Robert Rendo, a National Board Certified Teacher who often comments, posted these remarks:
You know, I’m a public school teacher, and I watched the debates, and they had a veritable tone and texture of something I could not quite put my finger on, but now I finally have.
I finally see that the debates took on the tenor of a hybrid between a reality show and American Idol, where each contestant had a swagger and self promoting, self-absorbed aura, and each judge was snarky and “gotcha” instead of provocative and fact finding. Each judge would lunch a torpedo at the contestant and the contestant would launch a bigger one back to the judge and/or to an opponent. It became a sport of sardonic badminton, with acidic, self aggrandizing and self congratulatory remarks as the shuttlecock.
There were smirks, grins, chuckles, and sarcastic rolling of the eyes. There was pivoting of the head side to side to indicate disapproval and raised eyebrows to show defensiveness.
There were myriad retorts from the Mr. cheap-shot-and-shinily-packaged Moliere himself, Donald Trump, and there were startling confessions about abortion from Scott Walker, who has always put women in a metaphorical state of being buried up to the neck and stoned. This was indicated unabashedly by the ultra-chauvinistic Walker, whose own wife he would seemingly have die in order to give birth to a baby that would put her life at grave risk. Or, heaven forbid, if Walker’s wife were brutally raped and had horrible memories and neurosis from the experience, Walker, according to his own principles, would still make her give birth to the ensuing and permanent reminder.
Walker said at one point before these debates that he is prepared to sign into law a 20-week abortion ban without any exceptions for victims of rape or incest, arguing that women are concerned with those issues “in the initial months” of pregnancy.
I guess he would know since he is a man.
Walker is the picture-perfect poster boy for the mediocrity American culture has raised as its highest level of expression: moronic, simple minded, very well funded, political connected, masterfully deceptive, and vested in state authority.
My point is that these candidates are frightening, incompetent, narcissistic, oligarchical, and just plain off-the-wall-crazy.
Between Rand Paul proudly declaring that the GOP has worked hard for over a decade to oppose a single payer healthcare system and Donald Trump asserting, pre-debate, to Cher that he has no rug atop his head, that “It’s the real thing”, and that he pledges not to discuss her “numerous unsuccessful plastic surgeries”, I could not help but think that this debate was an ultimate symbol for the disconnect between the average American person and the plutocrats who live and work in an Super PAC tower.
There was therefore nothing amusing about the debates, even if they read like a snarky stand up comedy competition.
There are tens of millions of people in this country who are suffering horribly.
People are saddled with higher education debt, never able to buy a home, sick and dying as a result of lack of access to Obamacare in which the compulsory insurance policies do not cover a condition or the premiums have shot up, stuck with their kids in once-excellent public schools that have been starved of legitimate funding and reduced to a skeletal staff, and dumbed down by the paucity of real journalism, that is now controlled by corporate agendas and bought media. People are under the oppression
of bad medicine, adulterated food, long work hours that lead to no promotion and stagnant wages, and the maintenance of instrastructral services that the very rich also depend on but don’t pay for, such as roads, bridges, tunnels, energy, and public transportation.
The GOP debate had almost no dignity and even less truth to it. These debaters are bonafide looney, dangerous, and disconnected, no differently than had been Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette, who lived isolated and opulent lives in grand palaces and who eventually faced a fate our current politicians might one day face, according to Picketty.
How could I not vote for Sanders?

Journalists need to press candidates on policy and implementation, not fluff and ideology. When Bush promises 4% GDP growth, we need to know for whom and how. That level of growth is very difficult and if JEB! has a plan, let’s hear it and score it. When Kasich says he balanced the Federal budget, the public should know he voted against the budgets and was asked to wait out in the hall while the meetings took place. When Walker brags about tax cuts and oppressing teachers, journalists might want to see why he only created 1/2 the jobs he promised resulting in a Wisconsin budget train wreck. When Trump, … never mind.
LikeLike
True that, and yet, Hillary Clinton is only more polished, not otherwise different. Maybe on abortion — but it is the wealth inequality that leads to many abortions….
LikeLike
These are all interesting questions. I would hope that you propose some of these for the next debate. There will be around 9 more. I was disappointed at the lack of questions presented to most of them. I liked the debates the night before. The Jr debate with Perry and Fiorinna et all was interesting and revealing. This is the purpose–to weed down the pack. Ideology IS important as well as implementation which is always the problem. I think that Trump will self destruct and more will come out about Walker and Bush. Give the process a chance. When the numbers decrease, more questions of substance will emerge. I agree that the commentators of the large debate were asking personal questions but look how Trump responded as well as Walker and the obvious lack of understanding about Common Core on the part of Bush was obvious. They should have asked Kasich on that issue as well. Hang in there.
