Not one Republican voted to defend our public schools against the most unqualified nominee for Secretary of Education in history
#stopprivatization
#dumpdevos
A site to discuss better education for all
Categories Betsy DeVos, Shame
81 Comments Post your own or leave a trackback: Trackback URL
Leave a Reply to dianeravitch Cancel reply
Search All Posts
Previous posts
- May 2022 (70)
- April 2022 (105)
- March 2022 (119)
- February 2022 (96)
- January 2022 (94)
- December 2021 (98)
- November 2021 (77)
- October 2021 (79)
- September 2021 (78)
- August 2021 (74)
- July 2021 (82)
- June 2021 (69)
- May 2021 (66)
- April 2021 (72)
- March 2021 (103)
- February 2021 (140)
- January 2021 (169)
- December 2020 (142)
- November 2020 (160)
- October 2020 (169)
- September 2020 (170)
- August 2020 (175)
- July 2020 (191)
- June 2020 (195)
- May 2020 (205)
- April 2020 (203)
- March 2020 (197)
- February 2020 (165)
- January 2020 (180)
- December 2019 (194)
- November 2019 (185)
- October 2019 (199)
- September 2019 (169)
- August 2019 (172)
- July 2019 (169)
- June 2019 (193)
- May 2019 (203)
- April 2019 (195)
- March 2019 (187)
- February 2019 (160)
- January 2019 (201)
- December 2018 (204)
- November 2018 (213)
- October 2018 (213)
- September 2018 (186)
- August 2018 (190)
- July 2018 (196)
- June 2018 (190)
- May 2018 (225)
- April 2018 (221)
- March 2018 (242)
- February 2018 (182)
- January 2018 (212)
- December 2017 (224)
- November 2017 (188)
- October 2017 (240)
- September 2017 (239)
- August 2017 (237)
- July 2017 (235)
- June 2017 (224)
- May 2017 (267)
- April 2017 (265)
- March 2017 (284)
- February 2017 (262)
- January 2017 (355)
- December 2016 (239)
- November 2016 (274)
- October 2016 (219)
- September 2016 (218)
- August 2016 (211)
- July 2016 (217)
- June 2016 (219)
- May 2016 (233)
- April 2016 (229)
- March 2016 (242)
- February 2016 (244)
- January 2016 (247)
- December 2015 (230)
- November 2015 (233)
- October 2015 (292)
- September 2015 (262)
- August 2015 (268)
- July 2015 (252)
- June 2015 (254)
- May 2015 (277)
- April 2015 (290)
- March 2015 (322)
- February 2015 (281)
- January 2015 (247)
- December 2014 (225)
- November 2014 (226)
- October 2014 (287)
- September 2014 (283)
- August 2014 (271)
- July 2014 (258)
- June 2014 (281)
- May 2014 (284)
- April 2014 (330)
- March 2014 (358)
- February 2014 (308)
- January 2014 (282)
- December 2013 (260)
- November 2013 (270)
- October 2013 (342)
- September 2013 (358)
- August 2013 (373)
- July 2013 (336)
- June 2013 (347)
- May 2013 (348)
- April 2013 (369)
- March 2013 (379)
- February 2013 (296)
- January 2013 (342)
- December 2012 (328)
- November 2012 (270)
- October 2012 (366)
- September 2012 (475)
- August 2012 (463)
- July 2012 (372)
- June 2012 (209)
- May 2012 (120)
- April 2012 (17)
-
Recent posts
- Texas: Trump Brings His Profitable Tour to Austin
- Sweden: The Failure of Vouchers
- Tucker Carlson Slams Houston Congressman for Supporting Aid to Ukraine
- Texas: IDEA Charter Chain Hires State Auditor to Be Its New CEO
- Tennessee: Supreme Court Reverses Lower Courts and Declares State Voucher Program Constitutional
Blog Topics
Accountability Betsy DeVos Billionaires Budget Cuts California Charter Schools Chicago Closing schools Common Core Corporate Reform Corporate Reformers Democracy Duncan, Arne Education Industry Education Reform Florida For-Profit Fraud Funding Gates Foundation, Bill Gates International Los Angeles New York New York City Ohio Parents Privatization Race to the Top Resistance School Choice Standardized Testing Students Teacher Evaluations Teachers Teachers and Teaching Testing Texas Trump Unions Vouchers
Top posts
- Tucker Carlson Slams Houston Congressman for Supporting Aid to Ukraine
- Texas: Trump Brings His Profitable Tour to Austin
- Sweden: The Failure of Vouchers
- Washington Post: Abortion Foes Want to Eliminate Exceptions for “Life of Mother”
- Texas: IDEA Charter Chain Hires State Auditor to Be Its New CEO
- The Greatest Hoax in the History of Education
- Tennessee: Supreme Court Reverses Lower Courts and Declares State Voucher Program Constitutional
- NY Redistricting Creates Turmoil, Dilutes Black Vote, and Favors Republicans
- The New Republic: "Newsweek" Has Turned into "A Zombie Magazine"
- Should an Ed.D. or Ph.D. Be Called “Doctor?”
