Education Week warns that almost a third of teachers are at risk of severe illness if schools reopen before COVID-19 is contained.
Madeline Will writes:
As states begin to consider what reopening schools might look like, a new analysis of federal data warns that teachers could be more susceptible to severe illness from COVID-19.
About 29 percent of teachers are aged 50 and older, federal data show. Older adults are at higher risk for severe illness from COVID-19—92 percent of deaths related to the disease in the United States were of people aged 55 and older, and that age group also has higher rates of coronavirus-related hospitalizations than younger adults. And as the brief report by the research group Child Trends points out, teachers have significantly more social contact than the average adult, since they’re in close quarters with dozens of students every day.
Already, teachers’ workplaces rank among the “germiest”—one study found that teachers have nearly 27 times more germs on their computer keyboards than other professions studied. Teachers report that they frequently come down with colds and other garden-variety illnesses over the course of the school year. After all, children are “effective transmitters of respiratory germs,” Donna Mazyck, the executive director of the National Association of School Nurses, told Education Week earlier this year.
The immune system naturally deteriorates with age, the Child Trends report notes. Also, teachers are more likely to report being stressed at work than average people, and some research suggests that stress can weaken the immune system.
Decisionmakers “responsible for reopening schools should weigh not only the health of their students, but also that of their teachers who are at elevated risk,” wrote Renee Ryberg, a research scientist at Child Trends. “Education administrators who choose to proceed with reopening should coordinate closely with health agencies to enact policies to keep teachers, as well as students, safe.”

“Decisionmakers “responsible for reopening schools should weigh not only the health of their students, but also that of their teachers who are at elevated risk,”
It’s just horrible that that has to be said, but I suppose it does with our terrible political leadership.
Did you see the photographs of the Trump supporters in the Michigan statehouse yesterday? Just really unfair that they were allowed to put all the people who have to work there at risk. Screaming at them right in their faces. Just absolute disregard for other people, and the President and his Administration cheers this on- heck, DeVos is bankrolling it. There is no behavior that is off-limits apparently. There is no standard they will not drag down to the lowest possible level.
LikeLike
I just do NOT understand that Nazi scene at the Michigan statehouse!! These armed maniacs should have been required, at the least, to wear face masks in the statehouse and only a small number at a time should have been permitted to enter the building, UNARMED! There should have been social distancing but I saw pictures of these unmasked fascists screaming at the guards.
LikeLike
Unmasked fascists screaming at the guards only inches from their faces.
LikeLike
I saw a photo of one protestor who was wearing a mask…and carrying the largest gun I’ve ever seen. Why is that allowed?
LikeLike
Michigan allows guns into the state Capitol
That has to change
They are forbidden in US Capitol
LikeLike
They are unpaid Storm Troopers.
LikeLike
The scene in the Michigan statehouse made me so angry. wouldn’t you think that carrying assault weapons in the statehouse should have qualified as impinging on the rights of others? You scream in my face even without carrying a gun and I would think that is a civil rights violation. The anger at that display is still with me; it was so not okay.
LikeLike
“’Decisionmakers responsible for reopening schools should weigh not only the health of their students, but also that of their teachers who are at elevated risk’: It’s just horrible that that has to be said.”– THANK YOU CHIARA. This goes right in the same basket with “Please don’t inject Lysol,” “Belgium is a country not a city,” and other corrective truisms never seen in print before the Trump era.
LikeLike
If you dare, go spend five minutes looking at the #FreeTN Facebook page and see what these nuts are doing and saying. These guys on free page get violent about people wearing masks.
LikeLike
I know there’s a lot of learning we all have to do about this virus, but it is hard for me to believe that children don’t infect adults. That isn’t true in any other contagious situation- we regularly have the flu rip thru schools here, for example.
I want schools to open and I’m also a realist and I know they will- the country can’t function with 50 million children at loose ends- but at the very least we could show teachers some respect and admit we don’t know the extent of the risk.
If it spreads in a meat packing plant or nursing home it will spread in a school. Denying that doesn’t do anyone any good.
LikeLike
If it were me I would worry more about daycares than public schools. Daycares are often not regulated at all and there’s very little reporting.