LikeLike
the social media is sort of threatening the mainstream traditional press……which is always asserting their importance in being able to do the necessary job of sorting out what matters from what does not. So……1.fiorino is supposed to matter, and I would agree if she ever debated Hillary, but I doubt it happens. 2.They seem even more careful, until the orders come down, to refrain from mentioning education as an issue that matters to “the average voter”. 3.Rubio is supposed to matter. 4.Kasich is the choice to soothe the nerves about Bush. 5.Paul is toast. (their sportswriters are saying the St. Louis Cardinals might make it into the post season). 6.Trump will drop several points in the polls. 7. Walker was too quiet. 8. Chris Christie is not a sickening piece of horse defecation, and it goes without saying that he has more right to punch public school teachers in the face than Trump does to repost what somebody said about Megyn being a bimbo. I guess of all these…….I disagree with numbers 8 and 7, but the rest I am not sure of….Trump should drop, because they seem to be dragging the poll taking until they can get the full story in…….and……if anyone is curious about the technical aspects of Trump switching from GOP to independent…..you know….the laws, the date necessary to decide or just forget it…….all that stuff too complicated for the media to bother with when all they have to say is he will elect Hillary if he does that…….I can tell you. I spoke personally with well informed experts. It is important, but not of much interest.
LikeLike
It was a circus and the RNC knows that. Good reality TV, but embarrassing for our country.
LikeLike
How I love the way you express the truth Robert… Perfect!
In a comment here, recently you said this… so wonderful and appropriate to repeat it here:
“When for many years the tall strapping moose has been tethered to a fence in the desert with little water and is then set free to be in his best environment, he does not know better to drink from the lush pond in the forest and avoids it, thinking it does not exist. This is the exact metaphor I use for people who have so much excellent information around them and just don’t know that it exists or how to use it. And they are so limited in their mindset that when they even hear (mind you, not god forbid READ!) about some news from a breath of fresh air, they don’t process it well because they can’t critically think and connect vital dots that explain their misery and suffering.
” Hence, people – poor and working class – end up voting against their own interests because big mommy and daddy corporate media outlets portray a politician this way or that way when all along, the voting record can be researched and digested objectively. There are even many, many educated people who behave this way also when it comes to making a decision about who to vote for. This uninformed and under-informed mindset is not limited to people without higher education by any far stretch of the imagination.”
Robert, you also described, in that post, so many of our fellow Americans who watched that debate.
I particularly love your metaphors and the way you have of using adjective phrases to identifying personalities like:
“the average passive, facebooking, mall shopping, cable TV watching, refined sugar slopping (my favorite), car driving American”I have met this person. You nailed the average American with this one, and it scares me that they have no idea what these candidates are saying or that they owe their allegiance to the oligarchs who put the $$$ in their PACs… worse, they do not know who the Koch brothers are, no less what they are up to.
…and BTW, good luck when you go back to the grind, and summer’s coach turns back into a pumpkin.
LikeLike
Mr. Rendo’s commentary is on target and among the best I’ve seen. Reminds me of Postman’s warnings in his book “Amusing Ourselves to Death”.
LikeLike
Y’all know I hate to be picky but—
Yes, it was a Bad Reality Show because it was a Good Rheeality Show, done in a most Johnsonally sort of fashion.
Ok, now that I’ve got that out of my system…
😎
LikeLike
You’re so Krazy . . . .
LikeLike
I think Roger Ailes knew that the Kochonuts would do their thing, as they had for recently. I think he realized that there would be a huge audience, and that the questions needed to hit home, and let these crazies who aspire to run our nation at this crucial moment in history, would be unable to contain themselves.
Trump in particular, never expected to be confronted with the questions, and the coven as a whole, did not grasp that their poor grasp of women’s issues, and IT WAS CLEAR that they were ignorant of the fact that at least 50% of voters are, hmmm…. WOMEN!
The party line hangs women out to dry… and they just didn’t get it, that by gathering them all into ONE place their animosity would shine and shout, lots and clear…we are dim-wits.
The GOP leadership, however, got the message, when they opened champaign bottles at the Hillary and Bernie headquarters.
LikeLike
Kochonuts? Excellent!
LikeLike
LOL. it just came to me. I think Kochonuts should become a meme for the monsters that you describe.
LikeLike
I dread watching another clown show as this primary gears up. Then we get the same show with the final election.
I am going to take a good look at the Green Party and their candidate Dr. Jill Stein.
LikeLike
Are you considering Sanders also?
LikeLike