Tom Hobson teaches preschool in Seattle, Washington. He is also a blogger.
He wrote here about the machinations of the greedy profiteers who want children to be taught by machines. He will not permit it. The children are his friends. The profiteers don’t give a damn about the children he teaches.
He begins like this:
I typically wait by the door or gate to greet the children as they arrive, “Hi Sarah! I’m happy to see you!” I say it because it’s how I would like to be greeted. In a way, I guess, you could consider it my version of shouting, “Norm!” the way the Cheers regulars did each time their beloved friend walked through the door.
I also say it because it’s true. I am happy to see each child walk through the door. I’m grateful they’ve come back. I’m grateful that their parents continue to trust me with their baby. I’m grateful that we are going to now spend hours together, just farting around, making stuff, imagining stuff, thinking about stuff and generally just goofing off. I’m even grateful for the times we get sad or angry, because those conflicts are a part of our friendship.
And that’s the thing, that’s the part that people who don’t do this job will never understand: the friendship. These kids are my friends, especially those who are back for a second or third year with me. We’re not even two weeks into the new school year and we’re already finishing each other’s sentences and cracking inside jokes. This is what I will remember from the too short time we spend together. It is also what they will remember. And we’ve got nine months of that ahead of us. Norm!
He adds:
Are we that stupid. People need other people, not just for procreation or telling stories or being happy or forming a team, but also for learning anything worth learning. We will figure out how to read and write and cipher as we always have: virally, by hanging out with other people, which is a system that has worked for most people throughout history. It’s been a largely successful system so why the hell would we mess with it? And that’s also, not incidentally, how we learn everything else: virally, by hanging out with other people. And that requires friendship, deep down real friendship. That, ultimately, is the source of extraordinary motivation.
Read their own documents, and you’ll see that they are planning to turn live, face-to-face teaching into a “premium service.” . . . Meaning that they know face-to-face instruction is a better way to learn, and they have no intention of having their own children learn from machines.
I am not laughing about this academic’s predictions. I’m girding myself because billionaires are behind this and they, despite their philanthropic BS, care primarily about making a killing at the expense of our kids. I will not permit children, my friends, to be turned over to machines. I want them to come to a place where everybody knows their name and where they’re always glad they came.
Friends don’t turn their friends over to machines. People need other people. Children need humans, not machines, to teach them.

Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education.
LikeLike
Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg understands friends.
They are the people who “like” you because of how popular you are.
And Google’s Larry Page also understands this as well, which is why his search algorithm is basically a popularity contest.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Would it offend you if I “like” both this post and your comment? (insert smiley face here)
LikeLiked by 1 person
EXCELLENT understanding of the true enemy: when having actual human friends turns into having technology “likes”
LikeLike
They’re pushing it hard in reform.
Here’s Jeb Bush’s lobbying shop pitching product to public schools:
“Personalized learning presents a vital opportunity to provide rigorous, high-quality instruction while addressing students’ diverse educational experiences and pursuing their unique strengths, interests, and needs. Coupled with flexibility in pace and delivery, personalized learning is grounded in the idea of students progressing when they demonstrate mastery of skills and knowledge, regardless of the time, place, or pace at which such mastery occurs. For some students, it means removing artificial barriers to their engagement with more advanced work. For many others, it means providing tailored support as well as the time and opportunity to close learning gaps rather than leaving them behind year after year.”
This is the same lobbying group that sold tens of millions in ed tech product to Maine public schools with outlandish claims about how children would never get a job unless schools purchased Chromebooks.
They’re back! They never really go away- they just switch seats among the ed reform orgs.
https://edexcellence.net/articles/personalized-learning-and-accountability-from-transition-to-transformation
Ultimately I blame public schools for taking advice from these people. Just because someone is selling you something doesn’t mean you have to buy it.
Tell them “no”. The world won’t end.
LikeLike
MORE LAWYER kind of talk. Spin, spin, spin.
LikeLike
That’s just lovely. It’s also how I spent the last 19 years – with my friends from 2-18, laughing, learning, loving and living. Education is about the 4 L’s! The hell with the 3 R’s. I retired and miss them, but will work as hard as I can to make sure laughing, learning, loving and living are not extinguished by the “reformers.”
LikeLike
I checked out Tom’s blog as well as the website for the school where he works. (“Work” might not be the right word to use since teaching is obviously his life, too.)
I was especially struck by a description on the school’s website: Tom, “…worked each day in his daughter’s classroom as an assistant teacher under the tutelage of veteran teachers, although he’ll be the first to tell you that most of what he learned came from the children themselves.”
Yup. And, therein lies a HUGE difference between the pseudo, wannabe, corporate controlled so-called “reformers” we have today and teacher Tom. Tom sounds like he listens to the kids and their parents and other teachers around him. Whereas, for the alleged “reformers”, it’s a top-down, hierarchical, might makes right system. Of course, the alleged “reformers” spend a lot of time and money trying to convince the public otherwise. But the truth is detailed page after page on this blog.
