Gail Collins, formerly chief editorial writer for The New York Times and now a regular columnist, has a hilarious column today about Governor Scott Walker of Wisconsin.
This is a man who seriously should not be in contention for the Republican presidential nomination.
Collins says he needs an eraser to take care of the mistakes and drafting errors that plague his speeches and statements.
She writes about his Big Speech to conservative activists in Iowa:
Mainly, though, The Speech was about waging war on public employee unions, particularly the ones for teachers. “In 2010, there was a young woman named Megan Sampson who was honored as the outstanding teacher of the year in my state. And not long after she got that distinction, she was laid off by her school district,” said Walker, lacing into teacher contracts that require layoffs be done by seniority.
All of that came as a distinct surprise to Claudia Felske, a member of the faculty at East Troy High School who actually was named a Wisconsin Teacher of the Year in 2010. In a phone interview, Felske said she still remembers when she got the news at a “surprise pep assembly at my school.” As well as the fact that those layoffs happened because Walker cut state aid to education.
Actually, Wisconsin names four teachers of the year, none of which has ever been Megan Sampson, who won an award for first-year English teachers given by a nonprofit group. But do not blame any of this on Sampson, poor woman, who was happily working at a new school in 2011 when Walker made her the star victim in an anti-union opinion piece in The Wall Street Journal. At the time, she expressed a strong desire not to be used as a “poster child for this political agenda,” and you would think that after that the governor would leave her alone. Or at least stop saying she was teacher of the year.
When it comes to education, Walker seems prone toward this sort of intellectual hiccup. Just recently, he released a proposed budget that would have changed the University of Wisconsin’s mission statement by eliminating the bits about “the search for truth,” educating people and serving society, in favor of the educational goal of meeting “the state’s work force needs.” When all hell broke loose, Walker blamed that one on a drafting error.
She notes that Walker wants to change teacher licensing, so teachers need not have any teacher education or training to teach. “Life experience” would count instead. Anyone should be able to teach, like in the early 19th century. This is a man who seriously doesn’t care about education.

This one is good too. http://www.newyorker.com/humor/borowitz-report/republican-voters-responding-walkers-opposition-knowledge
LikeLike
I have always loved the New Yorker magazine. This article was delightful.
LikeLike
Walker is a typical, union busting, know nothing bully so common among Republicans. My main question is how to these people keep winning elections?
LikeLike
Saying Walker is a bully is giving him too much credit for thinking. Walker is a dull, Koch puppet who does what he is told. These people keep winning because the electorate makes decisions based on sound bytes and echo chambers.
LikeLike
They win elections because teachers, in a time of bad economic conditions and extreme income inequality, are scapegoats. Those of us still teaching have jobs, health care and pensions. What’s not to hate. Walker and his ilk are adept at arguing convincingly that teachers should not have it any better than the ordinary shmo who is either unemployed, or underemployed and working without any job security or pension protection. And they also win because they, essentially, run unopposed. The Democrats have no message anymore for the oppressed, and the common folks who once would have voted in droves for a populist candidate stay home. Until progressives walk out of the Democratic Party and say, enough, I see no way that the Walkers of this world can be stopped. It’s human nature. The same thing happened in Europe in the thirties and the only reason it didn’t happen here then is because we were fortunate to have FDR. Today, we have Obama and Duncan, both of them nothing mor than Clinton retreads who have only one goal in mind as 2016 approaches – guaranteeing their million dollar retirements.
LikeLike
It may sound trite, but they win because not enough Democrats vote for their own candidates. Voter turnout for Democrats was awful compared to Republic voter turnout last year.
We win the war of ideas, of policy, of values, but not enough of us vote so people like Walker win.
LikeLike
It would be nice if Democrats had their own candidates to vote for.
LikeLike
Why would anyone expect a person who left college during his senior year (under a cloud of suspicion, I might add) to have any understanding or respect for the teaching profession?
LikeLike
“This is a man who seriously should not be in contention for the Republican presidential nomination.”
Agreed. But who should be?
And to be fair, I have the same question for the Democrats. Hillary is a Republican in all but name. Warren still insists she isn’t running, and even if she does, she’s not half as liberal as people give her credit for (albeit though, she is many times better than Hillary). Bernie Sanders would be the best possible choice, but there are three chances he’ll get the nomination: slim, fat and none. Has any other potential Democratic nominee even been mentioned?
LikeLike
Jerry Brown?
Bernie Sanders, I hope, decides to run in the Democratic primaries so there is some progressive challenge to Hillary, and when he loses because the corporate Wall Street and Clinton Foundation have pre-determined the outcome, I hope he runs a third-party campaign so I have something and someone to vote for.
I agree with Eugene Debs. I would rather vote for what I want and not get it than vote for what I don’t want and get it (see Barack Obama). The revolution has to start some time.
