This moving article by Steve Lopez of the Los Angeles Times is a tribute to Alan Kaplan, a high school teacher of the humanities, who died at the end of August.
Some 500 former students attended his funeral, driving or flying from wherever they were.
One week ago, very early Sunday morning, Harvard University graduate student Jimmy Biblarz boarded a plane and flew from Boston to Los Angeles to attend a memorial service.
He knew he would have to fly back to Boston later that evening, which made for a grueling day, but Biblarz never had a second thought about making the trip.
The provocative, maddening, abrasive, endearing, passionate, controversial Hamilton High School teacher who tormented, challenged and ultimately inspired him, had died. So Biblarz and hundreds of other students who got the same treatment from history and philosophy teacher Alan Kaplan crowded into the un-air-conditioned school auditorium on a blistering afternoon to pay their respects.
“Each of us spends our time on this Earth trying to ensure we are remembered in death. Mr. Kaplan, you won,” Biblarz said in his eulogy. “You produced hundreds of activists, organizers, scholars, therapists, teachers and thinkers. Your effects are exponential.”
Steve Lopez is one of the few writers for the L.A. Times (add Michael Hiltzik) who understands that teachers are more than test-prep automatons, that they enlighten and inspire in ways that can’t be measured.
“People don’t show up 20 and 30 years later to pay tribute to teachers who helped them do better on standardized tests,” fellow Hamilton High teacher Barry Smolin said at the service, a tape of which was made available to me. “We are here because Alan Kaplan did what all great teachers do. He clarified, he inspired, he awakened, he worked in ways that are unquantifiable.”
As I watched the tributes, I was reminded that from Los Angeles to New York, we have endured years of bare-knuckle battles but reached no consensus on how to improve public schools. Public education is shamefully underfunded, some say, while others insist money is not the answer. You can find equally rabid supporters and critics of charter schools, and the new Common Core curriculum is either a breakthrough or a curse.
But wherever you stand on any of that, we can all go to school on how a teacher managed to touch so many lives in such profound ways, loyal to both his convictions and his students even as his stubborn independence drew critics and even landed him in trouble at times.
Some students were intimidated by Kaplan. Some administrators and fellow teachers found him irritating.
He flat-out refused to teach Advanced Placement history, arguing that the curriculum was a memorization drill that allowed for neither true teaching nor learning.
When he died at the early age of 60, students came from everywhere to thank Alan Kaplan for changing their lives.
Measure that.

Steve Lopez was a columnist for the Philadelphia Inquirer, funny and smart. The best columnist the city has ever seen, and we still miss him. Of course he understands the loss of a great teacher.
LikeLike
Not JUST a teacher but a true EDUCATOR. I differentiate.
WHAT a tribute. I believe that there are many educators like that, maybe not quite that good, but close who are not heard from like this. THANKS for sharing such a tribute.
A fellow music teacher recently died and the line was enormous to pay him tribute. The double or more line extended clear to the doorway, doubling around where it was necessary to accommodate the crowd.
We DO have an influence on the lives of our students, good or bad.
AND it is always appreciated when former students wish us well.
That goes for us to OUR former teachers as well.
LikeLike
Two amazingly gifted Los Angeles teachers lost to us this week. Richard Lakin, who moved to Israel where he was murdered while just taking a bus ride, and now Alan Kaplan. Peace and love, guys.
LikeLike
“He flat-out refused to teach Advanced Placement history,”
Amen, brother Kaplan!
There was pressure on me to teach AP Spanish and I steadfastly refused (even though I was “certified”-a week long 3 hour graduate credit class to learn how to teach to the test-to teach it). I always said that I was already teaching what needed to be taught and that if the students wanted to take the test they could, against which I advised because unless they were native speakers there wasn’t hardly anyway that they would score above a 3 and all the universities considered a 3 as worthless. “Don’t waste the money” I used to tell them.
AP = BE!
LikeLike
Very touching!
Reading this account took me forever, as I could not see the print through my tears. Great part of my reaction is related to the Abuse and Death of our honorable profession – teaching. We gave it our ALL because that’s what we do!
Teaching reminds me often of a parallel – fire fighters. Most of us would not become fire fighters, but those men and women do it, because …this is what they do. Noble humans!
LikeLike
Don’t forget to read about how Mr. Kaplan met his wife Erin Aubrey Kaplan, a columnist for the anti-teacher L.A. Weekly, among other papers. It’s a great story in itself!!! I had heard about Mr. Kaplan for years — he is the one teacher who inspired so many many students — at least that I’ve known. I’m sure there are more in Los Angeles but this man knew how to infuriate one with just the right touch.
LikeLike
A strange pairing Joan. Erin occasionally writes op eds for the LA Times, and usually they are full of anger. A case of opposites attracting? And BTW, I do not read LA Weekly due to their anti teacher, anti public school, pro Parent Rev and charter, bias.
LikeLike
I was so surprised to read your characterization of Erin Aubry’s op eds as “full of anger.” I can’t remember thinking any were “full of anger” and usually found them to be spot on.And “a case of opposites attracting?” would imply Alan was not angry. Did you know him?
LikeLike
It’s nice to know that this teacher was remembered for challenging and inspiring his students. He was tough when he had to be tough. He had standards and refused to be a cookie-cutter teacher. I wish this new generation of teachers could learn what it means to not be afraid to buck the system.
LikeLike
Before your great teachers die, please let them know the positive differences they made in your life.
LikeLike
And that my friends is why we got into education. Or at least the teachers I know and respect. Teaching students to think and act beyond what they believed they could, as well as a role model for others to have moral courage. A life of service always has meaning.
LikeLike
In fact, DO TELL OTHERS about YOUR GREAT TEACHERS, too. Do it now. So tired of those who blame the ills of society on our PUBLIC school teachers, who are truly as a group one of our national treasures.
LikeLike
Tears…beautiful, simply beautiful.
LikeLike
To whom it may concern:
Whoever worries that teachers cannot make a living after they quit teaching job, please read this thread.
Yes, true educators cannot be intimidated, or bought out, because they master their teaching skills in motivating,and persuading people or learners to believe in themselves in a way, as in:
[start quote]
“”Kaplan implored them NOT to believe everything they THOUGHT they knew about one another, the world or themselves.””
“”He taught critical thinking. He demanded conceptual clarity””
“”He clarified, he inspired, he awakened, and he WORKED IN A WAY that is un-quantifiable.””
“”He produced hundreds of activists, organizers, scholars, therapists, teachers and thinkers. His effects are exponential””
[end quote]
In conclusion, true educators will always enlighten and inspire learners in ways that can’t be measured. Back2basic
LikeLike
Diane, have you seen this?
https://m.facebook.com/wendy.bradshaw1/posts/10206677508354085?locale2=en_US&__tn__=%2As
LikeLike