Governor Chris Christie did his damndest to harm the public schoolsin New Jersey during his eight years in Office. Its public schools are among the best in the nation outside of the so-called Abbott districts, a group of highly segregated, impoverished school districts that Christie determined to hand over to private charter chains.
The Education Law Center provides an update hereon Governor Phil Murphy’s efforts to reverse Christie’s foul legacy.
At the end of June, the New Jersey Legislature passed the FY19 State Budget and several other bills impacting the state’s 1.4 million public school students.
“Over the last eight years, lawmakers did little to prevent former Governor Chris Christie from cutting school funding; imposing PARCC exams as the high school exit test in violation of state law; and rapidly expanding charter schools, depleting resources and fueling student segregation in Newark, Camden, Trenton and other districts.
“With Governor Phil Murphy’s election, legislative leaders had the opportunity to reverse course by taking bold steps to restore equity, adequacy and opportunity for public school children, especially those at risk and with special needs.
“So did legislators heed the call for change?”
“Here’s a recap of the major actions taken by the Legislature on public education:
“School Funding: The FY19 Budget contains a $340 million increase in K-12 funding, with much of those funds allocated to districts spending below their constitutional level of adequacy under the SFRA funding formula. Yet other districts, including many below or slightly above adequacy, will have their state aid reduced by a total of over $600 million in seven years under changes to the formula pushed by Senate President Stephen Sweeney. While some last minute changes may mitigate the full impact of the cuts, many districts are facing the grim prospect of laying off teachers and support staff and eliminating needed programs as the reductions in state aid accelerate in the coming years.
“Preschool: The FY19 Budget includes $57 million in SFRA preschool education aid, providing the first increase in per pupil funding for existing preschool programs since 2013-14. It includes $32.5 million to address years of flat funding and adds $25 million for expansion of high quality preschool to low-income students across the state, as promised in the SFRA formula.
“School Construction: In passing a bill to authorize $500 million in school construction funds targeted to county vocational school districts, lawmakers did nothing to address the urgent need for school construction funding in all other school districts across the state. Legislators turned a blind-eye to the stark fact that the state school construction program has run out of money for 381 health and safety, capital maintenance and major projects recently identified by the NJ Department of Education for urban districts, as well as for grants for needed facilities improvements in hundreds of “regular operating districts.”
“Camden Charter School Expansion: Lawmakers bypassed the education committees in both chambers to rush through a bill to allow three out-of-state charter chains – KIPP, Uncommon and Mastery – to continue to expand across the city and, in the process, pave the way for these private charter operators to close and replace most or all of Camden’s public schools.
Private School Vouchers: Legislators decided to table a bill to use public funds to pay the salaries of science and math teachers in private schools. The bill would have added millions more to the over $110 million in public funds already allocated to private schools for textbooks, security, nurses and remedial programs. Lawmakers failed to take action to reduce the millions in taxpayer dollars diverted to private schools and to redirect those dollars to the state’s chronically underfunded public schools.
“The Legislature completely avoided other pressing issues, such as the looming high school graduation testing crisis, the need to reform the state’s charter school law, and the consolidation of K-6 and K-8 districts into unified K-12 districts across the state.
“The scorecard on the Legislature’s actions on public education is decidedly mixed. But one lesson is clear. Advocates for our public school students and their schools must redouble efforts to hold elected officials to account for advancing, and not threatening, the right of all children to a thorough and efficient education, as guaranteed under our state constitution.
“David Sciarra is the Executive Director of Education Law Center and lead counsel for the plaintiff school children in Abbott v. Burke.”
Education Law Center Press Contact:
Sharon Krengel
Policy and Outreach Director
skrengel@edlawcenter.org
973-624-1815, x 24

Great for New Jersey schools – I’m happy to hear that the ship is changing course. However, I’m utterly confused by this:
“Over the last eight years, lawmakers did little to prevent former Governor Chris Christie from cutting school funding; imposing PARCC exams as the high school exit test in violation of state law; and rapidly expanding charter schools, depleting resources and fueling student segregation in Newark, Camden, Trenton and other districts.
“With Governor Phil Murphy’s election, legislative leaders had the opportunity to reverse course by taking bold steps to restore equity, adequacy and opportunity for public school children, especially those at risk and with special needs.”
What does it matter who is in the governor’s office? Shouldn’t legislators do the right thing anyway? Even if the governor is going to veto it, at least they should try, no?
LikeLike
Christie was (is) an incredible bully, he would use threats and rewards to get certain Democrats to go along with his toxic agenda. When he ran for a second term, there were Democrats who openly supported him over the Democratic candidate, Barbara Buono! It was insane, fellow Democrats stabbed Buono in the back to support a Republican. One can only speculate about the deals/threats he made with these DINOs to win his second term. As far as I know, this is unprecedented in NJ political history. Yes, it’s true, too many Democrats were feckless, gutless and amoral during the reign of Christie the Horrible. So many politicians were cowed by the blustering and bullying of CC; CC would buy off many big wig Ds with big rewards/bribes.
