Christopher Hooks wrote in The Texas Monthly about the boundless hypocrisy and moral vacuousness of Texas’ elected leaders.
In the run-up to the 2022 primaries and election, they made a big show of “protecting the children.”
They obsessed about the danger of transgender children, even insisting on criminalizing parents’ efforts to get medical help for their children. They obsessed about teachers allegedly “grooming” children for lives of deviant sexual behavior. They obsessed about “obscene” books that might normalize sexual behavior they—these men of high righteousness— deplored. They obsessed about “critical race theory” and demanded the banning of books that taught children about racism, whether past or present, or anything about human sexuality.
Yes, the children of Texas would be protected from any teaching about race or sexuality.
But they would not be physically protected. They would not be protected from an 18-year-old with two AR15s.
When the bad man with a powerful weapon came into their classroom, the children were left to fend for themselves while 19 police officers stood in the hallway. The bad man killed their teachers. He killed children. Little girls called 911 and begged for help. One said 8 or 9 children were still alive. But the police remained in the hallway.
The parents in the schoolyard pleaded with the police to save their children, but the police had their instructions: keep the parents away.
Almost an hour passed before the police broke into the classroom and shot the murderer.
The Governor called a press conference , where he commended the police for their courage and bravery. He commended the men who waited in the hallway for almost an hour, while the children were dying, one after another.
Hooks writes:
Texas, a friend used to say, is hard on women and little things. That would come to mind over the years when reporting seemed to bear it out. In 2015, I watched a foster mother testify in court, via telephone from her daughter’s hospital bedside, that state cuts to the Medicaid acute therapy program were having disastrous consequences for her child’s incurable, debilitating genetic disorder. In 2021, an eleven-year-old boy in Conroe suffocated from carbon monoxide poisoning after seeing snow for the first time, as his family tried to keep their home warm after the collapse of a horribly mismanaged electrical grid. And then there were the perennial horror stories from the state’s spike-pit child welfare system—a three-year-old found dead, bleeding from the ears, after his day care repeatedly warned state agents about signs of abuse by his foster parents; a teenage girl who killed herself the moment she could despite orders that she was never to be left alone; and countless others who survive through the heavy prescription of psychotropic meds before being kicked out to the streets at the age of eighteen.
Each revelation of new misery brings a new wave of revulsion, but—I hate to say this—as you learn more about how the social safety net works in Texas, the revulsion starts to fade, and it becomes a dull undercurrent to an awareness of the world instead of something sharp that pokes through. As it fades, so comes the realization that it has faded in the same way for those in power—and that nothing gets fixed because leaders have been immunized from caring to an even greater degree. The grid remains unsteady; children in foster care still get abused. Legislators make a show of passing partial, temporary fixes and resist looking at problems head-on. The Texas Legislature, with all its self-regard and jocularity and pride in itself as an institution, turns out to be suffused with a very dull and banal kind of evil.
On Tuesday, though, something poked through. For me, it wasn’t the knowledge that there had been another school shooting. Who could be surprised by that? Every detail was familiar. A once-bullied eighteen-year-old, two AR-15s, 22 dead, and 19 injured. The thing that shocked was the pictures of the dead when they lived. They were so little! Do you remember what it was like to have a body that small? A round fired by an AR-15 at close range enters the human body at three times the speed as those fired by a handgun, disintegrating and liquefying bones and organs around it. “It’s like a grenade goes off in there,” one trauma surgeon told Wired. Parents had to submit DNA samples so their kids could be accurately identified.
This spectacular violence, it sometimes feels, has not left much of us. At his initial press conference, Governor Greg Abbott wore his traditional white disaster-response shirt and offered details of the massacre as if reading a weather report. At a press conference the next day, where the governor sat alongside Texas senator Ted Cruz and Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick, Abbott told Texans that the disaster “could have been worse,” and the primary flash of anger shown by elected officials came when Beto O’Rourke, who appeared in the crowd, tried to talk over them.
Appearing on Newsmax TV the day of the shooting, state attorney general Ken Paxton suggested that more armed guards at schools would help, “because it’s not going to be the last time.” Can you believe that, as a response from one of the most powerful elected officials in the state to a massacre of fourth graders? “It’s not going to be the last time.” There used to be at least a perfunctory mourning period, some hugs given in front of cameras, before those in power turned to one another other and shrugged. But in truth, leaders are only handling this the way they think about the foster care system they oversee, and every other death trap run by the state. The revulsion dulls, the novelty fades, and it becomes normal.