Public schools have to document everything- we know more about them than we know about any private entity. A lot of the ed reform attacks on public schools can only occur BECAUSE they are public- ed reformers often compare “no data” in private settings to “all the data public schools have to report”.
If you’re a parent who wants measures of how school is going as far as transmission you won’t get more information in a private situation- you’ll get less. Maybe ignorance is bliss, I don’t know.
LikeLike
True dat. Daycares are actually highly regulated here in NJ, regardless of whether state subsidy is involved. I knew a gal in the ’90’s that ran one for 10 kids out of her home: certificates, inspections, the works. Now in NJ daycares are supposed to be shut down unless they’re working w/state agencies to provide childcare for essential workers. But I don’t see any mechanism for monitoring that unless clients are getting state subsidy. If I were a parent I’d look for state-run (or city-run in NYC) places, they’d be following CDC guidelines for these places – but, easy to say, maybe not to do. Anyway if you look at those CDC guidelines you right away realize how near-impossible it is to create relative safety for those working with small children.
LikeLike
Children do get it & they are falling into the “no data” category due to lack of testing.
https://theintercept.com/2020/05/01/coronavirus-children-undercount/ “In the U.S., the vast majority of serious Covid-19 cases — and eight out of 10 deaths — occur in people who are at least 65. Yet newly tabulated data show that the virus is also affecting young people across the country — and in very rare cases, killing them.
At least 201 infected children under age 18 have been admitted into pediatric intensive care units in the U.S., according to data from a national registry called Virtual Pediatric Systems.”
LikeLike
Gov Cuomo’s press conference is just wrapping up.
NYS schools are closed for the remainder of the academic year. It isn’t a huge surprise.
Yesterday, he devoted about 30 minutes to talking about the NYC subway system, the homeless taking refuge there and essential workers getting to jobs on the trains. The day before it was, like, another 30 minutes on NYC mass transit issues.
If it wasn’t for questions from the reporters, today’s message about schools would’ve been about 5 minutes. Tops.
Of course, education is very, very complicated to begin with.
What comes next?? Wow!??
Asked by a reporter how teachers can control social distancing in a classroom, the Gov. looked like a deer in the headlights.
LikeLike
Yeah. Governor Cuomo has no answers to the problems that schools are facing. I liked how he responded to the question of how he would rate his response to the pandemic. He said he was doing the best he can. Too bad educators who are confronted with outrageous situations can’t just say the same and be taken seriously.
LikeLike
Yes, I caught that, too,
My first reaction, though, was at least this guy isn’t like Trump, who gave himself a “10” when asked how he was doing responding to the pandemic.
Yeah, Cuomo. Very mixed feelings about him at this point.
He was asked a question about summer school and I don’t think he even understood what the reporter was referencing.
Getting a subway train cleaned and running on time? That’s one thing.
Preparing for a classroom of wonderful, anxious kindergarteners and their worried parents on September 8, 2020, our first scheduled day of school in the fall….that’s an entirely different world!
LikeLike
Perhaps Cuomo should be judged by “outcomes”(eg number of deaths from covid19), as he would have teachers judged.
What’s good for the goose, is good for the guvnor.
LikeLike
Death Added Model (DAM)
Don’t give Cuomo any rest
Judge him by the covid death
Just like teachers by the score
Judge the guv forever more
LikeLike
A great way for payback to hostile governors like Cuomo! Give them a metric based on the number of people that died on their watch, the DAM model. We can then hear them all squeal on how unfair the metric is. Of course, it is unfair and unscientific, just like VAM. How would they like to be blamed for factors that are outside their control? This is exactly what has been done to teachers across multiple states. Brilliant idea, SomeDAM!
LikeLike
Better do that ranking by percent of total population plus some factor in there to take care of the total number of people per square mile. Perhaps some factor for typical transient population, too. Otherwise, you will let some rural governors get off with better scores than they deserve.
LikeLike
Don’t give Cuomo ANY breaks
Throwing dice is all it takes
VAM is randumb, “factors” moot
Give the guv the DAMming boot
LikeLike
This is off topic but something that is, in my mind, very important. Canada cares about its citizens, we don’t. First graders being shot didn’t even make a difference.
