Recently we learned that the principal of the Bay Tech Charter School in Oakland gave himself a generous severance package of $450,000, then left for Australia.
Bay Tech is a Gulen School, connected to the reclusive Imam Fethullah Gulen, who lives in seclusion in Pennsylvania while overseeing one of the largest charter chains in the U.S. You can tell a Gulen school by the disproportionate number of Tirkish people on its board and teaching staff. The repressive autocrat Erdogan in Turkey wants to extradite Gulen, claiming j
He fomented a failed rebellion against the government. Critics of Gulen believe he uses the money he extracts from his charter chain to subsidize his movement. I don’t know much about Turkish politics, but I wonder why Turkish citizens are taking control of American public schools, whose first obligation is to teach the duties of American citizenship.
California taxpayers are very generous indeed to those who work in the charter sector.
Now it turns out that the school has been forcing students to pay for their graduation gowns, which is illlegal, and requiring parents to buy tickets for the graduation ceremonies, which is also illegal.
You see, it’s simple. In California, laws are written to regulate public schools, not charter schools. The most powerful lobby in the state is the California Charter Schools Association, and it fights any regulation or accountability or even prohibition of conflicts of interest. And to top it off, Governor Jerry Brown vetoes any legislation that might hold charters accountable or block conflicts of interest. So charters are free not to hold open meetings, free to keep their records secret, free to give contracts to relatives, because Governor Brown protects them from transparency.
What a sad stain on an otherwise great legacy.

What exactly do you mean by a sad stain on an otherwise great legacy? What is the great legacy??
LikeLike
He has been a great governor with the exception of charter apologizing. He is THE environmental conservationist governor. He fought mandatory sentencing. He looked out for immigrants. He successfully fought to fund public schools with Proposition 30. The charter accountability vetoes were completely out of character.
LikeLike
Except for the fact that he started two charter schools when mayor of Oakland. One for the arts. One for the military. He protects charters against any regulation or accountability.
LikeLike
In related charter ripoff news: From Bob Braun’s Facebook page not his blog:
THE $10 MILLION CHARTER SCHOOL BAMBOOZLE–The Lady Liberty Academy Charter School in Newark, now closed, was struggling since its 2003 opening–but that didn’t stop Chris Christie, Cory Booker, Christopher Cerf and others from pouring state and local funds into the privately-operated, publicly funded school–a school just boarded up last week. Now state and local officials are scrambling to avoid explaining how the school won a $10 million loan from the state. It’s money channeled through a private real estate developer who has managed to help out a religious organization with $200,000 in annual rent. And none of the money will go to the Newark public school children who need the funds despite an auction of its publicly-purchased assets–an auction the state education department won’t explain and Roger Leon’s Newark school administration won’t discuss. Lots of money at stake–and lots of secrets. But some of those secrets will be revealed next week. Stay tuned. It could get ugly. End quote
The charter school scandals never end as they bleed funds and resources from the real public schools.
LikeLike
CEO Dr. Caprice Young the “Education Reformer” and founding CEO of CCSA resigned as of June 30, 2018. Dr. Young’s husband Mark Dierking is on the SV Planning Commission and has facilitated a sweetheart deal for Magnolia Science Academy #1 of Redevelopment land/Funds at #ResedaTownCenter via scab Councilman Bob Blumenfield who also sends his aids to testify for the Magnolia Schools when they go for renewal (even though they get a denial) This sweetheart land deal groundbreaking was done 2 weeks before Caprice’s departure and final flipping the bird at public education. These land scams by the Gulen Movement go from the East Coast to the West Coast http://gulencharterschoolsusa.blogspot.com/2018/08/bob-blumenfield-and-reseda-town-center.html
LikeLike
I too have criticism of the legacy of Governor Brown. However, I believe it is getting ahead of the facts before the trial to relate that the Principal Hayri Hatipoglu of Bay Tech Oakland charter school was gulity of fraud. There has not been an arrest or possibly even a warrant.
