable public servants. And I am pleased that if you search for quotes from me online, one of the most popular is this:
“The dream begins with a teacher who believes in you, who tugs and pushes and leads you to the next plateau, sometimes poking you with a sharp stick called ‘truth.’”
I believe every word of it. These aren’t empty sentiments. They come from my lived history. A while back here on Steady, I shared my own experiences as a student of public schools, including an emotional return to my elementary school in Houston.
For all the challenges our schools face, right now millions of children are learning about the world and themselves thanks to dedicated teachers. Teachers are going the extra mile, reaching out to kids in need, tweaking lesson plans to include new insights, passing their own inspirations to the young people before them.
The work is not easy — far from it. And it can be an incredible grind, especially when it seems that society doesn’t value it or is even outright hostile to teachers. With this as a backdrop, it is understandable that many are choosing to leave the profession. This is not a reflection on them, but rather on the nation that is allowing it to happen.
Teachers, you are our inspiration and our hope. You nurture the flames of our democracy. You literally save lives. You work miracles every day. Your resourcefulness, resilience, and creativity are boundless. We saw it during the heart of the pandemic. And we see it now. It is all the more reason you should not be taken for granted.
Dear readers, how many of you can close your eyes and be transported to a classroom from your past? Do you see a favorite teacher? Hear that word of encouragement or hard truth that shaped the course of your life? Teachers are the winds that propel our children’s sails forward. They are the North Stars that help guide us all.
I apologize if this reads as a bit trite. I can imagine red ink on the page from some of my previous English teachers marking my excesses. Sadly, those teachers are all now long gone. But in me, as in my classmates, as in all of you, the work of our teachers lives on.
We cannot thank our teachers enough. Each day the gifts they have given us are renewed. We should do everything we can to protect them and value them. A lot of this work must be done at the ballot box, but it can also be accomplished through words of encouragement and support.
To all the teachers out there: thank you.

Wow. That’s a nice piece. Thanks.
LikeLike
Dear Diane,
Even as my dear wife–retired music teacher of as many as 700 students at a time–is baking a Thanksgiving pie downstairs, with the aroma wafting up to my loft, where I type to you–only this dear, dear tribute from a man I admire–Dan Rather, could take my attention away from going downstairs to “inspect” the pie and the progress.
Seriously–this is a wonderful tribute to the most wonderful people in the world. It was my life’s great honor to represent for a decade the 5000 teachers of the Columbus Public Schools. It was also my great honor to teach several thousand of them over a 20-year period in three different school districts.
And let me say this: I don’t think American democracy–always incomplete and challenged–can continue without good public schools that do what I was said to have done by one of my students–“Mr. Burgess: You taught us to think!” Self-government, by whatever name, cannot exist or last unless young people are taught to think–to separate facts from fiction.
Thank you, Dan! Thank you, Diane!
LikeLike
America should be thankful for its public schools and teachers, and most Americans are thankful for the work that educators do. Most Americans do not believe the propaganda campaign that has been launched against teachers to fuel the unaccountable privatization of public services movement. Reasonable parents do not worry about teachers as “groomers,” agents of “Wokeness,” promoters of CRT or anti-American. There is little truth to what right wing extremists are attempting to present as an actual concern.
What is repulsive is that teachers are being bullied and insulted by those on the right. NYSUT recently launched a Peer Support Line to help teachers that are being harassed or threatened. This is a symptom of our anti-democratic times.
Thanks to Dan Rather for his kind words about America’s hard-working, dedicated and at times endangered teachers. America owes them a debt of gratitude. Teachers are our unsung heroes.
LikeLike
aka rt– “Most Americans are thankful for the work that educators do.”– this is confirmed by the PDK poll, which shows that the large majority of parents to current K12 pubsch students– regardless of their opinion of the nation’s pubschsystem—continue to ‘grade’ their children’s teachers A/B, as they have every year for decades.
LikeLike
The theofasist MAGA RINOs that control Red States have borrowed a page from Mao’s Cultural Revolution where bare-foot, illiterate, peasant farmers watched a few videos to learn how to be a surgeon and then were allowed to start cutting up patients.
At the same time, the real doctors and surgeons along with successful businessmen, the college educated, scientists, teachers, were being tortured and condemned by mobs of adolescents, Mao’s Red Guard.
The PLA (People’s Liberation Army) stayed in their bases and did nothing to stop that insanity until Mao ordering them to do it, ending his Cultural Revolutoin, years later.
Then Mao ordered millions of Red Guard members (those teenagers) to labor camps to get them off the streets.
LikeLike
In addition to reminding us that Dan Rather was likely the last real journalist to ever read the national news to us, he reminds us all that teaching is the noblest of callings and a profession to be nurtured and honored. Except in this country.
LikeLike
Thank you, Dan. A beautiful and so needed tribute to teachers and the profession. We need the voices that must support the work and worth of our teachers to speak up, speak out, write, text, call- Please do not take teachers for granted. They are lifelines for our children.
LikeLike
Thanks for your comment. Raw Story posted a recent article by Thom Hartmann that connects the GOP putting public schools on its hit list (the latest example- Mike Pompeo’s labeling of Rand Weingarten) and the descent into fascism.
