Public education in California is under siege by people and organizations who want to privatize the schools, remove them from democratic control, and hand them over to the charter industry.
The attack began when Arnold Schwarzenegger was elected governor. He stacked the state board of education with a majority of charter school advocates (even though only 4% of children were enrolled in charters at the time) and slashed billions of dollars from the budget of the public schools.
The attack continues today, as billionaires add their clout to the charter industry. Eli Broad is the point of the spear, with his unaccredited Broad Superintendents Academy, which has “trained” would-be superintendents in his management techniques and sent them out to reorganize schools, and whenever possible, close them down. Broad has proposed to open 260 new charters in Los Angeles, which would mean that 50% of the students in the district would be enrolled in charters. Other billionaires, such as Reed Hastings (CEO of Netflix) and David Welch (of Vergara notoriety), have joined the fight against public schools and their teachers.
The Golden State is often a bellwether for the nation.
Governor Jerry Brown, a progressive on many other issues, has defended the charter industry and blocked efforts to regulate it. California has had some of the biggest charter scandals in the nation, starting with the collapse of the California Charter Academy in 2004, which went bankrupt and stranded 6,000 students. The state has for-profit charters, including the California Virtual Academy (CAVA), which was recently the subject of an expose by Jessica Calefati in the San Jose Mercury-News. CAVA is run by Michael Milken’s K12 Inc. It is one of the worst performing schools in the state, perhaps the very worst. But no action has been taken to close it.
When the legislature passed a bill to prohibit for-profit charter schools, Governor Brown vetoed it. This, despite the fact that America has never had for-profit “public schools” until the rise of the charter industry. An associate of the governor told me that the governor did not believe that for-profit schools are inherently bad. I disagree. Any for-profit organization has profit as its highest priority, not education or children. Governor Brown also vetoed legislation to prohibit charters in one district from opening branches in other districts. He vetoed legislation to bar conflicts of interest in charter schools. Governor Brown opened two charters in Oakland when he was mayor, so he must be partial to them. Nonetheless, it remains baffling that Governor Brown would allow vested interests and advocates of privatization to ruin the state’s public schools.
Unlike many other states, California has a well-financed and formidable organization fighting to expand the power of privately managed charter schools: the California Charter Schools Association. It is active in advancing legislation to protect and advance privatization and to block any effort to rein in their excesses.
Begin your reading at this site, Capital & Main. It contains a series about California and the future of public education.
Not to keep beating the same horse, but just a reminder that Hillary is quite close with Eli Broad, in case anyone was thinking she might be an improvement for public education.
Read it and weep:
LEADING DEMOCRATIC SUPER-LOBBYIST and Hillary Clinton bundler Heather Podesta derided President Obama’s lobbying reforms Wednesday, while laughing off concerns about her own sky-high compensation.
“I think Obama hurt himself by taking such an arms-length posture with the Washington community,” Podesta, a multimillionaire who has represented chemical companies, health insurers, and for profit-colleges, told Vox’s Ezra Klein. “By attacking Washington in that way, there was a bit of a brain drain. And a lost opportunity.”
As for the idea of taking money out of politics, “I just find it preposterous,” she said. It is “not the lobbying class that keeps people from taking hard votes, it’s the member themselves,” Podesta claimed.
The interview was held on Facebook, and a question came in from a viewer: “If lobbyists don’t have more power and influence than a regular person, why are lobbyists paid so much?”
“I think we’re not paid enough,” Podesta replied with a smile, as she and Klein shared a laugh.
Oh, yeah. Labor unions are the problem. They’re getting in the way of these people sucking up every available dollar that is generated.
https://theintercept.com/2016/06/03/heather-podesta/
Reading the echo chamber commentary on Detroit has been interesting.
Here’s former Governor Engler, pretending that ed reformers haven’t been “reforming” Detroit schools since 1999 and ignoring the fact that there are tons of charters in Detroit:
http://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/politics/2016/06/02/engler-detroit-school-group/85319898/
It is literally impossible for these people to fail. When they fail they insist we double down on their methods. There wasn’t “enough” choice, or some public schools were still operating.