Another thing is there is a possibility that the governing board members that are claiming the former school principal is guilty of fraud are Gulen followers. Former Bay Tech principal Hatipoglu emailed the newspaper, The East Bay Express, that broke the story of the missing principal and the missing money. The principal in his email that the charge of fraud is a lie by the followers of Gulen at the school.
In this complicated story the Oakland School Board is having an investigation take place but the Board is not the FBI and does not have power to hold individuals responsible if they lie about their Gulen connection. Fraud has been exposed in other Gulen connected charter schools but Gulen followers continue to open their charter schools. There is even one open on a military base, Davis-Monthan Air Base by the former principal of Bay Tech charter school.
I believe what is needed is Congress to hold a hearing into the Gulen followers connection to over 180 charter schools in 26 states.
LikeLike
“. . . American public schools, whose first obligation is to teach the duties of American citizenship.”
Can’t agree. That is at best a tertiary obligation. The first obligation is to provide a teaching and learning environment that will enable a student to grow and thrive in his/her being as described in the fundamental purpose of public education as taken from the state constitutions that give a rationale: “The purpose of public education is to promote the welfare of the individual so that each person may savor the right to life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness, and the fruits of their own industry.” (From Ch. 1 “Purpose of Public Education” of my book “Infidelity to Truth: Education Malpractice in American Public Education”.)
LikeLike
The reason that public schools were funded throughout their history was to teach children the skills and knowledge needed to become a citizen. To vote, to serve on a jury, to make good decisions for themselves, their families, their communities, to participate in public decision making. If that is not their purpose, then you just made the case for vouchers.
LikeLike
Do you have sources for your statement of the rationale of public education? I use the state constitution rationales. What about your sources do you believe make them have more force of authority than the state constitutions?
Be those questions as they are, I’m not sure how you get from point A-a statement of the purpose of public education as delineated in the various state constitutions that give a rationale to point V-making the case for vouchers. Please explain.
LikeLike
My sources are my Ph.D. in the history of American education.
The Northwest Ordinance of 1787, enacted by the Congress of the Confederation of the United States:
Article III. Religion, morality, and knowledge, being necessary to good government and the happiness of mankind, schools and the means of education shall forever be encouraged. The utmost good faith shall always be observed towards the Indians; their lands and property shall never be taken from them without their consent; and, in their property, rights, and liberty, they shall never be invaded or disturbed, unless in just and lawful wars authorized by Congress; but laws founded in justice and humanity, shall from time to time be made for preventing wrongs being done to them, and for preserving peace and friendship with them.
Also, Horace Mann, Henry Barnard, other founding fathers of public education.
Dewey was not yet born, and you are citing his philosophy.
LikeLike
I would argue that Article III supports both of our contentions. So then how does one sort those contentions out. And I’d contend that the two stated purposes are not either necessarily at odds with each other. I would just place the development of the individual as first priority.
And I say that is why/where I have gone to the states’ constitutions. 20 of the 25 (the other 25 give no rationale) that give a rationale give the purpose as for the benefit of the individual with the second most cited (and only other reason cited) for the benefit of the continuance of the state.
Many of the constitutional sources I use are pre-Dewey. Is there something wrong with Dewey’s philosophy? What parts do you find wrong? I’m not sure why you think my citing the state’s constitutions have anything to do with Dewey’s philosophy.
On a side note. I see that the US has followed that article to the T, eh. Just ask the Native Americans.
LikeLike
Duane,
I am a historian of American education. I received a Ph.D. from Columbia University. The rationale used for public funding of public school was that it was essential to train up citizens to maintain and better our democracy. There were other rationales as well, some religious, some economic. But the bottom line was that we would not survive as a nation if we allowed ignorance to be perpetuated.
Thomas Jefferson, letter to Charles Yancey, 1816: Monticello Jan. 6. 16.
if a nation expects to be ignorant & free, in a state of civilisation, it expects what never was & never will be. the functionaries of every government have propensities to command at will the liberty & property of their constituents. there is no safe deposit for these but with the people themselves; nor can they be safe with them without information. where the press is free and every man able to read, all is safe.
