Christopher Cotton, who teaches high school English in Illinois, wrote the following:
It is all about the Id!
When people register their anger on Twitter, they are truly nasty. When the target is female, a large number of men become truly vile. It’s partly the anonymity. But many of the most despicable tweeters use their real names. It’s not just the rush of mob violence, ganging up on a defenseless victim, though that surely is a factor. Partly it’s because tweeting feels private; it feels like thinking. Partly it’s because of the quickness and off-the-cuff feeling of tapping thumbs at a tiny window. It’s often done standing up, on the move, multi-tasking: the superego is distracted; there’s no pause for reflection. This is the nature of the machine, of the interface of intellect and internet: it’s all about the id.
The power of Twitter is what it releases into the public sphere: the prehistoric reptile brain chained up by a thousand generations of human social organization. Now, much of this history has involved fierce repression—often cruel, sometimes stupid, and always changing. But as society progresses and the parameters change, what doesn’t change is the root idea that we need to control ourselves in order to coexist. We need a grown-up standing between the sudden thought and the spoken word. We need an armed grown-up between the impulse and the deed. That’s what Twitter tosses out the window: the very value of self-control….
Some people credit Trump for being some sort of genius: the first to see the possibilities, the game-changer of the internet. I don’t agree. He’s just your average dirty old man, just your run-of-the-mill scumbag megalomaniac narcissist billionaire. He’s just an oddly shaped peg that’s been swaggering through the world, bumping into people, knocking things over, and he just happened to tumble into a new and oddly-shaped hole in the universe.
So here he is, an avatar, but of the reverse type: he’s an avatar from the computer, now out in un-virtual reality. He’s a ragebot, lustbot, greedbot, egobot—released from the twitterverse and trolling the real world, looking for something to get mad at, to grope, to possess, to adore him.
Most of us never thought Trump had a chance to win the Republican nomination, let alone the presidency. He blew past mistakes that would have sunk any candidate in the past. But things are different now.
The world is a new place. We’re all strangers here. Except for the dirty old man. Turns out, he’s been living here for years. Hell, he bought property and put up hotels!

The Trump attack existed before Twitter. He is truly disgusting, utterly un-Christlike and totally WRONG, again and again and again, despite his continuous narcissistic revisions of reality.
http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/01/donald-trump-is-shocking-vulgar-and-right-213572
LikeLike
Unfortunately this country has lost its soul. We ae now a DYSTOPIA with a dirty old man at the helm. UGH.
LikeLike
Not only did he not win a majority. A vast number did not participate. My guess ,more of that number who did not participate could be mobilized to oppose him than support him . The problem is they are not going to be mobilized by the current opposition party leadership. Which is why we are in this predicament to begin with.
LikeLike
The right of Everyone to express an opinion is a hallmark of our Constitution. This blog has always respected that right. In 2 weeks the peaceful transition of power will take place as it has for 240 years. So be it. It is also my right to pick and choose which posting to read and which to ignore. With that in mind, I hope we can return to enjoy the relevant posts concern the future of education and topic elated to that subject. We are about to end 8 years of Obama bashing that has has raised the level of racial tension not seen in years. Please, not another 4 years of Trump bashing. It’s just demoralizing. Nothing is perfect .Just think, based on this election cycle we only have 2 years to before the campaign thing begins anew. Let’s all calm down and get to work and use this opportunity to teach more about civic , government and citizenship.
LikeLike
Telling the truth about Trump is Trump bashing? How do you ignore the rantings of a vicious demagogue? How do you ignore all his deplorable picks for his administration, such as DeVos, Puzder, Price, etc., ad nauseam? I am trying hard to calm down but then I read the latest headlines and what the GOP has in store for us from education to the ACA, to Medicare, Social Security, Medicaid, food stamps, legal abortions and any social programs that help the great mass of Americans.
LikeLike
Helen,
I love my country. I love the Constitution. Our country was just subject to the capture of the presidency by a vulgar fraud, with the help of Putin. The next four years will be dedicated to resistance against the wishes of this man to destroy public education, to crush unions, and to demoralize teachers. Do you not see that it is impossible to talk about or write about education issues while discussing the man who wants to destroy education, science, research, and knowledge?
LikeLike
Amen:
It never was possible to discuss education and what its role in society should be outside of the political arena. Which is the reason education has been under assault. Purely political , a matter of who is going to get to decide the distribution of goods and services . (wealth).
LikeLike
No. Trump and his appointments are critical to education, to pretend they are not is willful ignorance, citizenship requires participation.
