Reader “Left Coast Teacher” remembered that Kurt Vonnegut is no longer living. Reader Zorba replied that writers live as long as they are still read.
Edna St. Vincent wrote a poem about this, called “The Poet and His Book”:
Down, you mongrel, Death!
Back into your kennel!
I have stolen breath
In a stalk of fennel!
You shall scratch and you shall whine
Many a night, and you shall worry
Many a bone, before you bury
One sweet bone of mine!
When shall I be dead?
When my flesh is withered,
And above my head
Yellow pollen gathered
All the empty afternoon?
When sweet lovers pause and wonder
Who am I that lie thereunder,
Hidden from the moon?
This my personal death?–
That lungs be failing
To inhale the breath
Others are exhaling?
This my subtle spirit’s end?–
Ah, when the thawed winter splashes
Over these chance dust and ashes,
Weep not me, my friend!
Me, by no means dead
In that hour, but surely
When this book, unread,
Rots to earth obscurely,
And no more to any breast,
Close against the clamorous swelling
Of the thing there is no telling,
Are these pages pressed!
When this book is mould,
And a book of many
Waiting to be sold
For a casual penny,
In a little open case,
In a street unclean and cluttered,
Where a heavy mud is spattered
From the passing drays,
Stranger, pause and look;
From the dust of ages
Lift this little book,
Turn the tattered pages,
Read me, do not let me die!
Search the fading letters, finding
Steadfast in the broken binding
All that once was I!
When these veins are weeds,
When these hollowed sockets
Watch the rooty seeds
Bursting down like rockets,
And surmise the spring again,
Or, remote in that black cupboard,
Watch the pink worms writhing upward
At the smell of rain,
Boys and girls that lie
Whispering in the hedges,
Do not let me die,
Mix me with your pledges;
Boys and girls that slowly walk
In the woods, and weep, and quarrel,
Staring past the pink wild laurel,
Mix me with your talk,
Do not let me die!
Farmers at your raking,
When the sun is high,
While the hay is making,
When, along the stubble strewn,
Withering on their stalks uneaten,
Strawberries turn dark and sweeten
In the lapse of noon;
Shepherds on the hills,
In the pastures, drowsing
To the tinkling bells
Of the brown sheep browsing;
Sailors crying through the storm;
Scholars at your study; hunters
Lost amid the whirling winter’s
Whiteness uniform;
Men that long for sleep;
Men that wake and revel;–
If an old song leap
To your senses’ level
At such moments, may it be
Sometimes, though a moment only,
Some forgotten, quaint and homely
Vehicle of me!
Women at your toil,
Women at your leisure
Till the kettle boil,
Snatch of me your pleasure,
Where the broom-straw marks the leaf;
Women quiet with your weeping
Lest you wake a workman sleeping,
Mix me with your grief!
Boys and girls that steal
From the shocking laughter
Of the old, to kneel
By a dripping rafter
Under the discolored eaves,
Out of trunks with hingeless covers
Lifting tales of saints and lovers,
Travelers, goblins, thieves,
Suns that shine by night,
Mountains made from valleys,–
Bear me to the light,
Flat upon your bellies
By the webby window lie,
Where the little flies are crawling,–
Read me, margin me with scrawling,
Do not let me die!
Sexton, ply your trade!
In a shower of gravel
Stamp upon your spade!
Many a rose shall ravel,
Many a metal wreath shall rust
In the rain, and I go singing
Through the lots where you are flinging
Yellow clay on dust!

Speaking of reading… and of reading books by future history writer s(i.e. Sci FI) such as Vonnegut … he is just one of such writers whose books are flying off the shelves as The NY Times explains about two more books in this article: “Uneasy About the Future, Readers Turn to Dystopian Classics” https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/27/business/media/dystopian-classics-1984-animal-farm-the-handmaids-tale.html
“Last weekend, as hundreds of thousands of women gathered in Washington to protest the inauguration of President Trump, the novelist Margaret Atwood began getting a string of notifications on Twitter and Facebook. People were sending her images of protesters with signs that referenced her dystopian novel “The Handmaid’s Tale.”