Thomas Jefferson, 1787:
The people are the only censors of their governors: and even their errors will tend to keep these to the true principles of their institution. To punish these errors too severely would be to suppress the only safeguard of the public liberty. The way to prevent these irregular interpositions of the people is to give them full information of their affairs thro’ the channel of the public papers, & to contrive that those papers should penetrate the whole mass of the people. The basis of our governments being the opinion of the people, the very first object should be to keep that right; and were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter. But I should mean that every man should receive those papers & be capable of reading them.
From: The Works, vol. 5 (Correspondence 1786-1789) (Thomas Jefferson)
524px thomas jefferson by rembrandt peale 1805 cropped
From: The Works, vol. 5 (Correspondence 1786-1789) (Thomas Jefferson)
By: Thomas Jefferson
Jefferson writes from Paris to Edward Carrington, whom Jefferson sent as a delegate to the Continental Congress from 1786 to 1788, on the importance of a free press to keep government in check. He concludes that if he had to choose between “a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter”
Many newspapers quote the first part of Jefferson’s famous statement about the importance of newspapers, but they leave out his admonition that newspapers are vital only when people know how to read. He connected the ability to read and discern and act with the survival of democracy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
First, I know your credentials. I have not doubted your knowledge. And I appreciate what you cite here. That is more of what I am looking for as the reasoning behind your thinking.
Yes, I agree that most have only read/heard about only about the first part of the first Jefferson you quoted. What I find interesting is his last thought “where the press is free and every man able to read, all is safe” and how it doesn’t appear to hold true, at least with the Main Stream Press, hmmm, or even social media. As no one can foretell the future Jefferson couldn’t have imagined the state of the “press” these days and how it has evolved since his days-not necessarily for the good/better, but not all for the bad/worse.
And I agree that an educated population is vital to the survival of our democratic republic (it’s not really a democracy per se). I contend that by focusing on the having the individual develop as much as each individual (and parents) chooses (one has to allow for liberty issues of parental rights to a degree) one will get the educated citizenry that is needed to continue this democratic republic/country-not totally discounting the major influence of the media and the pulpit in people’s lives these days.
I sense that you take issue with my emphasis on the individual, that it is some nefarious way to justify vouchers, charters, etc. . . . Well it’s not. If you noticed in my book, it’s all about realizing that the state is discriminating against individuals in its charge through its standards and testing malpractice regime, the main charge being to enable the student to learn to enjoy their rights and liberties as citizens. I believe that my argument can form the basis for an attack on that discrimination, discrimination based on major invalidities and falsehoods. Perhaps were the citizenry truly better educated, better equipped to critically analyze the world around them instead of unquestioningly accepting the status quo of what happens to them (and many do question and/or reject that status quo by dropping out, or not voting, etc. . . ) they would better understand the current abuse of the students in public schools.
LikeLike
“The utmost good faith shall always be observed towards the Indians; their lands and property shall never be taken from them without their consent; and, in their property, rights, and liberty, they shall never be invaded or disturbed, unless in just and lawful wars authorized by Congress; ”
We all know how that turned out.
LikeLike
They should prolly rename that the “Worthless Ordinance of 1787” cuz it was not worth the paper it was printed on.
LikeLike
The Northwest Ordinance decreed that every town should set aside a plot of land for a public school. Nothing about charters or vouchers.
LikeLike
The Strange Case of Caprice Young & the Imam Fetullah Gulen
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Caprice Young is the CEO of the Magnolia Schools charter chain here in California, which are allegedly under the control of an Islamic cleric in exile in Pennsylvania, the Imam Fetulleh Gulen.
In that position, Young has always steadfastly denied any connection of the Magnolia Charter schools, or of herself to the either the Islamic political-religious Gulen Movement operating in Turkey and in the United States, or any ties to to its Islamic cleric leader, the Imam Fetullah Gulen living in the U.S. in exile, or to any internal matters in the country of Turkey.
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“I haven’t seen a connection (between the Magnolia schools and Gulen / Turkey*),” she (Caprice Young) said.
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
For that quote, go here:
http://laschoolreport.com/new-chief-of-troubled-magnolia-ive-done-this-work-before/
… or for another Gulen-connection-denying quote form Ms. Young:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“Absolutely, categorically, Magnolia has nothing to do with the Gulen movement as an institution,” said Caprice Young, Magnolia’s CEO and superintendent.