LikeLike
“We saw it during the heart of the pandemic”
Only to have teachers, who valiantly put up with so much during the pandemic, attacked when NAEP scores dropping 5 and 7 points in ELA and Math, which because these are 500-point exams, are declines of 1 percent and 1.4 percent, respectively. Countless breathless articles were written by “journalists” in name only and by windup toys for oligarchs at think tanks where thinking tanks about how these tiny blips were signs of Armageddon. And what this shows is that these people utterly disregard teachers, are predisposed to use them as the butts of political arguments, and willfully choose not to bother to learn anything about the subjects they pontificate on.
Unlike Mr. Rather. Thank you, Dan.
LikeLike
They don’t bother to learn the truth because they are completely focussed on producing tabloid trash for their masters (the people who pay them their salaries as “journalists”)
LikeLike
Thank you for pointing that out, Bob. I was incensed by recent WaPo ‘reportage’ by Hannah Natanson, who spent the 1st 1/2 of her article on sky-is-falling narrative larded with clickbait verbiage like “scores plunged,” “confirming our worst fears,” et al. There was zero acknowledgment of the relatively-small % drop in NAEP—all re-framed in phony CREDO-type “# of weeks of instruction lost,” & emphasis on “not since the ‘90s(!),” which ignores the tiny incremental pace at which those scores improve.
And it was solely about amount of instruction in-person vs remote, i.e., geared to once again kick up furor over certain red-states’ early reopenings vs blue states’ or cities’ longer spells on remote. You had to read ‘below the fold’ to get that there are lots more covid factors potentially affecting those scores, & studies on teasing them out are underway.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged this on Politicians Are Poody Heads.
LikeLike
Once again I am delighted by the title of your blog. This time I added it to favorites & plan to read there.
LikeLike
Thank you. I inherited this blog from a friend who was known as Zorbear, who sadly died several years ago, and in his honor, I keep the blog going.
But yes, as Zorbear named it, politicians are indeed poodyheads. Or, at least, way too many of them.
LikeLike
We teachers must be considered what we are, educated professionals, and nothing more, nothing less. We’re not heroes who never sleep, eat, or use restrooms. We’re not heroes who dash gallantly into burning buildings to save lives. We’re not heroes who can overcome any obstacles our rigged economy throws at our students. We’re also not lowly technical support for online platforms. We’re not babysitters or prison guards. We’re not hired to clean classrooms or serve breakfast and lunch. We’re professionals doing an important job. That’s all. Tech moguls should stop being disrespectful. The media should stop alternating between being worshipful and contemptuous. Legislators should stop meddling. Thankfulness is good. Just that, and let us teach.
LikeLike
Methinks that Dan Rather has been reading Diane Ravitch.
Cuz he is waaaay more informed than the average journalist on matters of education.
Even waay more informed than the average education journalist.
LikeLike
Once they’re off the payroll, they’re no longer under the control of the corporations that print or broadcast them. After all, it’s not reform; it’s a hostile, corporate takeover.
LikeLike
Dan Rather was telling the truth before he left the payroll (eg, about Dumbya going AWOL), which is what got him fired.
https://ew.com/article/2015/12/29/dan-rather-cbs-news-firing/
.
And the folks who change their tune after they leave the payroll were never real journalists to begin with.
LikeLike
MainstreamJournalism is in crisis in the US, which, not incidentally, is also why our country is in crisis.
These folks are more focussed on how many Twitter followers they have than actual news.
LikeLike
I can accept that as true, to be sure.
LikeLike
Rather screwed up in relying on documents of dubious authenticity (although they were never definitively proved fake), but the basic story Rather told was true and had actually been well documented by others.
Army Colonel Gerald Lechliter about George W. Bush:
“His commander’s connivance at ensuring Bush paid no penalty for his flagrant violation of regulatory requirements for attendance at training and taking a flight physical in no way excuse Bush’s disgraceful, selfish behavior.
In the final analysis, the record clearly and convincingly proves he did not fulfill the obligation he incurred when he enlisted in the Air National Guard and completed his pilot training, despite his honorable discharge. He clearly shirked the duty he undertook in 1968 upon enlistment and in 1969 upon completion of his flight training at Moody AF Base
We have not yet heard a satisfactory explanation by the President for his abandoning a profession he purportedly loved passionately … As a self-proclaimed “wartime president,” this President owes the U.S. public, especially the military and veterans, no less. He certainly cannot rely on his military record to answer these questions.”
LikeLike
Recently, Reshma Sarijani at CNN’s website described why Whitner won in Mich.
The journalist didn’t link the win to teachers but, the connection is evident. About 75% of teachers are women. Teaching is the career path that has provided the most women with financial independence and female teachers’ salaries are essential to families. Whitner’s messaging about the economy was compelling. She made the point that the price of parenthood is the ultimate economic issue. Parents’ rights to reproductive choice is an economic issue.
LikeLike
Read Frank McCourt’s bio at Wikipedia to understand what the axis of the religious right, economic libertarians and the GOP have in mind for the people of the U.S.
LikeLike
In my experience with teaching and teachers, I find that, in the balance, teachers are giving, intelligent, and humble. They typically live modest lives dedicated to those they serve despite the disdain they receive from the ignorant in our culture. The lunatics who decry teaching lack these traits and therefore, an appreciation for what this noble profession has provided throughout human history. I hope many in the Democratic Party read Dan Rather’s words and and make the necessary course correction that is required to uplift and support our teachers.
LikeLike