Follow blog via RSS reader
-
Diane Ravitch's Blog by Diane Ravitch is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Based on a work at dianeravitch.net. Blog Stats
- 39,513,059 hits
Diane Ravitch's blog 
All we needed were two votes- two people that thought beyond the train- to stop this insidious choice.
Just 1, not 2. One Republican. Do Republicans hate public schools?
Of course Repulsives voted for the unqualified DeVos. Repulsives despise all public institutions except the military-industrial-intelligence-congressional complex which provides so much $$$ to BOTH major political parties. Their great dream is to privatize everything, so they can get even wealthier, regardless of how many people suffer. The market is God.
DeVos put a charter promoter in to mollify liberal ed reformers:
http://educationpost.org/the-choice-of-botel-for-white-house-education-advisor-should-offer-some-comfort-to-devos-opponents/
You’ll notice she doesn’t feel she has to appoint anyone to represent the interests of public school parents and children. They know no one will make a fuss if we’re completely ignored.
Looking forward to “public school policy” that excludes any input from anyone in a public school. That’ll go well.
Race to the voucher. States that embrace vouchers and charters will see more millions of fed grants headed their way. States who don’t? As Blues Brother Dan Akroyd said, you go hungray.
I think her commitment to parental choice in education will strengthen our educational system. Options for students are a good thing.
Parental choice is great for those parents who happen to have white, affluent, English-speaking, non-disabled, compliant, cheap and easy to educate students whom any school would fight to accept. I guess you don’t care much about the rest of the riff-raff, do you?
Have you ever read anything by Diane Ravitch?
It’s faux choice, it’s toxic choice, it’s not real choice. It’s phony baloney choice. Finland does not have so called school choice. It has a good public school system – no charter schools, no school vouchers, no home schooling, no privatization glop.
Bad options for students is not positive in any way, shape or form.
Charter schools don’t want kids with serious behavioral problems or severe learning disabilities. They counsel them out or make life miserable for the parents of those kids. This goes on now in Camden, NJ, and many other places in the country.
Baloney. Privatized schools have ALL of the choice. Students with disabilities who are too expensive need not apply. That’s called discrimination, not choice.
jdhollowell…I believe that you are on the wrong blog to be commenting in favor of “school choice, vouchers, or charter schools”.
Typical leftist attempt to deny an opposing view.
I’m not denying anything, I just disagree.
Typical rightwing sneer at those who don’t share their views
Contrary to drext727, I as a regular blog contributor, welcome opposing views, they spark dialog & keep us from being an echo chamber. I hope you will expand on the basis for your opinion.
Options for the (select) few result in fewer resources for the overwhelming majority. It’s simple arithmetic, combined with racism and class warfare.
HUH? Do you read and are you aware, jdhollowell? Put on your thinking cap, please.
Options are a good thing. So is fully funded education. If she can compel the states and the federal gov to come up with another quarter trillion per year to fully fund education, more power to her.
Under DeVos, expect budget cuts. Predestination.