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
For that quote, go here:
http://www.ocregister.com/articles/schools-707539-magnolia-school.html
However, as a non-Turkish American, Caprice Young sure does tweet a lot — and make a lot of public comments to the press — about about the minutiae of internal Turkish politics, even to the point of drawing a contrast between Magnolia Charter “staff” and those Turkish politicians currently in power whom Young views as not “value(ing) human rights.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“The president of Turkey is busy shooting down Russian planes and smuggling arms to Syria. Doesn’t he have better things to do?” Young asked rhetorically. “The members of my staff are folks who value human rights.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
For that quote, go here:
http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/2016/mar/04/magnolia-charter-schools-caprice-young/
Hmmm … a Khomeini-like Imam-in-exile (who controls over 100 U.S. charter schools, including the Magnolia schools managed by Ms. Young) , the Imam Fetullah Gulen, is attempting a coup in the country of Turkey, with the Imam Gulen’s ultimate goal to impose a brutal Islamic theocracy and dictatorship like the one imposed on neighboring Iran in 1979 … yet Ms. Young prattles on about her and her Magnolia Charter Schools’ staff’s commitment to “human rights,” in a condemnation of human rights violations of those serving in the democratically-elected government that the Imam Gulen — again, Caprice Young’s alleged boss — is now on the verge of overthrowing.
What-ever.
From the comments section on the above article:
http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/2016/mar/04/magnolia-charter-schools-caprice-young/
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Tina Andres ·
CSUF, National University, UCI
“For someone who vehemently denies that her schools are even associated at all with Gulen, Young sure has quite a lot to say about Turkey.
“I suppose it is just a coincidence that the Magnolia schools hire Turkish teachers on VISAs. She literally denied any connected to Gulen charter schools in a school board meeting in CA, saying that she doesn’t know anything about it.
“The jig is up, Caprice. These schools have also charged for more for their building rents to the state of Oklahoma than they have paid.
“This (proliferation of Gulen-controlled charter schools) is a scam and it is being perpetrated in many, many states under multiple names but the connection to Gulen is very clear and easy to find.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
I agree with Ms. Andres.
… as well as with this other commenter:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Thaker Bil ·
Tucson, Arizona
“(Ms. Young stated): ‘The members of my staff are folks who value human rights.’
“Obviously Caprice Young does not keep up on current events. She is a sock puppet for the Gulen-controlled schools and repeats back like a parrot what the Imam Gulen tells her what to say. This is hardly something people that value human rights do when Gulenites ran the parallel state in Turkey. Officials under the control of the Gulen Movement regularly arrest journalists and suppresses freedom of speech.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Also, as a non-Muslim and a non-Turkish person, Young also sure does tweet and write a lot of outrage about “Islamophobia” towards certain Turkish people currently living in the United States. (Tweets BELOW)
Given Ms. Young’s repeated and steadfast denials of any connection between the Magnolia schools and the Islamic Imam Fetullah Gulen, or with Islam, or with the country of Turkey, this tweeting / defending of Islamic Turks of hers — and defending the subjects of these tweets — seems a very odd avocation on her part.
Once again, Ms. Young claims no ties or interest in the Gulen movement that originates in Turkey, but out of the 200 or so countries on Earth, she spends so much time tweeting and talking about Turkey, and Islam … more perhaps than she does about her own country of origin, or her own religious persuasion, whatever that may be …
Weird.
Here are some examples: (NOTE the picture of two Turkish politicians in this first tweet of Ms. Young’s:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Freedom of religion is a core value in the US https://t.co/8y7BGp2qwL @magnoliascience @laschoolreport @edsource @suztach @pcunningham57
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Caprice Young:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
*“Freedom of religion is a core value in the US https://t.co/8y7BGp2qwL @magnoliascience @laschoolreport @edsourc…
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Here’s more of Caprice tweeting away about Turkey and Islam:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Please oppose Islamophobia in all its forms https://t.co/NElGJ4gKEO via @ocweekly
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
CAPRICE YOUNG:
“Please oppose Islamophobia in all its forms.”
https://t.co/NElGJ4gKEO via @ocweekly”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Oh, and here’s Ms. Young tweeting just two years ago, tweeting about internal Turkish politics, and its effects on Turkish people in the United States. (She’s referencing and condemning a U.S. Congressman from Texas who is calling for an investigation of the Gulen charter school conspiracy.)