The shooting took place on the day of the Texas primary runoff. The composition of the Legislature and the rest of state government for the next two and a half years was set that night, barring extraordinary circumstances, by the conclusion of the Republican primary, which in Texas is more influential than the general election. Paxton, who had shrugged off the Uvalde shooting on Newsmax while wearing a campaign T-shirt, won renomination and almost certainly a third term in office.
It is a grotesque and cruel irony that the Republican primary this year, and several years of political activity before it, have been dominated by an all-consuming and comically misdirected argument about the “protection” of children and by a war on public schools. There was essentially no policy contested in the GOP primary that could affect the practical and economic circumstances of all Texans. (There rarely is.) There was, however, ceaseless argument about the well-being of children, their morals, their internal lives.
The most acute panic was over transgender children. In February, Paxton’s office issued a formal opinion holding that the prescription of puberty blockers to transgender children represented “child abuse.” Shortly after, Abbott tasked the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services, an overworked and underfunded agency he had overseen for close to eight years, with investigating the families of transgender children for child abuse.
The more widespread crisis concerned books. The panic was conjured by parents and elected officials in equal measure. The first target was books with “divisive” material about race. Then, elected officials began to panicabout “pornography” in schools, a category that mostly included literature featuring queer characters and sexuality. Lawmakers proposed lists of books to be banned. In November, Abbott ordered the Texas Education Agency to investigate cases of “obscene material” in public schools and prosecute those responsible “to the fullest extent of the law,” because, as he wrote, it had to be a top priority to “protect” Texas students.
Public school teachers and children’s librarians—two professions that offer a strongly beneficial service to society for little pay—became villains for parents and candidates alike. They were called “groomers” and pedophiles on social media. In a press release, Abbott called for criminal charges to be brought if librarians were found to have put “pornography” in front of children. In Granbury, southwest of Fort Worth, half a year later, one woman lodged a criminal complaint against the librarians of Hood County ISD, prompting a police investigation. At a subsequent school board meeting, she condemned the fact that a committee brought together to review troublesome books had “too many” librarians instead of “people with good moral standards.”
The deterioration spread. A record number of public school teachers, already weary from the pandemic and now faced with a sort of siege, started quitting en masse—and forfeiting their licenses, indicating they probably wouldn’t come back. “I’m tired of getting punched. It shouldn’t be like this,” ninth grade math teacher Gloria Ogboaloh told Texas Monthly. As more teachers left, the quality of life for remaining educators got worse. Then, just four months after ordering that libraries be investigated, Abbott ordered the TEA to create a task force to investigate why so many teachers were quitting.
Hooks goes on to describe politicians who are liars, braggarts, cruel, indifferent to the safety of children, callous. How long can they continue to fool people with their charade and their fake concern? They don’t care about thechildren

History has shown time and again that “these men of high righteousness” of the right wing who lean hard and heavy on these ridiculous talking points have some seriously deep and dark skeletons in their own closet, from extramarital affairs (especially homosexual) and providing abortions to their own “cute little co-ed” staffers to pedophilia themselves. What a bunch of seriously sick individuals who take their issues on on the entirety of the citizenry who just, for the most part, want to be left alone. How ironic for these “conservatives.”
LikeLike
They aren’t conservatives! They are regressive xtian fundamentalist reactionaries who seek a time in America that never was nor will ever be.
LikeLike
Well, ‘never was’, at any rate.
LikeLike
The earliest Puritan dominated period in our Nation’s history (with witch burnings and all the rest) comes pretty damned close.
I suspect there was a very good ( quite legitimate) reason these folks were made to feel unwelcome in England , but sadly, rather than getting the message, they simply redirected their extremism toward Native Americans and African Americans.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So true. Read, “In the Devil’s Snare”, by Mary Beth Norton.
Also, I think they got kicked out of England and went to Holland. Then they got kicked out of Holland before messing up North America. Could be wrong about Holland, but check it out.
LikeLike
I guess they would be more accurately called Africans at that point.
LikeLike
Using a line from Swedish Greta Thunberg…’blah, blah, blah’. And nothing will change until the American mentality goes through a radical change.
LikeLike
Peskyvera,
I agree that the “American mentality” must change, although I am not sure what that is or how to change it. You seem to be expert on the Russian mentality. How do we get Russians to stop brutalizing Ukraine and committing egregious war crimes against women, children, the elderly, etc. and to stop reducing towns and cities to rubble? Any ideas?