……………………………………………………..
Justin Trudeau announces federal ban on assault-style firearms in Canada (Full transcript)
‘These weapons were designed for one purpose and one purpose only: to kill the largest number of people in the shortest amount of time. There is no use and no place for such weapons in Canada.’
By Maclean’s
May 1, 2020
On May 1, the prime minister announced that Canada will be banning the buying, selling, transport, import or use military-grade assault weapons. The announcement comes in the wake of the deadliest mass shooting in the country’s history. This is the transcript of his remarks:
Last week, 22 Canadians were killed in the deadliest rampage in our country’s history. They were nurses and teachers, correctional officers and RCMP officers. They were someone’s child, someone’s best friend, someone’s partner. Their families deserve more than thoughts and prayers. Canadians deserve more than thoughts and prayers…
https://www.macleans.ca/news/canada/justin-trudeau-announces-federal-ban-on-military-grade-assault-weapons-in-canada-full-transcript/
LikeLike
Good for Trudeau!
LikeLike
That explains why Trump, DeVos, and most of the Republicans want to open the schools for the last few weeks of this school year, to kill off as many teachers as possible.
LikeLike
Just to get rid of those pesky teachers and their no good Union. SMH
LikeLike
Donald J. Trump is now the leading cause of death in the United States.
LikeLike
Allow Trumpty Dumpty to stay in the White House, and he will be the leading cause of death in the world, too.
And even if he loses the November 2020 election, he might start WWIII, in an attempt stay President for the rest of his life and/or until the end of our species … whatever he causes to happen first.
There are several options.
Trump stages a coup to take over before the election – the country explodes in a Civil War
When Trump sees that he is losing the election, he stages a coup and sends his thugs to eliminate anyone that dares to stand up to Trump — the country explodes in a Civil War.
Trump wins the election (with help from Russia and other cheating) and in four years, he stages a coup to stay in power beyond two terms and for the rest of his life with a dynasty in place so one of his children takes his place when he dies.
Trump loses the election and attempts to start WWIII to get even with the country and the world for letting him lose – the military steps in and stops him and rules the country with martial law to restore order and hopefully the Constitutional Republic.
The odds are not good for this one to happen. Trump loses and leaves the White House quietly in January 2021, without any twitter storms attacking everyone in can because they wouldn’t worship him and give him total loyalty, and he doesn’t have hate rallies that never pay their bills while stirring up his base to start a Civil War and put him back in power.
LikeLike
Well said, Yvonne!
LikeLike
John Ogozalek said “Asked by a reporter how teachers can control social distancing in a classroom, the Gov. (Cuomo) looked like a deer in the headlights.”
The Governor should look at this wonderful video of social distancing in first grade classrooms in China. Parents helped the children with this project. The “solution” actually has a logic and historical anticedent. You will find that in the very last image. We do not know what outfits the teachers have.
http://shanghaiist.com/2020/04/28/hangzhou-kids-wear-social-distancing-hats-upon-return-to-school/?fbclid=IwAR2npIfMxoAQ-2gjhmJ-7mb1gwlqawJN2WHKdYxMphvnoGotEpIRz0whaB8#.Xqrh9AGhCSg.facebook
LikeLike
And if you look at the pictures closely you will see half the kids not elevating the hats and others with their masks down around their chins. Also (not sure if it is nationwide) but if a child in Ningbo comes down with coronavirus their entire class is out non governmental quarantine (not with parents).
LikeLike
Cuomo looks more like a raccoon in the headlights.
https://images.app.goo.gl/nJsL5Eoifb8VU61S6
LikeLike
Laura, this is GREAT. My wife and I went for a long walk and she was telling me about this picture…these kids with the hats. I meant to try and find it when we got home and, WHOOSH!, ‘quarantine brain’ strikes again. It completely flew out of my mind.
Thanks.
LikeLike
Wow, Laura! Fascinating!
LikeLike
redirect: How will we adapt the schools to provide a safework place for high risk staff and students?