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“Texas rep does bidding of Turkish Pres = US students suffer. State Rep Investigates Top Charters https://t.co/kM1swIyRRt via @TexasTribune
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
CAPRICE YOUNG:
“Texas rep does bidding of Turkish Pres = US students suffer.”
State Rep Investigates Top Charters
https://trib.it/29zlq08 via @TexasTribune
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Wait, Caprice.
I thought those charter schools of yours had no ties to Turkey of Gulen. Why would any such investigation — one that is “does the bidding of Turkish Pres.” — be o0f any bother to you at all, or cause your “students” to “suffer” … as the claims of your schools’ connections to Turkey and the Imam Gulen are all a hoax perpetrated against your chain of charter schools?
You sure are quite upset about something that you otherwise claim is a total canard.
LikeLike
As shown in her Twitter, Caprice Young apparently did live monitoring of the Friday, July 15, 2016 coup attempted by Gulenists in Turkey — re-tweeting as the coup was happning(!!!) pro-Gulen Congressman Brad Sherman’s tweets cheerleading the Gulentist coup, right when it was looking to succeed, then later posting a mournful tweet when it failed, urging people not let the failed coup “whitewash” the Turkish President Erdogan.
Way more damaging to the charter school industry — and to California’s Magnolia chain of charter schools in particular — is the Twitter account and activity of Caprice Young, the CEO of the Magnolia chain of charter schools . For those who are not aware, Magnolia is the chain of charter schools here in California that has been accused of being under the control of the Islamic Imam Fetullah Gulen and his Gulenist forces, an accusation that Magnolia’s current CEO Caprice Young has denied “categorically” on numerous occasions.
Time and again, Ms. Young has vehemently denied that there was any such Magnolia connection to Gulen or to any part of the Gulenist Islamic cult in Turkey, the group which executed a failed coup to overthrow Turkey’s democratically elected government this past July 15 – 16.
However, you can see (BELOW) that something interesting was going on when the news of the Gulenist coup broke, (again, the goal of this coup being the overthrow of the sitting Prime Minister Erdogan).
At first, it appeared to be a successful coup.
Then, at THAT moment in time — Friday night, July 15 — Caprice Young re-tweeted Gulen ally & U.S. Congressman Brad Sherman’s tweets where Sherman was hoping for the Gulenist coup’s success … AGAIN, ON THE VERY FRIDAY NIGHT (July 15, 2016) THE COUP BEGAN.
Again, Sherman tweeted that was his hoping that the Gulenist coup would be successful, and the the anti-Gulen prime minister Erdogan was deposed, in favor of Gulen forces embedded in the Turkish military.
Go to Ms. Young’s Twitter page here …
… then scroll back back to “July 15” to see the following re-tweets Young made of Congressman Brad Sherman’s cheering on of the coup:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
… and then, the next morning of July 16, after the coup fell apart, and Erdogan re-assumed control of the country, sore loser Sherman whined in this tweet (which Young also re-tweeted) about the coup falling apart, and wished shame upon Erdogan and anyone else who would used the now-failed coup “to white wash Ergodan”:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
The first one of Sherman’s tweets got this snarky response:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
V @vpandey16 Jul 15
@BradSherman @zaidbenjamin
because real democracy starts by kicking out democratically elected leaders????
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
So here you have Ms. Young apparently monitoring and cheering on the Gulenist coup ON THE VERY FRIDAY NIGHT (July 15, 2016) WHEN IT WAS HAPPENING, and at the very moment when it looked like the coup engineered by the Gulenists looked like it might succeed.
Here’s a couple questions that people can ask Ms. Young (or ask anyone) at next Tuesday’s LAUSD Board meeting when the future of the Los Angeles Gulen schools will be discussed?