LikeLike
Please, Diane. Let’s focus on gun violence in our country
LikeLike
Daedalus,
Are you really lecturing to Diane Ravitch about which comments she can reply to on her own blog?
I would say that Diane Ravitch has focused on gun violence constantly, especially with regards to schools. In the past week the multiple posts she has made where we can all discuss gun violence have all been informative and interesting as well as heart-breaking.
I don’t think Diane Ravitch needs you to tell her what to focus on. Seems more like you want to change the subject when she calls out the pro-Russia trolls who want to divide our country, and especially help empower the right wing pro-Putin Republicans by dividing the Democrats.
The Democrats have a lot more in common than the right wing trolls who want to divide them acknowledge. And one of the things Democrats want is gun control. Lucky for the right wing, they now control the Supreme Court.
LikeLike
I’m pointing out that the topic SHE chose for this discussion is ‘gun violence in schools”, not the Ukrainian mess. Occasionally, everyone needs an editor in order to send a more coherent message.
LikeLike
“All hat, no cattle”
Texas “leaders” wear the hat
Cowboy boots and all of that
Ranch and cattle have they none
But, of course, they have the gun
LikeLiked by 1 person
Texas “leaders” shoot to left
Shooting squirrels, really deft
When they see a rattlesnake
Texas “leaders” quake and shake
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Clueless in Texas”
We vote for the liars
In Texas, it’s true
But don’t blame us buyers
We haven’t a clue
LikeLiked by 1 person
Alternative title: “All hat and no saddle”
LikeLike
a great movie idea
LikeLike
The Gettysburg Address
All the people can’t be fooled
‘cept in Texas, as a rule
LikeLike
The Republican Party has deteriorated into the party of thieves, liars, bigots and misogynists. Yet, we have to ask ourselves how people continued to be taken in by their dangerous, hateful ideology. It also includes parents in Uvalde, TX, many of whom voted for Donald Trump in 2020. It is not just Texas that has this problem, It is all the red states that emulate and legislate more hate, division and attacks against the common good.
LikeLike
How do people continue to be taken in?
Continual reinforcement of sloganistic worldviews by fundamentalist churches and by media owned by oligarchs whose purpose is to manipulate these people into continual outrage about a world changing in ways that they can’t comprehend and fear
LikeLike
Perhaps they are not taken in at all. Perhaps this is who they are and seek reinforcement by those Churches, Media outlets and Trump . Thus I hear from supposedly economically disgruntled White working class Americans . “There are more important things than my Job , my Union , my pension, “Like American values” . Seriously not the values I believed America pretended to believe in.
LikeLike
It’s ironic, isn’t it, that the people LEAST LIKELY to have American values, as enshrined in the Constitution and its amendments and interpretations over the centuries are the ones who always talk about American values. Trump and his propaganda minister Stephen “Goebbels” Miller were/are perfect examples. Clueless that this is an immigrant nation and that that is our strength.
LikeLike
The obsessed about naked cartoon mice.
LikeLike
Love it! Thanks, Bob.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The average rent in Tampa increased by 28 percent over last year. Last year, it increased 24 percent over the previous years. Wages in Tampa have increased 0.5 percent over last year. Half a percent. It now takes three minimum wage jobs to pay the average rent in Tampa.
LikeLike
cx: over the previous year.
LikeLike
Welcome to live in Desantistan.
LikeLike
Actually I would bet that is more like welcome to Wall Street or Private Equity. You would think DeSc—–o would be responsible for falling real estate values .
LikeLike
After the last crash, Black Rock came into Tampa and bought 1.5 billion dollars worth of foreclosed homes and turned these into rentals.
LikeLike
Sounds to me like children in Texas, even those passing through along with their parents from one state to another, need protection from the elected government of Texas and the Fascist Republican Party.
For anyone still stuck on fascism meaning Hitler and Nazis, please check the definition for fascism in a reliable dictionary.
Like this one from the Cambridge Dictionary – and the Republican Party of today fits that definition 100%.
fascism
noun [ U ] POLITICS (also Fascism)
US /ˈfæʃ.ɪ.zəm/ UK /ˈfæʃ.ɪ.zəm/
a political system based on a very powerful leader, state control, and being extremely proud of country and race, and in which political opposition is not allowed
LikeLike
Sounds like Greg Abbott and the Texas GOP.
