A new report on Florida’s education budget found that vouchers will divert $1.3 billion from public schools this year alone. This is money that goes mainly to religious schools that meet no accountability standards and are free to discriminate and ignore state and federal laws.
The amount of public money being spent on private schools in Florida has increased substantially since 2019, according to a new report by the Florida Policy Institute and the Education Law Center.
The analysis estimates that some $1.3 billion in taxpayer funds will be diverted school vouchers this year, amounting to 10% of the overall funding the state earmarked for public school districts for the 2022-2023 school year.
“This enormous increase in the flow of public dollars to fund private education has happened so quickly that many Floridians are likely unaware of the financial impact being placed upon public school districts and the way these voucher programs are affecting the availability of their tax dollars for public education,” the report reads in part.
Private schools don’t have to comply with federal civil rights laws or state laws on standardized testing, teacher certification or certain building codes in the way that public schools do.
Leon County Schools Superintendent Rocky Hanna, who spoke at a press conference about the report’s findings, said expanding vouchers is taking away resources away from traditional public schools.
“Enough is enough,” Hanna said. “What’s happening is, we are diverting funds from students with special needs, from students who otherwise are going to lose programs that are vitally important to their academic success later in life….”
The report – titled ‘Florida’s Hidden Voucher Expansion’ – traces the growth in the state’s voucher programs to 2019, when the state legislature created the Family Empowerment Scholarship or FES.
State lawmakers expanded the program in 2021, loosening the qualifications for applying and rolling two other voucher programs into the FES – the McKay Scholarship and Gardiner Scholarship, which set aside funding for students with disabilities.
Now, families who make nearly $100,000 a year are able to qualify for the FES. Students are no longer required to have attended public schools to apply for a voucher; now, students who were homeschooled can also qualify. Families also have greater flexibility in how the funds can be spent, including on transportation, private tutoring, online learning and other costs.
The impact of the vouchers on school districts varies depending on how much they rely on state versus local money. Funding for the FES comes from the Florida Education Finance Program or FEFP – which allocates money on a per student basis and is a key source of revenue for local school districts.
The report estimates that in the Miami-Dade school district, $225 million will be diverted to private schools in the 2022-2023 school year, amounting to “8% of the district’s total FEFP budget”.
Bacardi Jackson is the Interim Deputy Legal Director for Children’s Rights at the Southern Poverty Law Center. She argues that diverting public funds into private schools is part of a long legacy of undermining students’ equal access to education – especially Black students.
Open the link and read on.

This is money that goes mainly to religious schools”
This should be no surprise.
DeSantis has made it perfectly clear that he is on a 21st century Crusade for Christ:
“Put on the full armor of God. Stand firm against the left’s schemes. You will face flaming arrows, but if you have the shield of faith, you will overcome them, and in Florida we walk the line here. And I can tell you this, I have only begun to fight.” Ron DeSantis, February 2022, Hillsdale College
Of course, Bible thumping Republicans just love this stuff, but anyone who is the least bit independent would do well to heed Maya Angelou’s warning that when someone tells you who they are, you should believe them the first time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
yup
LikeLike
More to the point: Crusade for a White Male Christ
LikeLike
Crusades are always for and by White males.
The Knights Templar (dressed in white with a red cross) would never have gone on a Crusade for a Black Christ in a million years.
LikeLike
Even though Christ was in all likelihood darker (olive) skinned.
LikeLike
And of course, the White Knights of the KKK crusade only for a lily White Christ.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Trump: ‘I Love the Poorly Educated’ Duh.
LikeLike
Well, not true (like everything else Trump ever said). But they certainly love him.
LikeLike
DeSantis is another politician that never attended public schools, and he fails to understand their essential role in a democracy. In truth, he does not care about democracy much. He sees education as a personal responsibility, and an almost universal voucher puts him that much closer to his goal. His own children will get a stellar education in any case, and he does not care about other people’s children.
LikeLike
OIh, but he does. He does care about eliminating democracy and replacing it with rule by The Party,
LikeLike
There’s plenty of money in Flor-uh-duh to spend kidnapping migrants in Texas and flying them to Martha’s Vineyard. But I have to run now. Under a mandatory evacuation order. May you live in interesting times goes the old curse.
LikeLike
Stay safe, Bob!