What the-hell is Caprice Young, the former California Charter Schools Association (CCSA) President and current Magnolia Charter Schools CEO doing keeping track of an ongoing coup in the Middle East country of Turkey as it’s unfolding … when, at the same time, she, Magnolia, and the CCSA all deny any connection to or interest in the fate or politics of that same country, or any connection or interest in the Gulen movement of the Islamic Imam Fetullah Gulen, the architect of the failed coup?
Could California Charter School Association (CCSA) President Jed Wallace, Caprice young, or anyone else at the CCSA please explain or defend this Twitter activity of Ms. Young’s?
(NOTE: Magnolia Charter Schools CEO Caprice Young was the first President of the CCSA when she and others first formed it. Jed Wallace is her successor, so he’d be a good person to whom one can pose this question. As with Donald Trump’s recent troubles, it’s going to be hard for either Caprice or Jed to talk their way out of this one!)
Back to Caprice.
Hmmm … for someone who vehemently claims to have no dog in this Gulen fight, it seems kind of odd of Ms. Young to be apparently spending her Friday night (when the coup began) monitoring this coup in a Middle Eastern country — with the outcome determining the future status or survival of the Gulen movement — and re-tweeting U.S. Congressman Brad Sherman’s tweets cheering on the coup. You know… the same Gulen movement that her charter school chain has no connection whatsoever, as she “categorically, absolutely” claimed in a newspaper article.
C’mon Caprice!
Don’t you got something better to do on a Friday night?
LikeLike
Great work, Jack.
If I can piggyback off this, I’d like to show some clips of an LAUSD Board meeting where the alleged Gulen connection to some LAUSD charter schools — the Magnolia Charter Schools — was discussed.
Also, how do you get to put certain text in italics? What steps allow one to do this?
LAUSD Board Member Monica Garcia, in her past elections, had her campaign bankrolled by the Gulenists and Gulenist allies such as the California Charter Schools Association — and will likely have her future campaigns bankrolled by them as well — so it’s interesting to watch Garcia in this two-years-old LAUSD Board meeting carrying out her Gulenist masters’ marching orders.
The beginning of this video shows the alleged Gulenist connection that Garcia later dismissively refers to as “groups or something”, as an LAUSD lawyer (southern accent) somewhat sheepishly admits that officials and teachers in the Magnolia Science Academy Charter Schools are, in fact, Gulenist cult members.
However, the LAUSD lawyer also makes the incredible claim that such a Gulenist connection — a Gulenist connection which LAUSD’s lawyer readily admits has been DEFINITIVELY PROVEN regarding these LAUSD-authorized charter schools — does not rise to the level that it would mandate the LAUSD BOARD issue a “denial” of an authorization of, nor closing any of these Magnolia Science Academy Charter Schools.
———————————————————
( 00:06 – 00:23 )
( 00:06 – 00:23 )
LAUSD LAWYER: ” We have done some … uhmm … looking into that allegation, and and there is some evidence that some members of Magnolia DO HAVE TIES to the Gulen Movement, but we have not found anything, currently, that that would be grounds for denial.”
—————————————————-
Seriously, THAT’S what you think, Mr. LAUSD Lawyer? Did you get your law degree out of a Crackerjack box? You say that such connections do not merit a “denial”? Seriously, dude? What the-hell kind of legal advice is THAT?
Furthermore, the fact that these Gulen connections WERE EVEN MENTIONED in a public school board meeting enrages the Gulen-backed LAUSD Board Member Monica Garcia no end.
Later on, as soon as Garcia can get the floor, she responds with near hysterics. (at the end of those post)
To quote Shakespeare, “Me thinks the lady doth protest too much.”
Before taking that apoplectic performance in, however, you first have to understand more about the focus of Garcia’s outrage. Pursuant to that end, pay careful attention to the following exchange transcribed below.
LAUSD Board Member Bennett Kayser is asking Jose Cole-Guttierez, the the pro-charter head of LAUSD’s charter division whether or not, and why school boards in other states — and in other California districts — denied Gulen-backed charter schools. He further wants to know if part of that reason for the denials was related to the Gulen connection.