This is a choice that is not only about education….about where to send your children for pre-school, for example. I see it as a choice citizens face right now all across this country involving almost every aspect of our lives. Take for example the case before the U.S. Supreme Court about computer designed super-gerrymandering in Wisconsin. http://thehill.com/homenews/senate/349340-mccain-whitehouse-urge-scotus-to-affirm-wisconsin-gerrymandering-decision
As Diane concludes, do we reach out as humans and care for one another or just default to the easiest machine?
LikeLike
Regardless of what age group you teach, or even if you don’t teach at all, you should make Teacher Tom’s blog a daily stop. Chock-full of humanity.
LikeLike
I love Teacher Tom! I’ve learned so much from his blog.
LikeLike
Absolutely! A master’s class in early childhood education. Tom GETS IT!
LikeLike
I am still dumbstruck that we are even having this conversation. That whole Bush narrative (above) is just more code for: Here’s the door. You’re on your own (but be sure to buy our stuff on the way out.)
The problem is not that teachers have trusted them (Bush et al) to tell it like it is–it does SOUND so good. The problem is The Big Lie, and the RAMPANT IN-AUTHENTICITY of those pushing such programs on trusting teachers.
LikeLike
Today we had what was publicized as a “Swalwell Site Visit” at our public elementary school that serves poor kids of color right in Silicon Valley’s shadow. Eric Swalwell is our Congressional representative.
The visit turned out to be a Google commercial. Eric Swalwell did not show up. Maybe some of his staff was there??? If so they were not introduced to our students.
I had taught my students all about government in preparation for his visit.
It is amazing what Google could do with all its resources. There were about 15 Google employees (a ratio of about 1 Google employee for every 6 students) for a one-hour activity. They had all kinds of technological equipment that they brought in themselves and set up.
We do not have any resources to follow up on this activity. The result was a random event.
A random event that seemed more like a publicity stunt than an attempt to help kids of color and their public schools.
We need funding to lower class size. We need librarians. We need books aligned to our curriculum. We are still using pre-common core textbooks 5 years into this “new” curriculum. We need economic and educational opportunities for our families
LikeLike
Google, Apple, Intel, Microsoft and other tech giants could do a great deal to help schools if they were actually interested in helping rather than making a buck off them.
But they aren’t so they don’t.
These companies are always complaining about not being able to find qualified Americans to work for them, but the complaints are all empty excuses to hire foreign workers at lower pay and benefits.
Apple is particularly bad, using what amounts to slave labor in China to assemble their phones.
But of course, no one in the US cares as long as they get the latest iPhone.
LikeLike
“Things don’t teach, Teachers teach” – Marva Collins
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marva_Collins
Marva Collins was offered the post of Secretary of Education by Ronald Reagan. She declined.
Marva Collins is one my heroes.
LikeLike
We live in a self service world now. It’s every man, woman, and child for themselves. Look at all the jobs or services someone once provided for us, which we now do the work ourselves. We bus our own tables at the “restaurant”. We check out and bag and take our groceries to our cars, all on our own. It’s sold to use as convenience, and at times it is, and at times it isn’t.
Do travel agents even exist anymore? I mostly just travel on business, it’s up to me to figure out how to get somewhere and how to get back home. But hey, it’s all “on-line” now, easy peasy and free. And at times it is, and at times it isn’t. We even do our own performance reviews where i work. We write them ourselves and our manager signs off on them. Of course I far exceed expectations each and every year.
And this self service world is not just for the lower class. Most executives no longer have assistants, not needed they say, technology rules the day. Most lawyers don’t even have admins anymore.
This will trickle down to the K-12 market. Dick and Jane can basically educate themselves using technology. The school will provide the tools and give them a place to work, but it’ll be up to Dick and Jane to fail or succeed on their own. Teachers will not be needed at all. Too much overhead, too much cost, low ROI, misappropriation of capital. But IBM has Watson after-all. Artificial Intelligence may not save the day but it will rule the day. And it will all be sold with some fancy language, personalized, rigorous, engaging, rewarding, best of breed, future proof, yada yada.
LikeLike
So true. It is all about cutting costs. Some have talked about a jobless economy. What will people do?
LikeLike
Low-end manufacturing is dead in this nation. Robotics, and low-wage nations like China and India, have seen to that.
The work of the 21st century, is the work of the mind. All the more reason, that our schools/colleges/vocational schools, must be second to none.
LikeLike
Charles,
You are right. The work of the mind matters greatly in this world. That is why we must not squander public money on schools that teach children that the Bible contains the best thinking about science or that climate change is a hoax, or that women are inferior. We must develop every child to their greatest capacity—intellectually, socially, physically, creatively, emotionally.
LikeLike