Florida has a large teacher shortage, about 10,000 at last count. Under the tutelage of Jeb Bush, the Florida Legislature has made testing and privatization the centerpiece of state education policy, while treating public schools and their teachers as enemies for almost 20 years. Florida holds public schools to strict accountability, based on test scores, but imposes no accountability for the religious schools that get vouchers, and showers state money on charters. The Legislature seems to be intent on replacing public schools with charters (half of which operate for-profit) and vouchers and replacing teachers with computers.
This teacher from Polk County has had enough.
Shanna L. Fox writes:
Stand Up and Fight – An Open Letter of Resignation
There is no business model that can fix education. Students are not products and services that can be quantified. They are living, breathing human beings and their complexity cannot be reduced to cells on a spreadsheet.
Each child comes with their own set of needs, strengths, and abilities. Teachers must be provided the freedom to address those in the way that they professionally know is best based on their training and education.
My expertise is in a Language Arts classroom, so this is what I see most clearly. Students can analyze the hell out of a text. But testing has chipped away at the time teachers have to help their students write to inspire, write to express, write to create, write to change the world. Because what matters, in today’s education system, is one single way of writing. The thing is, our students are whole people, and this only provides them a chance to show a tiny sliver of who they are.
It’s not only Language Arts, though. This toxic testing nightmare has stripped students of the opportunity to foster their creativity in every single subject area. Children are being denied the right to express themselves in their own unique ways. They yearn for the chance to be artistic and imaginative, to be inspired and inspire others, and to innovate and build and solve. They are capable of more than simply working toward a test score. They deserve more.
And it is time for me to stand up and fight for them and the profession I love.
After twenty years, the decision to resign did not come easily. In fact, it has taken me two months to process and collect my thoughts and to muster up the courage to share them here.
Leaving my stable, secure career as a classroom teacher was risky. I was willing to risk everything because giving it all up feels like freedom in comparison to the restriction in which I was living.
My decision to walk away was not impulsive. It was years in the making. I almost walked away last year. I almost walked away two years ago. When I finally gained the courage, it wasn’t the administration, the school, or the students. And it certainly wasn’t my wonderful colleagues. None of those things drove me away. Instead, I was battle weary from years of working in a broken system. And honestly, I could not face another testing season.
I thought this transition would be more difficult than it has been. I thought I would be devastated and depressed. But I haven’t been. Now, I realize why. The truth is, I have been grieving the loss of my profession for years. I was grieving the time I used to have to foster meaningful relationships with my students. I was grieving a time when I was trusted to teach well, based on my training and knowledge. I was grieving a time when student creativity was valued over a test score.
But that simply isn’t the reality anymore.
Over the past six years, I changed grade levels, campuses, and roles. I even returned to the school that felt like “home” with the people who I consider family. I searched tirelessly for the thing that would reignite my passion for teaching and renew my sense of hope for the future of the public school system. No matter how hard I tried, I just couldn’t find it.
And I’m not alone. This has been called a silent strike – teachers exiting the profession prematurely or retiring early. But I, for one, will not leave silently. Although I can no longer work within this broken system, I will stand and fight from where I am now. I will work to fix it.
I am not writing to encourage others to leave teaching. This was a personal, individual decision that I made to preserve my physical, mental, and emotional health. But if you do decide to walk away, as I did, please do not be silent. If you’ve already exited or retired early, for your very own unique reasons, please speak up. This shouldn’t be a silent strike. It should be the loudest protest of all time because speaking up for public education is speaking up for our children and, quite frankly, for the foundation of our democracy.
To my colleagues who continue to work for change within their classroom walls, I am standing by your side. I support you. I know you are doing what is best for your students, even with mounting pressures, longer task lists than ever before, and mandates upon mandates. I applaud your strength and dedication. I can’t wait to meet Bella’s amazing teachers during her upcoming journey as a public school student. I hope they are just like you.
To my former students, you are the reason I stayed for twenty years. As a teacher, I learned so much from you. And now, I marvel at your continued success, your ability to achieve your dreams, and your capacity to tackle the obstacles of life. I was proud of you then, and I am proud of you now – every single day.
To the Polk Education Association, I thank you for your tireless efforts to quell the overwhelming tide of negativity. I know that you fight tooth and nail for every single right, benefit, and dollar that PCPS employees get. I am proud to have been a member of the union. I may not be working from the inside anymore. But I will be here, battling right alongside you. After all, you’re the ones who taught me how.