LikeLike
I would rather vote for what I want and not get it than vote for what I don’t want and get it (see Barack Obama).
You’re a bonehead. Politics is mostly about compromise, and your thinking is exactly what got us the destructive Bush-Cheney regime.
LikeLike
billyjoe,
What got us Bush/Cheney was vote tampering in Ohio. Just ask Michael Connell.
(Michael Louis Connell (November 30, 1963 – December 19, 2008) was a high-level Republican consultant who was subpoenaed in a case regarding alleged tampering with the 2004 U.S. Presidential election and a case involving thousands of missing emails pertaining to the political firing of U.S. Attorneys.)
Oh, what we can’t ask him?
(Connell was killed when the plane he was flying crashed on December 19, 2008 [by the way a favorite tactic for eliminating folks]).
I thought billyjoe died back in the sixties:
LikeLike
Hey, Billyjoe, please, as I have to tell my 7th graders when we have a debate in class, no name calling. We can disagree and still be civil.
But I see your point. Politics is about compromise. That’s true, but only sometimes. Lincoln, I take it, should have compromised with the slaveholders from your neck of the woods (Choctaw Ridge)? FDR should have compromised with the Republicans who opposed Social Security and work relief, and the Isolationists who were comfortable with a Nazi Europe? MLK should have called off the March on Washington and counted on the Democrats to do the right thing, eventually?
Your response suggests to me that you believe that the election of Hillary Clinton will restore public education as it is meant to be to this nation, but I believe you are seriously off the mark. Her compromises with Wall Street mean that her administration on issues that matter to me would be, in no important way, any different from a Republican one, no matter who they nominate. I will support and vote for a candidate who has a message for common people that is pro- public schools, anti-Wall Street, and against militarism. If that candidate doesn’t win, well, the revolution has to start somewhere. Lincoln lost a few before he won.
Oh, and about Eugene Debs. That bonehead ran for president while imprisoned in Georgia in 1920 for exercising his right to free speech in opposition to Wilson’s war to make the world safe for democracy. Your logic, Billyjoe, seems to be that Debs’ run in 1920 must have helped Warren Harding win. My logic tells me that Debs’ run staked out the positions which the public was finally ready to support, after twelve years of Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover, when FDR took the reins in 1933.
By the way, I don’t think Harding was all bad. He commuted Debs’ sentence, something Wilson wouldn’t do, on Christmas Day, 1921!
Have a great day.
LikeLike
billyjoe – and your way of thinking is what’s gotten us eight years of Obama, otherwise known as Bush’s third and fourth terms.
LikeLike
But he has been elected twice in a state that once had a strong liberal base…..how did that happen?
LikeLike
Because the Democrats offer no other alternative. Bruce Rauner just won in Illinois which is, supposedly, one of the bluest of blue states. And it’s not because people overwhelmingly voted for Rauner, but that they voted against the Democrat, Quinn. Our Democratic senator who was up for re-election (Durbin) got more than enough votes to win had he been running against Rauner, which indicates that a large number of people left the governor’s line blank or voted third-party for governor. I would like to think that these sorts of events could be a lesson for the Democrats to move further left, but all they seem to be doing is moving further right.
LikeLike
The national Democrats abandoning public schools are one question (and perhaps a lost cause) but the state level Democrats are even more baffling.
They’ve lost nearly the whole upper midwest- OH, MI, WI, IL. The Democrat who won was in PA and HE ran on supporting public schools.
It’s as if their goal is to be indistinguishable from the Republican and lose every governorship.
Those huge piles of ed reform cash must be obscuring their ability to look at a map and notice they’ve lost state after state after state attacking public schools 🙂
LikeLike
Looks like Andrew Cuomo wants New York to join the Republican club too.
LikeLike
The only difference at the state level is the Republicans promise to cut taxes. They don’t really, they just push the taxes down and increase taxes on lower income people, but still.
That leaves the Democrat with “I’m exactly like the Republican except I won’t promise to cut your taxes”
You’d think they would figure this out, what with all the consultants and think tanks and such 🙂
Maybe they don’t care. They pretty much agree with the Republican who wins, right? It’s all good! 🙂
LikeLike
Which is why I am hoping Bernie Sanders runs and a real Progressive movement takes off and in the process either remakes of supplants the Democrats. It’s going to be difficult because, as Bernie says, we no longer live in a democracy, we are ruled by oligarchs.
LikeLike
He always needs “Erasor” to fix his problems.
LikeLike
Right on, Ken Watanabe.