LikeLike
Helen, not sure if you realize it, but your last sentence completely contradicts your argument.
LikeLike
GregB
A bit off topic but a link that I posted earlier a rather short read on where labor has gone wrong in the last 50 years . I found it on par with a Frank or Lufgren analysis.
Trumps victory has nothing to do with twitter or facebook or anything other than the failure of there to be a true alternative to the Republican right. The question is not did circumstance deny Hillary the election,it did . Like I said the brain stem would have to be missing to think not. The question is why we find ourselves with Hillary as the candidate to represent workers. (So what percentage of the population is not workers ?) The link in short order goes through the failures of labor that brought us to this point . As well as talking about building a mass social justice movement,focused on economics .
http://www.tikkun.org/nextgen/unions-facing-the-trump-era
LikeLike
I completely agree with you Joel. I long thought Sen. Sherrod Brown might fit the bill, but his relative ignorance of education issues now gives me pause. Prior to the election I rationalized the idea that a Trump victory might create a real progressive revival, pretty much the same hopeful conclusion of the article you linked to. Now I’m not so sure. I knew things would get worse. Now I have to find the strength to believe we’ll get through this.
LikeLike
If his chronological age matched his mental age, this boy/man would be considered a spoiled brat and a bully only tolerated because his daddy had lots of money. How do we teach more about “civic, government and citizenship” without being aware that our President has no idea what any of that means? Allowing the “peaceful transition of power” does not mean that we give up our right to free speech and assembly (among other rights) although we have to be careful how we translate that into the classroom. We want our students to understand their rights and responsibilities and how they are and have been defined and interpreted within our government documents and institutions. We want our children to know how to exercise their rights and fulfill their responsibilities.
LikeLike
How are we going to last four more years?
……………
Headline: 10 Trump Fails and Lies from Just This Week @alternet
http://www.alternet.org/election-2016/10-trump-fails-and-lies-just-week#.WHEHCPuSGzs.email
Every post-election week with Donald Trump feels like an eternity. The details change but the story stays the same: Trump whines, lies and pleads for attention, scrambling facts, fiction and conspiracy into a fatiguing, but now familiar blend. Last week followed the same formula, with Trump pretending not to know what he knows and to be an expert in everything he doesn’t know, all while waging petty wars using time that could be spent boning up on policy. …So we don’t forget, here’s a look back at just 10 of Trump’s most recent lies and fails….
LikeLike
The better Alternet link.
http://www.alternet.org/news-amp-politics/lets-impeach-him-now-case-preparing-end-trumps-presidency-it-even-begins
LikeLike
I don’t tweet, I have not got involved in tweeting yet. I just recently started a Facebook page against my better judgment. Relatives and friends encouraged me to start a FB site, I reluctantly obliged. I mostly post pictures but I just recently have been using it to protest the privatization of our schools and Zuckerberg’s appointment of Campbell Brown as his media ombudswoman. Some aspects of FB creep me out so I have no idea how long I will continue with it.
LikeLike
Keep us updated on your experience with FB, Joe. I have not taken the plunge yet, I suspect, for many of the same reasons that kept you waffling.
LikeLike
Thank you for this well written, insightful post. The format of Twitter suits Trump who seems to have no filter for his mouth and a short attention span. I have nothing more to add about Trump other than I fear he will be a tool for the out of touch, extreme right wing of the Republican party.
LikeLike
Here’s a link to a Robert Reich video on how to resist the Trump agenda during the first 100 days. Some of us are already contacting representatives and donating to progressive groups; we need to keep the heat on. It is a short video and worth viewing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sueka7aZLsg
LikeLike
retired teacher
Excellent link. I will be in DC on the 21st. I hope everyone will be at least in the streets of their home towns.
LikeLike
I woke up this morning singing this song and wondering why. Now I know!
Some folks sing opera, some folks sing flat
Some sing like sawing wood, I’m not like that
But when the dickie birds wing in the trees
I feel we ought to try and sing like these
Let’s all sing like the birdies sing
Tweet, tweet, tweet, tweet, tweet
Let’s all sing like the birdies sing
Tweet, tweet, tweet, tweet, tweet
Let’s all warble like nightingales
Give your throats a treat
Take your time from the birds
Now you all know the words
Tweet, tweet, tweet, tweet, tweet
LET’S ALL SING LIKE THE BIRDIES SING
(Robert Hargreaves, Stanley Damerell,Tolchard Evans)
(Transcribed from John Wright’s 78 RPM Record Collection
by Bill Huntley – January 2015)
LikeLike
GE2L2R,
What a nice way to wake up!