LikeLike
If you pretend to be a migrant by milling around the Texas statehouse with a “Florida or Bust” sign , you can probably get a free ride to Martha’s Vineyard to avoid the storm.
Of course, you would first have to get to Texas. But maybe DeSantis intends to start up migrant flights to Texas, as well.
LikeLike
Also, for those now living on Martha’s vineyard , this is now the time to visit San Antonio, Texas for cheap.
Just buy a one way ticket to San Antonio and then mill around the San Antonio Mayor’s office (or wherever it is that DeSantis looks for victims) with a Florida or Bust sign to get a free ticket back to Martha’s Vineyard.
LikeLike
$1,300,000,000! That would be the equivalent of giving each of the state’s 176,537 public school teachers $7,363.90 each. Would be better spent by giving them raises and money for supplies. Astounding. And we’ve pissed away more than than in Ohio!
LikeLike
Shout out to Gates, Aspen, Harvard School of Education, and state Catholic Conferences for setting up the conditions for the ripoff of taxpayers, communities and students.
LikeLike
Why the hell aren’t all the supe adminimals on the streets shouting about this travesty? O, yea a couple are mentioned but it should be every damn one of them including the asst supe admimials, building adminimals, etc. . . .
When those involved don’t stand up for the children. . . . . . Spineless self absorbed bunch they are.
LikeLike
You point to a problem. The year before I retired, our county got a new super. She was introduced to me in the hall one day when she was new. I suggested that she call the newspaper and announce the county’s refusal to participate in testing, as it has been proven illogical on the face of it. She looked at me terrified.
I guess I understand. She buys into the whole testing thing, or she would not be employed. Now that testing regimen has been in place for twenty years, there is not an administrator who does not buy into this sham. All the others have gone away.
I do not know what is to be done.
LikeLiked by 1 person
If you support school choice, you don’t understand what public education is intended to do. If that fundamental lack of understanding of democratic governance leads you to believe education is a strictly financial endeavor, you have no place in any elected position. Voucher and charter proponents are too dumb to run.
LikeLike
Have you considered just why these parents want their children in charter or public schools? Your comments suggest that you are only looking at from a financial loss. Give parents what they want for their children or at least what tax dollars are paying for. Be competitive, entice them back or suffer with your inaction. Perhaps the laws you speak of can be changed. Many parents have been paying out of pocket in addition to paying high taxes for years. I have 8 grands being home schooled and they pay for nearly everything in addition to high school taxes. Where is the fairness?
I do not see what migrants, Texas, the KKK, the crusades and Martha’s Vinyard have to do with this topic.
LikeLike
School choice doesn’t foster better education, just better marketing. Thank you to Peter Greene for that one. And it’s true. Public schools have to spend money on students, not in slick marketing and high salaries for administration.
LikeLike
I neglected to mention the Taliban.
I apologize for the obvious oversight.
LikeLike
Vouchers for Christian madrasas, you know.
LikeLike
April,
If you read the Dyer article that followed, you know that in Ohio the kids who use vouchers fall behind the peers they left in public school. Why leave a good school to go to a bad school? Why should the government pay parents to home school? Why should I or anyone else pay taxes to send children to be indoctrinated in another religion? Or to a school that would not admit my own children?
LikeLike
Mommy -conferred diplomas for April’s grandkids- the next generation of MAGA and QANON.
I don’t want one dime of my tax dollars for the Featherkile homeschool rip-off.
LikeLike
Let the parents decide what schools they want their children attend. The scores coming out of the public schools are lacking. Homeschoolers and private school parents pay taxes to schools they are not using plus they must pay for their books. Not that many actually use any public-school classes or facilities. I am retired so don’t talk to me about paying for the education of children. We must all pay for the future of our country. We must accept the rights of parents and cultural and religious beliefs. What makes the NEA and the Dept of Education the authorities on the education of anyones children? I have 14 grands and can compare all of them in educational abilities. They all differ. It would be hard to pick out the homeschoolers..
LikeLike
Sorry. I don’t want to pay for private decisions to homeschool or send to a religious school that wouldn’t admit my grandchildren.
If you want to homeschool, that’s your right. Don’t expect taxpayers to pay you for it, anymore than they would pay for you to build a swimming pool.