LikeLike
That’s Greg aBUTT, & I hope Beto kicks his!
Send 💰💰💰💰!!!
LikeLike
Also like Ron DeSantis and the Florida GOP.
LikeLike
Again, misspelled.
DeINSANEtis.
LikeLike
From njspotlightdotorg: New Jersey already has some of the nation’s strongest gun laws, according to Paul Boxer, a psychology professor at Rutgers University in Newark, and an expert on social development and gun violence, and he praised the existing multi-disciplinary team with state and local officials, law enforcement and other partners that currently works to improve school safety. [snip] With a rate of five firearm deaths per 100,000 people, New Jersey has the third-lowest gun fatality level in the nation, following Hawaii (3.4) and Massachusetts (3.7), according to 2020 data — the latest available — from the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, which tallies health impacts by state. New York is fifth-lowest (5.3 deaths per 100,000), while Pennsylvania (13.6) is 20th nationwide. But even with the low state rate, 443 New Jerseyans lost their lives to gun violence in 2020, CMS found. end quote
LikeLike
Too bad we rarely hear the facts that demonstrate that common sense guns laws work and protect people from being victims of gun violence. When we look at most other western countries that restrict access to guns, the US mortality rate from guns is off the charts in comparison.
LikeLike
Yep.
LikeLike
443 Deaths may have more than a little to do with easy access to guns from other states .
LikeLike
yes
LikeLike
I want to see the results of the study that shows how many of the police who were unwilling to save the children in the Uvalde classroom believe that women should sacrifice their lives for fetuses.
LikeLike
Abortion Solution
Harden the women
Harden the gals
Keep sperm from swimmin’
Up the canals
LikeLike
Harden the orifice
Chastity belt
Best to deplore a kiss
Kicks will be felt
LikeLike
The second stanza is especially good.
While the last line probably didn’t refer to kicks outside of the womb, statistically, the incidences of a man’s violence against a woman increase after he impregnates her.
LikeLike
Nothing will change unless America is forced to take an unflinching look at what happened in Uvalde. Someone needs to take photos of the carnage in that room and post them on every newspaper and every social media platform in this country. As cruel as this might seem to the families, nothing will change until the public realizes what this kind of weaponry does to the human body. The families were asked to provide DNA samples for their children. What this means is that the children’s bodies and faces were cut to pieces, and I know this is a hard statement to read, but that’s the reality of it and we as a nation need to face reality. The collective “we” continues to sanitize this barbarity and trauma towards children, numbing ourselves to what it really is to go through this kind of needless, endless pain and suffering, all for the sick, twisted, worship of the gun and the dollars that flow with it.
LikeLike
The crime scene photos should be sent to GOP legislators like Ted Cruz, Kevin McCarthy, Marjorie T. Greene, Louie Gohmert, Rand Paul, Gregg Abbott, Dan Patrick, etc.
LikeLike
Yes. There are crime scene photos. Too gruesome to release.
LikeLike
I doubt that these non-persons–no heart, no soul–would be moved in any way that we human beings would.
LikeLike
But they WOULD be moved to redouble their efforts to blame this on liberals, Democrats, immigrants, etc etc ad nauseam.
LikeLike
An ER doc said the children looked as though grenades had gone off inside their bodies.
Yeah, we need for 18 year olds (or anyone) to be able to buy guns and ammunition that can do that. [Here I restrain myself from saying what actually comes to mind when I think of people who support this.]
LikeLike
Just before the Uvalde shooting, the company that made the AR used in the massacre (Daniel Defense) was running an ad featuring a very young child with an AR in his lap.
Folks like this are simply immune to any sort of reason or even human empathy. They are driven by their moronic ideology (based, as it is, on a completely irrational Kyle Rittenhouse-like paranoia that everyone is out to get them and a fanciful, pretzel-logic “interpretation” of the second amendment) — and, in the case of Daniel Defense, making money hand over fist, of course.
LikeLike
Raw Story (5-30-2022), “Criminalizing abortion is a key feature of dismantling the social safety net”… “It’s about preserving a social order in which the poor have fewer options except humiliating themselves…”
The despot aligned with the conservative church. Jefferson warned the nation. Religion has proven to be particularly effective, recently, in getting women to vote against their own interests and the interests of their children.
LikeLike
Big Sigh
Part of the problem with ‘public education’ is that it’s ‘public’, and involves politics. This is why ‘charter schools’ were invented (with teacher support). However, it now seems that our messy politics (local school boards) was a better idea after all.