“Make Margaret Atwood Fiction Again!” one sign read. “The Handmaid’s Tale is NOT an Instruction Manual!” read another.
“There were a honking huge number of them,” Ms. Atwood said.
“The Handmaid’s Tale,” which takes place in near-future New England as a totalitarian regime has taken power and stripped women of their civil rights, was published 32 years ago. But in recent months, Ms. Atwood has been hearing from anxious readers who see eerie parallels between the novel’s oppressive society and the current Republican administration’s policy goals of curtailing reproductive rights.
In 2016, sales of the book, which is in its 52nd printing, were up 30 percent over the previous year. Ms. Atwood’s publisher has reprinted 100,000 copies in the last three months to meet a spike in demand after the election.
“The Handmaid’s Tale” is among several classic dystopian novels that seem to be resonating with readers at a moment of heightened anxiety about the state of American democracy. Sales have also risen drastically for George Orwell’s “Animal Farm” and “1984,” which shot to the top of Amazon’s best-seller list this week.
Other novels that today’s readers may not have picked up since high school but have landed on the list this week are Aldous Huxley’s 1932 novel, “Brave New World,” a futuristic dystopian story set in England in 2540; and Sinclair Lewis’s 1935 novel “It Can’t Happen Here,” a satire about a bellicose presidential candidate who runs on a populist platform in the United States but turns out to be a fascist demagogue. On Friday, “It Can’t Happen Here” was No. 9 on Amazon; “Brave New World” was No. 15.
The sudden boom in popularity for classic dystopian novels, which began to pick up just after the election, seems to reflect an organic response from readers who are wary of the authoritarian overtones of some of Mr. Trump’s rhetoric. Interest in “1984” surged this week, set off by a series of comments from Mr. Trump, his press secretary, Sean Spicer, and his adviser Kellyanne Conway, in which they disputed the news media’s portrayal of the crowd size at his inauguration and of his fractious relationship with American intelligence agencies. Their insistence that facts like photographs of the crowd and his public statements were up for interpretation culminated in a stunning exchange that Ms. Conway had on NBC’s “Meet the Press,” when she said that Mr. Spicer had not lied about the crowd size but was offering “alternative factsTo many observers, her comment evoked Orwell’s vision of a totalitarian society in which language becomes a political weapon and reality itself is defined by those in power. The remarks prompted a cascade of Twitter messages referencing Orwell and “1984.” According to a Twitter spokesman, the novel was referenced more than 290,000 times on the social network this week. The book began climbing Amazon’s best-seller list, which in turn drove more readers to it, in a sort of algorithm-driven feedback loop. It amounted to a blizzard of free advertising for a 68-year-old novel.
More here: Why ‘1984’ Is a 2017 Must-Read
By MICHIKO KAKUTANIJAN. 26, 2017
Why ‘1984’ Is a 2017 Must-Read – The New York Times
.
LikeLike
What is ironic to me, is that I chose to use Animal Farm in my curriculum (this was in the nineties before Gates managed to convince people that REFORM meant telling professional teachers what they can use).
My humanities colleague, at that time, was introducing our seventh grade to the concepts of the Constitution, as he studied the period in history where the people of our nation (like the animals on the farm) were disposing of the ruling elite (King George and company) and WRITING A CHARTER that explained what the revolution would establish.
I loved that simple Orwell tale– so easy for my kids to read — where the charter that is hung in the barn after the revolution, IS ERODED ER TIME as the original framers of the charter die, and THERE is NO MEMORY of why the animal revolution happened.
Generations of animals had come and had gone,; NO ONE REMEMBERED except one, Boxer — and he was vilified by the propaganda of the PIGS, who now lived in the farmhouse, walked on 2 legs, and knew that the ignorant animals did not remember WHAT the original charter said.
The Pigs could rewrite history like the Koch Brothers are doing, in North Carolina. https://dianeravitch.net/2014/12/05/north-carolina-plans-to-adopt-koch-funded-social-studies-curriculum
The Kochs give us Trump’s new cabinet, and the only way they did this was by OWNING THE MEDIA , the only way the people know what the freak is going on!
Now they want to take over our schools.
No longer are our schools about LEARNING… they are places where our future citizens are ‘taught’ what our alt-right PIGS want them to know.