Engler insists that his same approach will work as long as the city is completely privatized. He simply omits inconvenient facts and history. Eli Broad “reformed” Detroit in 2012. The whole cheering squad showed up to celebrate- Duncan, Rhee, the whole gang. That recent history has completely disappeared from the “debate”.
The Michael and Susan Dell Foundation is remarkably focused on charter schools for an organization that insists they are about “portfolios”
Why would I hire an ed reform organization if I support existing public schools? Public schools are barely mentioned in the echo chamber.
Sort of silly to insist you’re promoting a “portfolio” when you’re obviously promoting charter schools. I don’t know why we can’t have a real debate on privatization of public schools. Ed reform should have to defend their pro-privatization position to the public.
https://twitter.com/JoeatMSDF
They should have to defend their position before the public. However, since these privatizers are backed by wealthy individuals, it is an easier and more direct process to buy the policymakers. They want to avoid the public because they know they would lose. Citizens support free public education! Privatizers want to stay in the shadows and manipulate from behind the curtain, and unfortunately, they have been quite successful at it.
Boycott of corporations that are aggressively seeking privatization of education–
Start with Netflix, Amazon (Jeff Bezos) and any Walmart/Sams Club. Anything made by Georgia Pacific….(Koch Industries)…..It might not make that much of a difference, but you never know…
Senators Schumer, Whitehouse and Warren, today, shouted out from the D.C. mountain top their outrage at the Koch’s attempts to destroy Social Security, through executive branch appointments. But, Democratic Senators just can’t find GATES in the Dept. of Education.
Bernie’s camp is probably holding out trying to nudge the DNC platform to the left before he offers his support. We should try to get them to support NPE’s petition to stop supporting charters to the detriment of public education.
Agree.
Fallacy of propositional logic
“Propositional logic is a system of formal logic which deals with the logical relations that hold between propositions taken as a whole, and those compound propositions which are constructed from simpler ones with truth-functional connectives.” For instance, consider the following proposition:
Brown was empowered by “democracy” and he excercises democratic control.
This is a compound proposition containing the simpler propositions:
Brown was empowered by “democracy”. He excercises democratic control.
The word “and” which joins the two simpler sentences to make the compound one is a truth-functional connective, that is, the truth-value of the compound proposition is a function of the truth-values of its components. In other words, whether the whole sentence is true or false is determined by whether the simpler sentences that compose it are true or false. The truth-value of a conjunction, that is, a compound proposition formed with “and”, is true if both of its components are true, and false otherwise. So, the compound sentence is true if “Brown was empowered by “democracy”and
“He excercises democratic control.” are both true, and false if one or both are false.
“When the legislature passed a bill to prohibit for-profit charter schools, Governor Brown vetoed it. Governor Brown also vetoed legislation to prohibit charters in one district from opening branches in other districts. He vetoed legislation to bar conflicts of interest in charter schools. Governor Brown opened two charters in Oakland when he was mayor, so he must be partial to them.”
The invocations of “democracy” or “democratic control” continue to clash with
reality, yet they are continued as though they weren’t an illusion.
Does keeping “unreality” in the “mix” improve matters?
Coastal Commission anyone? Bullet Train anyone? Why do we keep saying Brown is progressive?
retired teacher
June 8, 2016 at 10:09 am
They should have to defend their position before the public. However, since these privatizers are backed by wealthy individuals, it is an easier and more direct process to buy the policymakers. They want to avoid the public because they know they would lose. Citizens support free public education! Privatizers want to stay in the shadows and manipulate from behind the curtain, and unfortunately, they have been quite successful at it.”
I don’t know if citizens support it or not but it seems like we should have a real debate before privatizing public schools.
This is a profound change. “Public” does not mean and has never meant ‘publicly-funded” and “nonprofit” is meaningless outside the tax code.
Charter schools are *technically* nonprofits in Ohio. It means absolutely nothing. Obviously.
Similarly, the Gates-funded “Senior Congressional Education Staff Network”, claiming to be non-ideological and non-partisan.
In an oligarchy or, under colonialism, the terms non-profit, non-partisan, non-ideological,… are meaningless obfuscations.
Thanks for putting the spotlight on California, Diane. When local media is in the tank with the reformers, your exposes become even more essential.
Thank you for this! Here is another example of struggle against charters in California…http://contracostaherald.com/031401-2/