LikeLike
View at Medium.com
LikeLike
And yet when teachers tried to go in …..did they let them in or have a private session somewhere else
Did they let those protesting abortions come in and sit there or did they have private sesdions?
LikeLike
Panic porn.
LikeLike
I don’t think that’s right, FLERP.
Don’t expect teachers to risk their lives in the middle of a pandemic.
LikeLike
Given the requirements for reopening K-12 education given on various posts here, I do not think there is much of a chance that schools will be open for the 2020-2021 school year. Giving up a year of school for students is simply not as important as the risk to teacher’s health.
LikeLike
Quarantine (A “Dancing Queen” Parody)
Apr 9, 2020
Cast and band members of Moonlight Stage Productions’ “Mamma Mia!” virtually reunite in this parody of a beloved ABBA classic.
LikeLike
To me, this is just plain ridiculous. My county is not included because of the death and infection rate, except for ‘expanded church services”. Got to get to church! I’d like to know how barbershops, tattoo parlors and salons can meet social distancing practices. [My hairdresser has always been good at cutting my hair from 6 feet away.] Indiana Democratic Party Chairman Zody said that there has been a record high in daily new infections while Governor Holcomb [R-IN] says the hospital admissions have decreased for the last 14 days.
Just in case you didn’t know, Costco is asking customers and workers to wear face masks starting Monday, May 4. Have to so this or you won’t get inside.
…………………………………………….
Holcomb [R-IN] says it’s a methodical step-by-step plan for progress that will be carefully monitored.
He stressed that the number of COVID-19 cases will continue to increase. He said at any time if the health care system is struggling the state might need to pause or revert back.
Democrats said Holcomb is moving too fast in lifting restrictions.
“Why is Gov. Holcomb out of step with federal guidelines for reopening that require a downward trajectory of cases for a 14-day period? Why potentially rush a reopening and risk the sacrifices Hoosiers have made?” Indiana Democratic Party Chairman John Zody asked. “A record high in daily new infections this week and testing and tracing programs still on training wheels, let alone proven effective, should give Holcomb pause. This isn’t about who’s first, it’s who gets it right.”
Holcomb said the plan was based on four guiding principles. The first is that the number of COVID-related hospital admissions have decreased the last 14 days statewide.
He said cases and deaths will always rise because there is no treatment or vaccine. But the purpose of flattening the curve was to not overwhelm the health care system.
……………………………………………………………………………………..
Stages
Here is the road map for reopening Indiana. It is a guideline and if the virus surges again could be paused or reverted back. The dates will be slightly different for Marion, Lake and Cass counties.
May 4 to 10 – Stage 2
Senior citizens and those with health conditions are encouraged to stay at home as much as possible. Masks are encouraged in public and social distancing and proper hygiene should continue.
Retail and commercial businesses can operate at 50% capacity; indoor common areas at malls will be limited to 25%.
Social gatherings, currently capped at 10 people, will be increased to 25 people.
Essential travel restrictions will be lifted but people are still encouraged to work from home when possible.
Manufacturers, industrial operations and other infrastructure that has been closed can reopen.
Public libraries can reopen.
May 8 – Stage 2
Churches around the state can hold in-person services as they are exempt from the social gathering limitations. Weddings, funerals and baptisms are also allowed.
Specific guidance will be issued, including spacing seating out for social distancing, face coverings and more. Livestreams and remote services are still encouraged.
May 11 to 23 – Stage 2
Personal services such as hair and nail salons; barber shops and tattoo shops can open by appointment only. And they must meet social distancing guidelines and other restrictions.
Restaurants and bars that serve food may reopen at 50% capacity but bar seating will be closed.
Still closed or banned: bars and nightclubs; visitation in nursing homes; gyms and fitness centers; sporting events, fairs, bowling alleys, zoos, pools, casinos, recreational fields and courts.
All school buildings and grounds – public or private – will be closed through June 30.
May 24 to June 13 – Stage 3
Social gathering limit will be increased to 100 people.
Gyms and fitness centers reopen with distanced equipment and limited class sizes.
Playgrounds, sports fields and courts may open.
Movie theaters can operate at half capacity; retail stores at 75% capacity.
June 14 to July 3 – Stage 4
Social gathering limit increased to 250.