There might be a surprise here! Once school choice is initiated, and parents get the vouchers, there could be a surprise. If the voucher payments are not adequate, to meet tuition at private/parochial schools, then the government might be persuaded to increase the amount of the voucher. When the vouchers are redeemed at public schools, the amount of per-pupil spending will increase accordingly! Well worth consideration.
Charles, that is nonsense. Several cities already have vouchers. No, the amounts have not increased. Kids go to poor schools and outcomes are negligible. Money drained from public schools, so that public schools suffer
“Fully funded education” for whom? As is happening now, public schools are being starved. Money is being stolen by charters, both non-profit & for-profit.
The last place the money goes to is students, if you’ve been following any of this at all, TC. Lot$ of $$$$ to “$tandardized” te$ting, i.e., Pear$on Publi$hing (&, oh, “poor” Pear$on–the WSJ has reported that their $tock$ dropped by 30%! {& you’ve GOT to wonder just WHO owns Pear$on $tock-?}). Then, archive thi$ blog, & read about all the PUBLIC (that’$ right–OUR tax $$$) school monies stolen by charter school operators, rent that’s been saved & charter schools that have–w/o much or any prior notice–been shuttered, leaving families scrambling.
Or…just read Diane’s recent postings about DeVos & just what she’s done to schools in Michigan.
The very LAST thing she needs is “more power.”
Charles,
NIOL(Not In Our Lifetime)!
“Options are a good thing.”
Yeah, if they are for all. But in this case, as in most cases where politicians want to deregulate, only the 1% will have a choice.
“Options” and “choices” are dirty words here.
JDHollowell,
Any evidence or just your hope?
As long as her school choice has accountability and plays by the same rules as public schools. In Michigan, the DeVos family used their money to have accountability removed from a charter school bill. Most charter schools in Michigan fall well below the public schools, in regards to test scores AND they are for profit. Makes you wonder why Mrs. DeVos is against accountability, doesn’t it?
Well, public school parents are going to have to start holding Republican Senators accountable. When they show up at your public school come election time tell them to take a hike. The least they could do is stay out of the public schools they spend all their time bashing. I’m not aware of any requirement that says we even have to host them. We have to comply with federal law. All the rest is optional.
Did we REALLY expect anything less from the Republicans. Or should I day something better from the Republicans. NO!!!! Republicans are AFRAID of Trump. They are afraid to vote against anything or anyone that Dumb Trump wants. That is the bottom line. Republicans to not have the backbone necessary to stand up for the American people and serve the American people as we expect our elected officials to do. Republicans lined up behind Dumb Trump with their dunce caps on and stupid smiles on their faces.
Yes. One thing that Trump has used to his own purposes often and abusively is his unfiltered (and untethered) voice: you can bet that when any person now theoretically on his “side” steps out of line, he won’t hold back.
Yes, ciedie…and he is now in further lockstep with DeVos and her drive to use vouchers to indoctrinate the Nation’s children in Christianity, by insisting that all Christians from the 7 Islamic countries on his hit list be able to step to the front of the line and gain easy entrance to the US. How do you tell who is a Christian? Is there a mark imprinted on the forehead as with a Scarlet Letter?
may many learn to game that system very quickly
I wonder what they were threatened with. After all — she doesn’t own ALL of them!
As she has said herself, she does own most of them. She claims her major donations gives her the right to demand her positions be followed by the legislators who take her cash.
This confirms that we are living in a corrupt country filled with fake people who are so corrupt that the system they serve will rise up to bite them in the ass. This confirmation is a sad day for american public education and education in general. This is complete bull shit and Devos will be despised in any environment she tries to attend such as a NYC school. If Devos tries to visit a NYC public school she better come with the secret service or it could get ugly
She will bring a grizzly bear and a gun when she visits schools
But I doubt she will ever visit public schools. Only charters and religious schools
Two Senator, Murkowski from Alaska, and Collins from Maine, made it clear that they have significant concerns with DeVos as a nominee, and that she has not yet won their floor vote. Their votes today were to advance her out of the committee, but they were VERY clear that they have doubts about her ability to be an advocate for traditional public schools. All hope is not yet lost!