The fox in the henhouse, as it were, Cole-Guttierez disingenuously denies knowing about any Magnolia Charter School applications being denied in other states, or whether those whose charter petitions that WERE denied in California were rejected based on their connection the the Imam Fetulleh Gulen, and to the Gulen movement.
Here’s that back-and-forth:
——————————————————–
( 3:49 – 5:20 )
( 3:49 – 5:20 )
BENNETT KAYSER: “Also, from one of the public speakers, there was a mention of the (Magnolia Science Academy) CMO having applied, or having put in petitions for charter schools in some other states that have been turned down. Is that .. uhh… is that accurate information?”
JOSE COLE-GUTTIEREZ: (flustered by the question) “I can’t … speak … I don’t … from … uhh … ”
BENNETT KAYSER: “And would it be relevant information if it’s … uhh … if it’s alleged?”
JOSE COLE-GUTTIEREZ: “I’m not aware that THIS organization — the California-based Magnolia Science Academies organization — has applied out of state. I AM aware that they have applied in other parts of this state, and we have been in contact with such authorizers, but I cannot speak to out-of-state at this time.”
BENNETT KAYSER: “And the authorizers in other districts, in-state?”
JOSE COLE-GUTTIEREZ: “Yes.”
BENNETT KAYSER: “They’ve accepted or allowed the petitions? Or they’ve turned them down?”
JOSE COLE-GUTTIEREZ: “In the past, there’s been approvals. I know of one in uhhh.. in a different … uhh … county that was recently denied … for a new petition.”
BENNETT KAYSER: “And what was the basis of the denial?”
JOSE COLE-GUTTIEREZ: “I don’t have those findings committed to memory, but I do understand that some of those denials had do with the financial picture … for the school, which is one of the reasons why we have the conditions on these renewals … uhh … as stated.”
(Cole-Guttierrez knows full well that, in addition the the financial concerns, the Gulen connection was a key factor in those charter petitions being denied, but instead of mentioning them, Cole-Guttierez feigns memory loss …
“I don’t have those findings committed to memory.”
Yeah, right. That dodge sounds like something out of Watergate hearings.)
——————————————————–
As to out-of-state charter school denials, while that may be true, Cole-Guttierez knows full well that other Gulen-backed charter groups such as the Horizon Charter Schools have been denied because of their shenanigans related to their connections to Gulen, and their importing teachers from Turkey, using dubious justification for the visas used in these cases, among other reasons.
When it comes to the issue of Magnolia Charter Schools being denied by districts WITHIN California, Cole-Guttierez ducks the question of whether or not the Gulen connection played a role in the denial when he knows full well that the Gulen connection was key to the denials.
This sets the stage for Garcia’s volcanic reaction, and her dismissive, vague reference to the Gulen controversy.
” … (Magnolia charter) people are in groups (related to Gulen) or something.”
Garcia is royally pissed at the idea that any consideration, or even the barest mention should be given to any denial of a Magnolia Charter School elsewhere, or that the district should be ascertaining the reason for those denials (i.e. the connection to the Imam Fetulleh Gulen, and his Islamic cult) or that any of those reasons should be considered — or even mentioned — when deciding whether or not to approve a Magnolia charter school.
Along with the earlier admission by LAUSD’s lawyer that Magnolia officials, administrators, and teachers are, in fact, Gulenist cult members, the above back-and-forth between Cole-Guttierez and Kayser provokes Board Member Garcia to blow a gasket.
Observe Garcia’s anger here.
Garcia furiously calls such comments or conversations related to Gulenists connections “dangerous.”
Really, Ms. Garcia? They’re “dangerous” ? How so, Monica?
Monica never says, but instead trumpets the idea:
How dare you question Magnolia Charters, Inc.? How dare you look into any denials elsewhere or the reasons for the denials? That’s not “material” here, Garcia insists.
————————————-
( 5:20 – 6:36 )
( 5:20 – 6:36 )
MONICA GARCIA: “Board Members, I’m just a little confused, and I’m concerned about this! So WE’VE turned down charters that other people approve, and then people … the County (BOE) approves charters that we’ve turned down! So I am uncomfortable with the notion that what is happening in other jurisdictions is material here: Number One!