Now, another problem is that our ‘politics’ now involves money instead of people.
LikeLike
Part of the problem is that democracy is “messy”. Authoritarianism is “clean”. One guy tells everyone what to do. Easy peasy.
Until Americans start accepting that democracy is “messy”, progressive ideas will lose. Because nothing is perfect. Nothing happens exactly as you might want and even when it does, the results still won’t make 100% of the people happy.
Do you know why good people so often avoid running for school board? Because it is “messy”. There will always be people mad at you even if you are tireless in trying to make everyone happy. It is so much easier for someone who is funded by the far right who doesn’t care at all what people think and just wants to do it in the way that the right wing wants.
LikeLike
Oddly, I agree with you. Perhaps you didn’t read me accurately.
However, how do you envision Americans coming to accept that ‘democracy is “messy”‘ and stepping up to the plate? Particularly in our country, today, when money is being spent on school board races to smear ordinary people in public?
Perhaps I’m old and pessimistic. Time for my students to take over.
LikeLike
Charter schools don’t avoid politics. They are deeply embedded in politics, funded by Koch, DeVos, and others who believe that private is always better than public. Where you stand depends on where you sit. What’s best for the common good? Not privatization.
LikeLike
Well, that depends on (from) your definition of ‘politics’. I think of it as a movement to enhance the general public. Aristotle had a few things to say about it (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politeia). However, the meanings of words seem to mutate rather quickly in our ‘modern’ society, so you might have different ideas. I’m just a ‘science guy’, after all.
In no way does our current government work to benefit the general ‘polity’ of our country. It is designed (at present) to benefit one class at the expense of the rest of the country. Still, one might argue that this is ‘politics’, but I would submit that it is the opposite.
Perhaps I chose the wrong word (we science guys are known for that).
LikeLike
Meanwhile, salvation is finally underway in the den of Massachusetts:
https://www.rawstory.com/rockefeller-republicans/
LikeLike
A resounding yes to your 3:43 PM comment, Mark.
LikeLike
What trauma surgeons describe: absolutely ghastly, but a necessary read
LikeLike
“How long can they [Texas elected leaders] continue to fool people with their charade and their fake concern? They don’t care about the children.” –last sentences of Christopher Hooks’ article, above.
Hooks got this wrong. Texas leaders are NOT “fooling people”; they are accurately representing the sincere beliefs of millions of ignorant, selfish, dysfunctional narcissists in need of someone to follow. And alas, they constitute a functional majority, because our side can’t be bothered with persistent vigilance and regular voting.
Once in a while we eek out a victory, like in portions of the 2020 election, but the insurrectionists have been pandering, gerrymandering and working on low-level elections and appointments to prime the pump for decades.
Even if our side could muster an equally effective turnout, we would still have only a slight majority. The traitors will still be here…what, 40-45% of our population? In 1860 the North had a population of 22 million, and the South 9 million, 3.5 million of whom were slaves.
This is who we are, and the elected leaders of Texas and elsewhere are the result–not the cause–of who we are.
LikeLike
I know the primaries took place on the day of the shootings but I’m thinking maybe, JUST maybe, this tragic event can change the outcome of the general elections. Earlier this evening, I ‘d sent Diane an article a friend sent from The Washington Post, someone who had lived in Uvalde &, given the good ole Texas atmosphere, wasn’t at all surprised that this tragedy occurred. I hope you can post it, Diane, or at least write an intro & a description and provide a link.
Sandy Hook didn’t occur during/before an
election cycle.
Is it too much to hope for that, just this one time, everything can change around so that the RIGHT people who can pass legislation to prevent further tragedies will be elected?
LikeLike
The New Republic, 3-9-2021, written by the author of Power Worshippers, “…The religious right (dominates) the nerve centers of influence and owes its strength to decades of investment in a sophisticated suite of tools including data, media and messaging that drives voter mobilization.” A review of the state Catholic Conferences will show you the voter mobilization efforts.
The religious right which is made up of conservative Catholics and protestant evangelicals have the goals of (1) men over women, (2) Christians over non-Christians and (3) straights over gays. And, IMO, (4) a continuation of white over black colonialism.
Theocracy is used to keep the poor, poor and to maintain the social order that benefits the richest 0.1% who have 90% of the U.S.’ wealth.
Studious efforts to avoid the identification of liberalism’s enemies aids those enemies.
.
LikeLike