Don’t hold your breath. Especially with Murkowski, DeVos has invested in her.
I would hope some of the moderate Republicans in the senate will throw out a few of the least palatable, be that Mnuchin, Perry, or DeVos.
It would be sad if they rubber stamped everybody.
I think it will take 18 months at a minimum before Reps vote against Trump. Hope I’m wrong.
Remembering the rubber stamp of the Bloomberg years in NYC…so many schools closed 😦
Please call and write to these two, plus Sasse, McCain, Graham and others to NOT vote for DeVos…and the other candidates who will further deform America…particularly Tillerson.
Are there any moderate Republicans?
Abigail, it’s an extinct species. Susan Collins will claim to be one, but her voting record indicates otherwise.
Collins is a hypocrite.
http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/campaign-k-12/2017/01/senate_committee_backs_betsy_devos_two_GOP_votes_uncertain.html
One vote would have made all the difference 😦
Now, Senate Democrats, show your filibuster power! Those who value public schools are looking to you.
There is no filibuster power for cabinet votes.
Sen. McConnell warned Harry Reid, some time ago. It has been proven true! The democrats brought this on themselves.
Thanks Harry Reid for this cabinet of deplorables
Democrats could have blocked the nomination with procedural rules. They didn’t .
Which rules? They can’t use the filibuster to prevent a vote.
Democrats should be using the same tactics for promoting delays in Congress that Republicans used on them for the last 8 years.
I’m certainly no expert on this, but as mentioned in an article Diane posted here a few days ago, to prevent cabinet nominees from being rushed through, Dems could withhold consent and trigger the cloture process:
https://dianeravitch.net/2017/01/29/former-senate-aide-democrats-can-stop-trump-if-they-have-the-will-and-the-guts/
I think that article is talking about ways to drag the process out, rather than actually blocking votes.
I think it was very apparent I knew when I wrote that Democrats could use “tactics for promoting delays” and “prevent cabinet nominees from being rushed through” that this will “drag the process out.” Buying time is sometimes just what is needed to get through to someone who might be on the fence or wavering. Didn’t they only need ONE person to jump ship?
Apparently, the procedure will cause a lot of extra work for Republicans. There’s no good reason why Democrats should be promoting smooth sailing for Republicans, or make things easier for them when dealing with such critical matters, especially after Republicans just spent year after year trying to thwart Democrats at every turn.
If Democrats don’t capitalize on every single opportunity they get to at least try to prevent Trump from getting whatever he wants handed to him on a silver platter, they’ll just look like the party of wimps giving up to the fascist bullies.
Sorry, I read your comment as referring to using procedural rules to block a nomination.
Then we’ll just have to wait for a better time, and hope the public schools survive until that better time.
Anything else? Is there any alternative to flying the white flag?
OMG…HELP committee. Turn everything 180 that comes from D.C.
Can you list for us who they are???
Sent from my iPhone
>
Subcommittee Chair Ranking Member
Subcommittee on Children and Families Chris Dodd (D-CT) Lamar Alexander (R-TN)
Subcommittee on Employment and Workplace Safety Patty Murray (D-WA) Johnny Isakson (R-GA)
Subcommittee on Retirement and Aging Barbara Mikulski (D-MD) Richard Burr (R-NC)
United States Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and …
Deb…here is a follow up to the HELP committee and those members who took DeVos bribes…article by Steve Singer.
Steven Singer posted this message on Basecamp.
“Farcical Senate Closer to Selling Education Secretary Position to Highest Bidder
Unqualified billionaire Betsy DeVos is one step closer to becoming our next Education Secretary.
In one of the most embarrassing displays of subservience, once-respected Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN) pushed the nomination through committee this afternoon despite numerous objections from Democrats.
The Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee voted along party lines 12-11 to bring DeVos before the full Senate. A final vote has not yet been scheduled.
DeVos has next to zero experience with public schools. She never attended one. He children never attended one. She never taught in one. Nor does she even have a degree in education.