LikeLike
In 2015, Buono sold her home in Metuchen and moved to Portland, Oregon. This is total speculation on my part, but I’m suspecting that Buono moved out of NJ, in part, out of disgust for being betrayed by her own party. She was the only Democrat who had the guts to run against Christie, none of the men even attempted a run. Cory Booker and Steve Sweeney had made too many behind the scenes deals with CC to challenge him.
LikeLike
Thanks for the info. Can’t say I find it surprising.
LikeLike
Remember, Christie shut down the George Washington Bridge to punish a Democrat.
I think Murphy is actually quite charter-friendly. But this shows that there is a DIFFERENCE between having a Republican in charge and a Democrat, even if the Dem is still pro-charter.
Even most charter friendly Dems (and I include Elizabeth Warren) don’t want to destroy public schools. The right wing Republicans and Trump could not care less if they do as long as their donors make a profit.
LikeLike
NYC public school parent: I don’t think that Murphy is that pro charter though he is certainly not anti-charter. He’s close to being agnostic on the issue unless you have better information than I do. It’s a relief having Murphy as governor after 8 toxic years of a vehemently pro charter, pro voucher governor who belittled public school teachers and the real public schools. Murphy is not at war with the NJEA and he does not demean and demonize public school teachers as CC did. Big improvement over the bellowing bloviating anti-education governor.
LikeLike
nycpsp: Agree w/ your conclusions, but there isn’t much to suggest Murphy is “quite charter-friendly” [like, say, Booker]. He’s said he isn’t “hell no” on charters, but he “doesn’t like the way it’s been done,” & soon after taking office, called for a comprehensive review w/an eye to tightening up the charter law. That could of course be a bone thrown to teachers’ union (in place of backing their call for a moratorium). But I take as a positive that Ed Dept, at same time as announcing the review, rejected 5 proposals for charter school expansions. Time will tell.
LikeLike
Thank you Joe and bethree5, for your correction.
I now realize I confused Gov. Phil Murphy in NJ with Chris Murphy in Connecticut, who is pro-charter. I’m glad someone corrected my error!
LikeLike
Christie was a fatter version of Trump. Just as nasty and people voted him twice into office as he destroyed the lives of minorities. However the rest of the legislators allowed themselves to be bullied by a white hater
LikeLike
Agreed, Beata. Christie was loud, crude, rude, and a bully. It worked until the Bridgegate scandal. His executive assistant, Bridget Kelly, a single mother of four, went to jail and took the rap for him. And he let her.
LikeLike
You do know that NJ’s governor has a veto that can only be overcome by a 2/3rds veto?
You do know that Christie was elected through normal means and won an overwhelming majority in 2013?
Even with legislative majorities, overcoming that veto is impossible, nor would the Democrats have had a mandate to do so.
LikeLike
Christie was the most unpopular governor in the nation at the end of his second term. Did you know that?
LikeLike
Christie was indeed horrible in many of the same ways as Trump. Yet he didn’t make me embarrassed to be a NJ’an (as Trump makes me embarrassed for the US). He was an aberration in a sense, or perhaps more accurately a taxpayer revolt against hi state cost during recession, a sort of line drawn in the sand. And he did not seem intent on destroying everything the state stands for – like govrs of WI, MI, NC, KS, free to do max damage w/their all-red legisl. Tho he cowed the Dem legisl majority to an extent (& had strong veto power), his bullying was harnessed by that balance. I saw him as a low that would pass while I gritted my teeth for 8 yrs, & damage retrievable. Whereas T-rump scares the h out of me: he has done more damage in 18 mos than I could have imagined.
LikeLike
Right. Trump embarrasses our nation. He wants to destroy NATO and the EU. Weird to see him fawning over Putin and Kim.
LikeLike
bethree5,
That is a great analysis. Trump is dangerous to democracy in a way that Christie wasn’t.
LikeLike
The terminal cancer continues to spread. What should we name this cancer — after Koch or maybe greed?
LikeLike
Under Chris Christie New Jersey was the only state in the country to receive an “A” in school finance on the Network for Public Education’s report card. NJ not only spends more per student than just about every other state (though still quite a bit less than New York), it also spends that money the most equitably (see p 13): https://networkforpubliceducation.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/NPE-Report-Card-Smaller.pdf
It’s absurd to blame Christie for NJ’s longstanding extreme school segregation, and the parents who are choosing to send their children to charter schools are, say it with me, zoned for traditional district schools that neither you, me, anyone who reads or comments here, or anyone who works for the Education Law Center would send their own child or grandchild to if they were literally the last public schools left on earth.
(Since everyone was made very upset by the fact that Chris Christie didn’t send his own kids to public schools, it must be pointed out that Murphy’s don’t either. His two K-8 aged children attend a $31,000/year private K-8 school in Monmouth County and his HS-aged kids go to hyperelite, $55,800/year Andover.)
LikeLike
Christie was in no way responsible for equitable spending in NJ. That was the result of court orders that long predates him.
Christie was a bully who hates public schools and their teachers. He ended as the most unpopular governor in America. Deservedly so.
New Jersey has some of the best public schools in the nation. No thanks to Christie. Like Trump, a bully.
LikeLike