LikeLike
Gail Collins is jumping the shark here with a Brian Williams-esqe lie (or maybe she is just too lazy to check her facts). She writes Walker was responsible for cuts in education in 2010 which resulted in the teacher being layed off. Sorry Gail, Walker didn’t become Governor until 2011 so had nothing to do with any budget cuts. In fact, his reforms aged teacher jobs when he came into office. Have fun in your little liberal la-la land!
LikeLike
Many people remember he is the one who attempted to turn the clock back to the 19th century industiral revolution age mindset, and viola! He blew it off everything, and upset over a million. Definitely, he’s one of the weakest links in GOP camp. His erasor is too big to handle. He could even erase his brain from the canvas.
LikeLike
Actually Scott it was Felske, the real Teacher of the Year that year, that said that the those layoffs happened because Walker cut state aid to education. It was Felske’s mistake, not Gail Collin’s.
LikeLike
As far as his plan to cut $300million budget on UW Madison is concerned, I wouldn’t be surprised to hear the reason why teachers were getting fired. His plan makes many people hostile–regardless of the party they are rooting for.
LikeLike
Walker represents the dark side of populism. If you want to understand Walker’s appeal. take a look at Richard Hofstadter’s seminal book, “Anti Intellectualism In American Life”
There is a lot of country between the coasts and Walker’s brand of populism resonates positively with the very population who has no need or desire to read the NYT. For this segment of the citizenry, Walker’s lack of a college degree, his spelling errors and his failure to remember the teachers of the year, provokes a positive reaction.
Let’s be clear eyed. Walker could be the right wing’s new poster boy. Given the current domination of the right wing in the Republican Party. Walker, like Chris Christie,
could well turn his political efforts to making a serious run for the Party nomination. We can make fun of Walker; that requires no effort. We would like to see him hoisted by his own petard, but that is a crap shoot. It will require a concerted, coordinated effort to strip him of his electability and the state level Democrats have failed miserably in their efforts.
LikeLike
This weasel could easily win the nomination. I have no doubt at all about that.
LikeLike
Republicans win because they get people who should know better, to vote Republican anyway. I grew up in a poor, backward state. If any state should be a blue state it’s my home state. But it’s one of the reddest states out there. it’s all God, guns, and freedom. And a whole, whole lot of racism to boot. It took me several years to finally see just how racist the right is. I’ll never understand claiming to be a Christian, but having so little compassion for your fellow man. Not only do they lack compassion, they have contempt for them.
They are so afraid “the man” will take their money and give it to a black or brown family. Yet they have no clue of how much “the man” gave to Wall Street in 2008, under a Republican administration. And when you try to explain it, they say it’s to complicated, plus we need the banks so the whole economy fails. That’s your Republican party right there. Good ol nationalist, racist, fascist types.
And the Republicans are just like ISIS, you have to get farther and farther extreme to be relevant.They are just ridiculous these days, and Scott Walker may be the worst one.
LikeLike
Vote 3rd party. Bernie Sanders is the ONLY one who makes any sense. The DEMs and REPs are bought and sold.
LikeLike
Bernie Sanders is 76 years old. He’s the left’s answer to Ron Paul, and equally unelectable.
LikeLike
You’re right. We should just dutifully report to the polls every four years and choose between the two corporatist offerings available and then go home, watch reality TV and forget about it all. Anyone know when the next Dancing With the Stars is starting?
LikeLike
I don’t know Dienne. I am busy with The Bachelor.
LikeLike
Don’t forget to leave some room on the DVR for the Two and a half Men finale, 9pm Thursday, CBS.
LikeLike
How are Wisconsin public schools doing under ed reform? Any improvements yet?
That’s how we’re holding ed reformers accountable, right? They were supposed to improve public schools. That was the sales pitch they made to the public.
Number of vouchers distributed, charter schools opened, declining membership in public sector unions are all “successes” of the ed reform movement, I get that, but MOST children attend the unfashionable and much-maligned public school “sector”
How can we hold them accountable if they move the goalposts the minute they get elected?
LikeLike
Chiara, the students in Milwaukee are the ones most affected by “reforms” like vouchers and charters. Milwaukee is one of the score of cities tested by NAEP. It is one of the lowest-performing urban districts in the nation, only slightly ahead of Detroit.
Also, before Scott Walker became governor, Wisconsin already had one of the highest graduation rates in the nation. It was in a tie with another state (I think it was New Hampshire) for the highest–at 91+%.
LikeLike
http://nces.ed.gov/ccd/tables/ACGR_2010-11_to_2012-13.asp
Wisconsin:
2010-11: 87%, tied for 2nd in country
2011-12: 88%, tied for 2nd
2012-13: 88%. tied for 2nd
Iowa was first in the country all three years.
LikeLike
Looks like the Gail Collins is the one that needs the eraser.
Sad that she probably knew the facts were wrong but didn’t want this to interfere with her hit piece in Walker.
LikeLike