Her entire experience is bribing policymakers to enact Common Core, push school choice measures and reduce transparency at charter schools – measures that have gutted public schools in her home state of Michigan.
At her confirmation hearing two weeks ago, DeVos’ ignorance of even the most basic education knowledge was laughably on display.
She wouldn’t commit to protecting students with special needs.
She wouldn’t commit to keeping guns out of school campuses.
She wouldn’t commit to holding charter and voucher schools to the same standards as traditional public schools.
She didn’t know the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) was a federal law.
And she couldn’t explain the difference between proficiency and growth, two of the most common academic terms.
DeVos entire qualifications are that, along with her family, she has donated around $200 million to mostly Republican lawmakers.
That includes direct donations to at least five members of the HELP Committee:
Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-LA) – $70,200
Sen. Tim Scott (R–SC) – $49,200
Sen. Todd Young (R-IN) – $48,600
Sen. Richard Burr (R-NC) – $43,200
Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) – $43,200
If you add in PACS funded by DeVos and family, the number jumps to 10 members of the committee including Sen. Alexander, himself.
Senators have been bombarded by calls from constituents not to confirm DeVos, but greenbacks apparently talk much louder than our fragile excuse-for-a-Democracy.
However, two GOP members of the committee said that their votes today do not necessarily guarantee support on the final vote.
Sen. Susan Collins, (R-ME) and Sen. Murkowski said they were approving DeVos out of deference to Donald Trump. In effect, the President can nominate whomever he likes, and the Senate should vote on it.
Both Collins and Murkowski said they’re still concerned about DeVos’ seeming lack of commitment to enforce laws protecting disabled students and other policies.
“I would advise she not yet count on my vote,” Murkowski said.
The Senate, just like the HELP Committee, is controlled by Republicans. DeVos is only another party line vote away from becoming Secretary of Education.”
It is a position that she has apparently already bought and paid for.
READ MORE:
https://gadflyonthewallblog.wordpress.com/2017/01/31/farcical-senate-closer-to-selling-education-secretary-position-to-highest-bidder/
DeVos’ involvement with Neurocore alone should disqualify her from being approved as Secretary of Education! Two paragraphs from ‘Betsey DeVos Invests in a Therapy Under Scrutiny’ which appeared in today’s New York Times:
Neurocore is the creation of Timothy G. Royer, a licensed psychologist with a master’s degree in theology, who served as division chief of pediatric psychology at the Helen DeVos Children’s Hospital in Grand Rapids, Mich.
Originally called Hope 139, after Psalm 139 from the Bible, the company marketed itself to schools — especially religious ones — in Michigan to help children improve academic scores and lessen the need for medication to treat certain ailments.
The list of her holdings came to 102 companies listed. She said she would not divest from any of these. Neurocore is biofeedback which has been used for decades to ‘treat’ ADD, ADHD, and other learning disabilities. There are far more egregious companies on her list…the Prince family members are prime investors in weapons industries, and in clandestine military interventions…as with mercenaries. What a way to make billions….
So a single vote would have been needed, and then the 12:11 would have turned into 11:12.
Correct me if I am wrong, but since charter schools are “public” schools and get “public” money it seems to me that they will be in the same boat as regular district schools in that they will be loosing kids to religious or prestigious private schools. Why would a parent put a kid in a charter school with huge classes when they can take the “public” money attached to the kid and put him or her in a nice, mellow, relgious or private school? Seems to me that charters are gonna be scrambling for kids harder than ever if the voucher law really kicks in.
Yep.
Like Milwaukee, and DC, and Cleveland. No winners.
No, poor parents won’t be able to take their kids to Catholic schools with small class sizes, because the voucher doesn’t pay for the whole tuition, and poor parent cannot afford even the rest of the tuition.
So what happens to poor parents’ kids is that their public school will get less funds, due to voucher sucking away the money from them. So there will be bigger and bigger class sizes, and eventually technology will take over the job of the teachers—because that’s the “most costeffective” solution.
This is why vouchers give choice or “options” only to the rich, the rest will have even less choice than now.
We are doomed
We are NOT doomed unless we give up fighting, DeVos or No DeVos.