I often find myself singing songs from the 40s and 50s as I walk the dog.
Will anyone hum the songs of this era 20 years from now?
LikeLike
Can we “out tweet” the Tweeter?
LikeLike
To tweet, tweet, tweet like the birdies sing requires the brain of a bird – which is probably insulting to actual birds.
LikeLike
LET’S ALL SING LIKE THE BIRDIES SING was first written in 1932, by the team of songwriter Tolchard Evans and lyricists Stanley Damerell and Robert Hargreaves, along with Harry Tilsley. It was first recorded by the BBC Dance Orchestra, directed by Henry Hall (famous for The Teddy Bears’s Picnic) and recorded 19th November 1932.
LikeLike
Global survival is bigger than local politics, and yes even bigger than the US Constitution which is supposed to protect us from crap like Trump.
LikeLike
Trump and all of his appointees agree that global climate change is a hoax.
LikeLike
How long will it take for these people to realize that Trump is not going to be their savior? For me it is had to imagine why Russian interference in our elections is nothing to be concerned about. We will be living with a con man who thinks nothing except what will benefit himself.
……………….
‘What’s the Big Deal?’ Ask Trump Voters on Russia Hacking Report from the NYT
BY CAMPBELL ROBERTSON AND MITCH SMITH
Supporters of President-elect Donald J. Trump have dismissed a report by U.S. intelligence officials accusing Russia of interfering in the election to undermine Hillary Clinton…
But interviews with Trump supporters here in Louisiana, a state the president-elect won by 20 points, and in Indiana, a state he won by nearly the same margin, found opinions about the report that ranged from general indifference to outright derision….
“From the parts of the report I’ve seen,” said Rob Maness, a retired Air Force colonel who twice ran for Senate here as Tea Party favorite, “it seems silly.”…
Of the comments he had seen from fellow Trump supporters on Facebook and in emails, he added, “90 percent of them are like, ‘What’s the big deal?’”…
Even if the Russians did do it — which some were more willing to concede than others — what difference did it make? People did not need the Russians to make up their minds about Mrs. Clinton, Mr. Trump’s election opponent. Blaming her loss on the Russians was, as one Trumpsupporter here said, “just being sore losers.”…
Tina Gunaldo, 44, taking blankets off the citrus trees in her Mandeville, La., front yard after the previous night’s frost, had a similar attitude.
“Trump is Trump,” she said. “Do I think he’s going to become more of a friend to Russia because of this? No I don’t. I think — I hope — his focus will be on making America great again.”
Ms. Gunaldo would not reveal whom she voted for, but she did say Mr. Trump’s slogan resonated with her. It apparently resonated quite widely in this parish, which he won by more than 50 points. But it was a quiet support, she said. She knew of only one yard in the whole subdivision with a sign.
That yard belonged to Thurston Yates Sr.
“I don’t believe it,” Mr. Yates, 78, said flatly of the intelligence report. He was standing in the yard under his “Make America Great Again” flag, which he bought at a gun show several months ago. “Why would Putin even want Trump?”…
LikeLike
LikeLike
Headline in the Washington Post: Trump says his brand is ‘hotter.’ But sales at Trump Tower Mumbai have chilled. from The Washington Post
http://wapo.st/2igxacC?tid=ss_mail
MUMBAI — One stretch of scaffolding along Mumbai’s skyscraper-speckled skyline is especially dense. More than a dozen luxury apartment towers stand unfinished, and their concrete hulls reach up into this seaside city’s thick haze. Among them, one has generated unusual buzz. It is the one that will soon glimmer with a facade of gold-tinted glass, with the name of the president of the United States emblazoned across it…
Then, in 2014, Donald Trump announced that he’d be lending his name to a 75-story building in Shah’s native city, slated for opening in late 2018…
Suparna Salaskar, a former Lodha Group employee who managed interactions with buyers until just a few months ago, said in an interview that she knew of only one unit being sold since Trump announced his candidacy in June 2015. The Lodha spokeswoman did not respond to a request to confirm Salaskar’s observation …
Limaye, the real estate expert, said he wasn’t so sure Trump’s election would be good for the Lodhas. “If the building is delayed by the usual number of years, then it will only open once Trump’s first term is finished,” he said. “And who can predict what his name will signify then?”
………
It would be interesting for Trump to give out his tax returns. It is totally possible that he is overstretched and isn’t as wealthy as he claims. Is his wealth a ponzi scheme?
LikeLike
The leader of the White Trash Party (formerly the GOP).
LikeLike