Senior citizens and those with known medical conditions should remain cautious at work and in their communities.
Retail stores and malls at full capacity; restaurants at 75% capacity.
Bars and nightclubs can open at half capacity.
Entertainment and tourism venues such as zoos, museums and aquariums can open at half capacity.
All recreational sports leagues and tournaments can resume.
July 4 – Stage 5
All social gathering limitations lifted, including for fairs, festivals, conventions, sporting events and concerts.
Face coverings will be optional.
LikeLike
This is horrible, carol. At one point, the area governors–both Dems (MI, IL, WI, MN) & GOP (IN, OH)–were working together: in fact, I believe DeWine (R-OH) was the first one to shut down. WH it getting to Holcomb?
I wish better for you, your state, & all states of those reading this.
Please stay healthy, friends, so we can all vote it out in November.
LikeLike
This is the woman whom a lot of Republicans follow. She found it acceptable to get Social Security. What a creep.
……………………………………..
AYN RAND: “The newest proposals of having special, millions spent on subnormal children and on the handicapped. You are getting the so-called “needing” [school] buses is the attempt to bring everybody to the level of the handicapped. […]
But it includes the mentally retarded which is the subnormal, which is the children who are unable to learn, so that at the end of spending thousands or millions of taxpayers’ money, you’re left with a half-idiot who MAY learn to read and write. MAY.”
LikeLike
She sounds like she would have fit right in on Hitler’s staff or perhaps Stalin’s. I shiver to think who she would have consider “unworthy.”
LikeLike
Oh the irony that someone as deficient in normal human empathy and compassion as Ayn Rand was, someone so obviously broken, should have spoken this way about people who vary from norms.
LikeLike
My op-ed in the Atlanta Journal Constitution addressing this same concern. https://www.ajc.com/blog/get-schooled/teacher-guarantee-schools-can-reopen-start-planning-accordingly/PGC0gYajCBshpVdzicvMWI/
LikeLike
Very good article. Thank you.
I am worried about schools opening early and the devastation that will result from this happening. Red state governors are following the plans of ‘open’ is better for the economy even if it only kills 2-3% of the population.
Schools can be the equivalent of cruise ships or nursing homes. Some children can get sick but they can also be carriers. It is the adults in the school who will suffer.
LikeLike
Terrific article. I had these reactions:
“The AVERAGE Georgia elementary school holds 621 children”– OMG! Is that normal? I must really live in a bubble. NJ’s ave elemsch size is 440. Of my town’s 6 elemschs, one is near GA’s ave [600] & another over state ave [479]; the other 4 range 300-400.
“Move all high school classes to online only. Use the now vacant schools to house elementary or middle school classes.” This sounds wrong. High-schoolers benefit just as much from IRL classes as younger students. This is really hanging them out to dry. The mentality seems to be from the “babysitting” POV, i.e., let those old enough to stay at home w/o adult supervision get along w/ the lowest quality option. Wouldn’t it be better to put all the available district seats into the hopper & parcel them out so that everyone gets an equal [PT] amount of IRL classtime?
LikeLike
Thank you for explaining this so clearly. So many conversations have rightfully focused on students bringing the virus home to multigenerational households but few have mentioned this angle. As a seasoned educator with diabetes, I rely on twice-daily insulin shots. I’m doing what I can to be healthier and I certainly appreciate these wise words.
LikeLike
Stay wekk, Tyra. We need all the seasoned educators we can get. Your is important.
LikeLike
cx: your voice
LikeLike
A British doctor says: “Here in England, medicine is so advanced that we cut off someone’s liver, put it in another person, and in 6 weeks, that person is looking for a job.
“The German doctor says: “Ja Wohl, dass ist nothing! Here in Deutschland we took part of a brain, put it in someone else, und in 4 weeks he is looking for a job.
“The Russian doctor says: “Gentlemen, we took half heart from citizen, put it in another citizen’s chest, and in 2 weeks he is looking for a job.
The American doctor laughs: “You are all behind us. A few months ago, we took a man with no brain, no heart, and no liver and made him President. Now the whole country is looking for a job!”
LikeLike