I’ll be honest. When I was a Polk County Public Schools employee, I didn’t take a stand each time there was an opportunity to do so. But I know that I did not take this career risk to sit on the sidelines and watch.
I’m standing now.
I am standing for our students.
I am standing for our teachers.
I am standing for public education.
In solidarity,
Shanna R. Fox

Small correction: Florida, like every other state, doesn’t have a teacher shortage. It has a teacher exodus. As Peter Greene points out, just because you can’t find a Ferrari for a buck fifty doesn’t mean there is a shortage of Ferraris.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It has a teacher exodus.
Spot on, Dienne!
And Ms. Fox: My feelings exactly. Thank you. At some point, one just can’t do this crap anymore. It’s destructive.
LikeLike
A Ferrari for Fifty Bucks
Ferrari for Fifty
And teacher for twenty
The “shortage” is shifty
Cuz “paltry” means “plenty”
LikeLiked by 1 person
exactly, exactly
LikeLike
Brilliant (as usual), dienne77!!
& the whole “teacher shortage”–ahem, exodus–is an oligarchical, rotten legislative-made crisis–made by the state legislators (& this, all over the country) & oligarchs, & brought to schools near you by…
ALEC.
(BTW, Comcast just withdrew from ALEC. ‘Bout time.)
LikeLike
I hear you, Shanna Fox, and empathize.
Godspeed.
LikeLike
There is a bit more on Shanna’s process of leave-taking and stats on the number of teachers who are leaving. Shanna, I hope you have some flexibility and some desire to continue teaching in a public school, if not in Florida, then some other state. Florida has become one the worst, but many others are only marginally better.
https://www.theledger.com/news/20190524/teacher-resigns-pleads-to-board-to-fix-toxic-testing-nightmare
LikeLike
I meet teachers that are calling it quits here in Florida all the time. I often go to garage sales looking for books for my grandson, and I run into teachers that are liquidating their stock. Teachers here are tired of the demand of the job including large classes and spending their own money on classroom materials. When these teachers leave, they even bring the Elmer’s glue they bought with their own money. Last weekend I met a bright young woman that had accepted a position as a care coordinator at a major hospital instead of returning the classroom in August. She mentioned she was tired of the difficult working conditions and the unwillingness of administration to do anything about it. She also said that having to pay so much of her salary into benefits made her realize she could do better somewhere else. Her new job pays better, has better benefits and is less stressful. Florida is disinvesting in public schools, and many teachers are seeking better opportunities.
LikeLike
I forwarded this article and sent it to Senator ‘rock head’ Niemeyer [R-IN] and Representative Chyung [D-In].
……………………
Dear Senator Niemeyer and Representative Chyung,
This teacher who was ‘fed up and couldn’t take it any longer’ is speaking for many. I am retired and I am speaking up. Stop the worthless testing that is draining all creativity and love of learning from the classroom. Stop the vouchers, private charters and virtual schools that drain money from public schools and do no better, and often much worse than public schools. Stop telling teachers how to do their jobs. They are the experts and they demand to be heard.
Read what this teacher says. She is living in Florida but what she speaks rings out around this whole United States of America. Politicians are not funding public schools and Indiana has a teacher shortage. You politicians are the reasons for the shortage. [Thank you Representative Chris Chyung. I know you are working to get more money into public schools. You are running against a GOP wave of ignorance.]
Quote: I am not writing to encourage others to leave teaching. This was a personal, individual decision that I made to preserve my physical, mental, and emotional health. But if you do decide to walk away, as I did, please do not be silent. If you’ve already exited or retired early, for your very own unique reasons, please speak up. This shouldn’t be a silent strike. It should be the loudest protest of all time because speaking up for public education is speaking up for our children and, quite frankly, for the foundation of our democracy.
Sincerely,
Carol Ring [retired teacher]
Schererville, IN 46375
LikeLike
He reads every email. I doubt it. This is an automated response.
…………………..
Thank you for taking the time to contact me. Your communication is important. Due to the high volume of e-mails I receive, I may not be able to respond immediately but I do see every email.
Your comments help guide me in the legislative process and I value your communication.
Senator Rick Niemeyer
Indiana State Senate
Senator.Niemeyer@iga.in.gov
LikeLike
Reminds me of the quote from Kostantin Josef Jirecek:
“We, the unwilling, led by the unknowing, are doing the impossible for the ungrateful. We have done so much, for so long, with so little, we are now qualified to do anything with nothing.”