“Number Two: I am also uncomfortable, Superintendent, that in every motion that comes to this board, I should ask if you believe that your team is right on the finances, or that you have neglected or denied or ignored the Inspector General’s reports to us!
“So this idea that we’re uncomfortable with something that we really aren’t clear about, but (HERE COMES HER VAGUE, DISMISSIVE GULEN REFERENCE) people are in groups or something … I think this is … in a dangerous place! I am expecting that when you bring us a recommendation, I can disagree with you, but I’m expecting that when you bring us a recommendation, the work has been done, and I am uncomfortable accepting amendments that direct you to do your work!”
—————————————-
Garcia’s in-the-heat-of-the-moment, Gulen-supporting arguments here are asinine, and in fact, would endanger children, and even open up LAUSD to multimillion dollar legal judgments in lawsuits.
She claims that denials elsewhere in the state, or elsewhere out of state — and the reasons for those denials — are not “material” in deciding whether or not the LAUSD School Board should approve those charters?
As Jack would put it … WTF?
For example, if, hypothetically, a proposed charter school authorization —- requested by a charter school corporation, or corporate charter school chain — was denied elsewhere in another California school district, or in another state because of … say … that same charter school’s administration’s improper response to or rampant and illegal mishandling of child abuse perpetrated by the charter school’s, or an inept response to the charter chain’s administrators or teachers… a botched response that later led to millions of dollars of payouts in legal settlements …
… does Garcia REALLY think that LAUSD’s Board should be compelled to ignore such past transgressions or disastrous track record, then go ahead and approve the charter petition anyway, and just hope for the best, and that no kids end up getting molested?
(LAUSD’s insurance carrier would just love such an action, I’m sure.)
Of course, not. She truly blew it here.
Put simply, Garcia, whose campaign for the LAUSD board was bankrolled by Gulen and the Gulen-supporting California Charter Schools Association, is under direct orders from her Gulenist masters to do her utmost so that the Gulen connection to Magnolia Science Academies be kept out of any LAUSD Board Meetings or any LAUSD documentation. If any mention does occur, she has to throw out disinformation and hysterical anger to confuse and squelch any such discussion.
Having her campaigns for school boards bankrolled by Gulenist entities, or by Gulenist allies such as the California Charter Schools Association, and furthermore, having been feted on luxury junkets to Turkey, ones paid for by the Gulenists, where she was treated with one gala luncheon and dinner after another, first class air & hotel, etc., these statements of Ms. Garcia are very troubling.
Again, I HAVE TO SAY IT AGAIN, having her election campaigns bankrolled by alleged allies of the Islamic Imam Fetulleh Gulen (with campaign funding funnelled through groups that the Imam controls), her speech in the video (ABOVE) clearly shows that Ms. Garcia’s loyalty is obviously not to the million or so citizens and voters in her LAUSD School Board District, or to the ones who elected her and whom she represents, but instead her allegiance is to foreign Islamists who use the profits from their charter chains — profits which Garcia enables though her votes to approve those Gulenist charters, and whose interests she so vehemently fights for elsewhere (SEE VIDEO ABOVE) — to finance a revolution back in Turkey with … to quote Jack above … the Imam Gulen’s ultimate goal to impose a brutal Islamic theocracy and dictatorship like the one imposed on neighboring Iran in 1979.
LikeLike
Thank you, Julie.
Gulen is a BAD person. Gulen Charters steal and disguise. In the meanwhile Gulen portrays himself as so holy, holy, holy … NOT.
LikeLike
Yvonne, the Gulen System of Education Scamming in the USA is not only abusive to the American taxpayer, but to American credentialed teachers and worst of all to their own cult members that they Tuzuk (forced donations) of 40% of their salary. Already Magnolia has had 2 lawsuits from ex Gulenists teachers who successfully sued Magnolia Science Academy for wrongful termination and extortion of pay. Metin Demir vs. Magnolia Science Academy was just resolved on April 12, 2018. Another one is pending.
LikeLike