LikeLike
April’s family found the worst and least efficient way to educate students. They are like all grifters wanting to profit from bogus products, except they are worse, they want to take from their neighbors, not some distant schmuck.
April should just walk around the neighborhood and ask the people to give her money for nothing in return.
LikeLike
April– “Give parents what they want for their children or at least what tax dollars are paying for.”
Public schools are supported by the entire society. So what’s good for society as a whole– balanced by what all taxpayers are willing to pay– is what should be shaping pubsch policy. Parents of children currently in K12 represent only 1/3 of the total number of individual taxpayers. Then there are businesses, whose property & other taxes comprise 35%-45% of state and local revenue. Adding in sales taxes, and their share of the fed govt’s input to school budgets, I figure parents of school-aged children’s share of the cost of public schooling is about 1/4.
But it’s not like they have no voice. 88% of school districts are run by locally-elected schboard members. Go to those mtgs [or watch on local cable]: majority of attendees are parents of current K12 students, and their voice has great influence. Except that, the more fractured their communities are into traditional/ charter/ voucher/ homeschoolers– the more diminished their voice. The parents of charter and voucher students are elsewhere– trying to influence the boards of their charter and voucher schools, where they have less (if any) voice. Homeschoolers’ parents are most likely at home.
What is the premium to public of providing “school choice,” i.e. running a 3+- tier schoolsys? [The “+” is for homeschoolers, if granted vouchers]. Only a few states are transparent about these costs, but judging from the article (and just applying common sense), it is significant. What does the public get in return? Charter schools in most states have to meet state curriculum standards, but studies show no difference in their ed achievement. Voucher schools are generally held to no standards, and studies show negative results. So, pay more for same or lower ed results… The only quid pro quo appears to be school choice for that 1/4 of the paying public.
BTW, the NEA and the Dept of Ed don’t run decisions on the degree of tax-supported school choice. That’s a state decision.
LikeLike
Kind of sort of off topic, but it’s still about Florida…
One of my fears was that Florida would get a big hurricane late in the season. DeSantis would be on the air frequently with press conferences as FL governors do during hurricanes. He is especially good at this as he zig zags the state giving multiple pressers a week. As people watch more live local news than normal during the storm and its aftermath, those on the fence would be like, “Well, he’s not as bad as I thought, and he handled the hurricane well.”
As I watch coverage on the local ABC in Orlando, I’m seeing a slew of pro-Republican ads for candidates at every level during every break. I’ve only seen one Dem ad, and that was for Senate. Maybe the Dems are focusing more on digital ads or blitzing TV closer to early voting and election day given their smaller war chest?
In an interview of former Biden press sec Jen Psaki by Kara Swisher at CODE, after discussing the Dems who do a good job of messaging and communicating, Swisher asked Psaki who she thought was the best on the Republican side. Without a moment to ponder, she said Ron DeSantis.
We’ve got work to do before November!
LikeLike
Ron DeSantis is a man without a soul. No doubt he will use the Hurricane as a campaign prop.
LikeLike
Could say the same thing about paying for college debt
DeSantis is at least doing something. He knows what to do and had plans in place. Biden called several Dem mayors and did not call DeSantis until it was announced on TV–Gov Cuomo sent seniors to their deaths and then lied about it. Remember the daily news briefings?
LikeLike
April: I understand that you may be responding to Diane more than me. But I was speaking more of just an unplanned circumstance working in his favor and not him using it as a political prop. Florida has had a good emergency management system for years, so DeSantis and whoever is in office 10 years from now regardless of party will benefit from that.
There are people on a forum that I am active on who love to use Florida’s post-2020 tourism numbers as a testimony to Ron DeSantis. Like natural disasters, we have a longstanding tourism apparatus that has been our bread and butter for 50+ years. Over 100 million people visited Florida in 2019 with around 70 million of them going to Orlando. Of course the place that was top-of-mind for most travelers pre-COVID would be top-of-mind “post”-COVID. I would love to see the pyramids in Egypt, but me visiting there is not an endorsement of their government and its policies.
There as even an article talking about the expansion of school “choice” under DeSantis as if it was all him. Jennifer Berkshire tweeted something akin to “It’s funny how Jeb Bush created the environment they have in Florida 20 years ago only for Ron DeSantis to get the credit for it.”
LikeLike