This hung on the wall in my room when times were not so good (I thought at the time), but now the times are magnitudes of ten times worse.
LikeLiked by 1 person
and the quote could be clearly modified to: ” We are now EXPECTED to do anything with nothing.”
LikeLike
TAGO, ciedie!!!
&, Susan, we had a poster of that quote up in the office of one of the schools I taught at. (‘Cause I was lucky & had great principals!!)
Unfortunately, my constant brushes with adminimals were ALL of our special ed. admins.—both directors & coordinators (I won’t dignify them by capitalizing their “titles”)–which I further explain in my comment below.
LikeLike
So true…
LikeLike
Or there’s this rough-hewn version I found posted on many a cubicle wall when in corporate work ’70’s-’80’s: “It’s hard to soar like an eagle when you’re surrounded by turkeys.”
LikeLike
I had that one up as well…
LikeLike
What a BEAUTIFUL letter of resignation. I understand. I retired over a quarter of a century ago. I LOVED teaching but could not stand the politics. When one is told their work is far superior to anything seen by North Central evaluators, takes his students to Ball State University and is told by the head of the Music Education department that many of the college students would find it difficult to do [academically] what one’s high school students just demonstrated and is pushed out of the high school by a principal who had just been fired from an adjoining town and the teacher is pushed out of the high school because he dared to question a move which the ENTIRE department heads of the school had voted against but the principal had approved. When a superintendent removes a person from a supervisory position because of similar disputes between the person in question who has had teachers from all over the top of his state plus many from an adjoining state come to view the work of his teachers, finds that the superintendent in question who plays politics with the school board and finds his administrators views distasteful to the “regime”, then it is time to get out.
These kinds of things, which Ms Foxx writes about – as well as so VERY many others of our best teachers SHOULD give the nation pause. Sadly the moneyed interests have, and use, their power to magnify their greed for money and our nation loses out.
I am so VERY deeply concerned about the nation, and indeed the world, our children will inherit when in so very many ways money has become more important than people.
Soon there will be a pile of money, held by the few, and with climate change et al few people. God help us.
LikeLike
These are the sorts of highly competent people that dumbsters like Duncan and Devos have been bashing.
I’d like to see writing by any one of the clowns running education into the ground for the past twenty years that comes anywhere close to the eloquence and insight of this piece.
We are losing something as a society that we will never get back.
Thank you Shanna for your tireless service to our young people and I wish you luck in your future endeavors. You have already made a huge difference.
LikeLike
Who are the ones directly responsible for the hell that the teachers are put through?
If you guessed GAGA Good German administrators*, who not wishing to damage their own little personal career and fiefdom, mandate the implementation of educational malpractices, you are correct.
But, but, they’d lose their jobs if they don’t!
Yep, better to keep your job even when it involves harming the students and teachers!
Those GAGA Good German administrators* deserve our contempt and scorn for not making a stand against those maligned educational malpractice policy mandates. They put their own well-being and comfort before the interests of the students. Unethical and unjust administrators* causing harm and violence to the very being of the students. Sad, very effin sad! From an astute French philosopher:
“Should we therefore forgo our self-interest? Of course not. But it [self-interest] must be subordinate to justice, not the other way around. . . . To take advantage of a child’s naivete. . . in order to extract from them something [test scores, personal information] that is contrary to their interests, or intentions, without their knowledge [or consent of parents] or through coercion [state mandated testing], is always and everywhere unjust even if in some places and under certain circumstances it is not illegal. . . . Justice is superior to and more valuable than well-being or efficiency; it cannot be sacrificed to them, not even for the happiness of the greatest number [quoting Rawls]. To what could justice legitimately be sacrificed, since without justice there would be no legitimacy or illegitimacy? And in the name of what, since without justice even humanity, happiness and love could have no absolute value?. . . Without justice, values would be nothing more than (self) interests or motives; they would cease to be values or would become values without worth.”—Comte-Sponville [my additions]
*Administrators should more rightly be called adminimals:
Adminimal: A spineless creature formerly known as an administrator and/or principal. Adminimals are known by/for their brown-nosing behavior in kissing the arses of those above them in the testucation hierarchy. These sycophantic toadies (not to be confused with cane toads, adminimals are far worse to the environment) are infamous for demanding that those below them in that hierarchy kiss the adminimal’s arse on a daily basis, having the teachers simultaneously telling said adminimals that their arse and its byproducts don’t stink. Adminimals are experts at Eichmanizing their staff through using techniques of fear and compliance inducing mind control. Beware, any interaction with an adminimal will sully one’s soul forever unless one has been properly intellectually vaccinated.