Sherri,
We are not doomed unless we give up. I ain’t giving up.
Nor am I!!!!!!
No one wanted to hear our warnings when the Democrats were on the same page as the GOP regarding education policies, at least in part, due to their trust and belief in Obama for the past 8 years.
Now we are going to have to make it very clear to the public on both sides of the aisle what privatization is all about, and that when billionaires want to take away something from us, whether it’s our public schools, our democratically elected school boards, our Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, health insurance or any other public good, they are not being altruistic or acting out of the goodness of their hearts. They are pursuing their own economic and ideological agendas. And, no, they really aren’t satiated by their wealth and always want more. (It’s like there’s a race to become the first trillionaire.)
The super-rich are people that see themselves as “the betters” in our society and they have waged class warfare against us, who they see as their “lessers.” It should be a lot more evident to people today that when it comes to public education, billionaires are aiming to destroy something they have not used for themselves or their children because they don’t value it.
And if you think that’s alarming, the choices those people promote for us are very limited in other arenas. Many of the same people who claim to believe in school choice are not only against women’s choice, but they also want to make birth control illegal, because they see contraception as the same thing as abortion:
http://www.alternet.org/right-wing/anti-choice-advocate-admits-joy-reid-her-ultimate-goal-make-birth-control-illegal
Trump did say something not long ago about making abortions illegal and about prosecuting women. Now try to imagine women being sent to jail for wearing the patch and men being sent to prison for wearing condoms –all created underground as contraband due to legal restrictions.
If that ever happens, the people who pushed such policies should be jailed for promoting the spread of Sexually Transmitted Diseases, including HIV, because without condoms that are manufactured to a high standard, we are sure to see a very severe spike in STDs…
Since so many of these right-wingers are fundamentalist Xtians, they probably want to make sex outside of marriage illegal, too.
They are just as likely to make sex inside of marriage illegal, the Puritans that they are.
Thank you for the laugh, Norwegian Filmmaker!
Also, others here…NOT doomed, NOT hopeless. As Bernie has been saying, we don’t have the luxury of despair. More people running for local, state office–primary legislators
who are complacent, career (those who’ve never done anything else in their adult work lives) & those who are just plain lousy, take bad money (e.g.–those 13 DINOs who voted against that Big Pharma resolution).
“Democracy is NOT a spectator sport…get out there, get active…tag, you’re it.”
–Thom Hartmann
(have to go—going to a meeting…)
I have been teaching in the public schools for 20 years, and after living through the Duncan years, I find DeVos to be refreshingly open and honest about being what the weasel Duncan tried so hard to hide being.
Look at all of the angst and outrage about DeVos already coming from some of the same camps who SHOULD have opposed Duncan, but could not do any more than shift uncomfortably and cough a little because he was Obama’s choice — the choice of the Democratic president.
DeVos is poised to boldly unmask corporate education reform and free many people to target it, and that is something that desperately needs to be done. The insidious Obama and Duncan were really a greater threat, IMO.
In a comment of mine which disappeared (I don’t know why), I asked if there are any alternatives to flying the white flag. Now I ask, are there any alternatives to flying the white flag OR to clenching our fists with fruitless shouts of defiance?
Never fly the white flag.
Join Network for Public Education and fight with your allies.
If she gets confirmed, the fight goes on.
No white flag. Never.
I watched the vote on DeVos live yesterday. As far as I can tell, only the Washington Post is fully reporting the bizarre double vote after Sen. Murray questioned the rule of order due to Sen. Hatch’s proxy vote (on cabinet appts senators must be present to vote). They tried to drag the poor clerk into the disagreement and Sen. Alexander basically stalled while they got Sen. Hatch back and revoted. As someone who knows about Robert’s rules of order, the shutting down of debate on a motion and the handling of the proxy vote were not trivial. Rules were broken. These are the signs of cracks in our democracy. Full transcript from c-span: https://www.c-span.org/video/…
I just know that in these times God will prevail. What is tough makes us strong!!
Well, DeVos and the adminsitration also think, God is behind them.