LikeLike
Duane E Swacker: “Adminimals are experts at Eichmanizing their staff through using techniques of fear and compliance inducing mind control. ”
I’ve had a number of them in my career. They want to be bowed down to yet they do nothing to make our teaching jobs better.
With one principal, I’d smile and say how great everything was and go back to my music room and kick myself for lying. I wanted the job.
One new principal got furious when a teacher spoke up and gave her opinion. [We’d gotten used to expressing what we thought on issues.] That ended anyone ever speaking their mind again.
One principal micromanaged everything. Teachers collectively wrote a total of 17 pages telling what was wrong and nothing changed. She’d turn the school over if one parent complained about anything.
One principal had the janitor clean out teacher’s closets and throw things away during summer break. She didn’t like messy closets.
One manipulated the superintendent into thinking she was fantastic. Teachers were depressed and most of the students also were. Fortunately she got her doctorate degree in education and the teachers gave her a glowing recommendation to get rid of her. The music teacher before me sued this principal on her evaluation and won. She got a full year’s salary from the district.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“she got her doctorate degree in education and the teachers gave her a glowing recommendation to get rid of her”
That’s called the Peter Principle: upward failure.
I used to work as an engineer and witnessed this many times. It’s virtually the only way you can get rid of incompetents. It makes your life easier not to have to work directly with clowns but unfortunately, it has the decidedly negative effect of promoting people to the top who go on to make very bad decisions with major ramifications, leading to disasters like those with the Boeing 737 max
LikeLike
And the special ed. adminimals are expert at destroying their clientele (they are the worst) by actually interfering with teachers/good special education practices, by helping to cut corners for the school districts (saves them $$$–more money for which to pay those sometimes 6-figure $alarie$ of…the sp.ed. adminimals!!)promoting the utterly useless, going-round-in-circles* “Response to Intervention,” or R.T.I. as it’s known (should be called NRTNI~No Response to No Intervention), just to whittle down the #s of kids who do need sp.ed.
These adminimals promote inclusion, & some even promote charter school groups! (e.g., Advance ILL-Annoy & ILL-Annoy Stand on Children). They are too ignorant to even think that, were there a charter school take-over, they would be out of their jobs!
In fact, what began as a good bill (the IL G.A. just closed its General Assembly for the summer) had an amendment tacked on–last minute, & vote on Memorial Day, giving us no opportunity to fill out opponent Witness Slips–that stated that school districts must use RTI (not “may,” but must, or an MTSS (Multi-Tiered Support System), which is a social-emotional component & is not needed for all students, so the schools then “must use RTI. (&, actually, RTI is a component of MTSS, so there’s no choice.)
Adminimals, indeed, Senor Swacker!
LikeLiked by 1 person
To Ms. Fox-
Your resignation letter makes my resolve even greater to stay. Just finished Year 35 as a Duval County Public Schools (primarily) Latin teacher. World Language students ‘only’ have to take a District End-of-Course Exam, not the ridiculous FSA and related foolishness. Still, the unnecessary disruption—primarily in lost instruction—is enough for me to stay in this struggle & fight. Please know that we will continue until the testing racket stops. All the best to you. With love and respect, Kelley Ranch
LikeLike
To SDP comment above: RE your comparison w/Boeing MAX–brings to mind the saying, “it’s easier to fix a child (or is it to help/nurture/love/do the right things for a child-?) than to fix an adult.” & America’s solution to the latter is…the U.S. criminal justice system, i.o.e.
prison.
LikeLike
I meant i.o.w.=in other words.
LikeLike
Student stress results in teen suicides and violence- evidenced by reports from psychologists and teachers, by statistical correlations and, by the student chant, “mental health”, in response to the recent Colorado high school shooting.
To bring justice down upon those responsible for high stakes testing is to serve humanity.
LikeLike
I have seen everything she said in Ohio. I want to add this. As an advocate for gifted children this testing is creating a generation of gifted adults who passed the tests but have become unable to innovate and create. Our country will pay for accountability abusing children.
LikeLike