You see, my friends and colleagues, what is happening with DeVos, is NOT about making tons of money in an educational marketplace. The hedge funds and profiteers are A DIVERSION — folks who profit…GET THE WINDFALL — from the plot WHICH IS TO END AND EDUCATED CITIZENRY — ONE WHERE PEOPLE will realize what the CONSTITUTION ACTUALLY SAYS!
“Privatization of the schools’ is simply the methods, the plot of the oligarchs (i.e. the “billionaire’s boy’s club” as Diane calls them or the EDUCATIONAL INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX https://greatschoolwars.files.wordpress.com/2015/10/eic-oct_11.pdf).
The real OBJECTIVE (i.e the goal of the PLAN to ‘reform’ our schools) is to end democracy,– since democracy depends on shared knowledge http://www.aft.org/sites/default/files/periodicals/hirsch.pdf
IT IS ESSENTIAL TO ENSURE THAT THE CHILDREN of this ‘farm’ called America, never know the truth!
Betsy DeVos is the final blow!
You DO KNOW that HER BROTHER IS Blackwater Founder Erik Prince, Is Secretly Advising Trump: http://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/Scahill-Blackwater-Founde-in-Best_Web_OpEds-Betsy-Devos_Blackwater_Erik-Prince_Erik-Prince-170126-287.html#comment642042
IT IS ALL IN THE FAMILY!
This election circus, and the endless chants about abortions and ending planned parenthood DISTRACT THE PEOPLE as the REAL ASSAULT TO OUR FUTURE IS ONGOING behind the curtain.
In all the discussions and conversations which I read in the media, there is NOT A SINGLE ONE where the TALK is about the PLOT & THE PLOY that ENDS EVERYTHING… BY GETTING OUR CITIZENS when they are YOUNG .
MY words to describe what the oligarchs plan to do: “GET ‘EM YOUNG!”
The greatest propaganda war in history is being waged to end public schools, and it is called EDUCATION REFORM! Orwellian like ‘alternative facts!’
Aided by a chaotic technological era of 24/7 endless static & noise, as lies become facts, a public so ignorant that most cannot name the 3 branches of government, is being farther diminished in the ‘schools.’
Who out there knows that there are 15,880 SCHOOL SYSTEMS, in 52 states… making it a sure thing that NO ONE KNOWS WHAT IS HAPPENING IN “THE SCHOOLS”
(see my series here, or follow the diane Ravitch blog, TO CORRECT HIS GAP IN YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF THE END OF OUR nation)
http://www.opednews.com/author/series/author40790.html
One last thing…
Nowhere, in THE AMERICAN MEDIA, even in all the serious talk about what is going wrong — is there a CLUE about what is going to happenWHEN THE ONLY ONES who can get the skills WHICH ARE ESSENTIAL FOR A good life, are the scions of the wealthy. (hey, I should not complain… my NJ grandkids attend a private academy which costs 25 grand a year for each of them from k to 12. BUT my other grandkids, are home schooled in Texas, where public schools are a joke!
LikeLike
Better Read Than Dead …
LikeLike
Never dead when read
Authors can live forever
I went to see an amazing production of “The Tempest” this afternoon at St Ann’s warehouse in Brooklyn.
All-female, multicultural cast, directed by Phyllida Lloyd, who also directed such shows as “Mama Mia.” If you can get to NYC by Feb 19, see it.
Shakespeare will live forever.
LikeLike
I think we all live forever in a way.
According to quantum mechanics, information is never lost, no matter how black the hole is that it goes down.
“Infortality”
The blackest hole
Can take its toll
But information
Is ever patient
And what goes in
Will re-emerge
In end will win
A black-hole purge
LikeLike
We live forever as a dot of data but as human people with hearts and souls, we live in the memories of those who knew and loved us. Once they are all gone…
LikeLike
Poet and Diane, you are both great authors. I am your student. I think of you as more than bits of information. Much more.
LikeLike
LCT
Thanks for the kind words, but I am not even an author to say nothing of great one.
But as physicists use the word, information is more than just random data bits scattered hither and thither.
In fact, by the technical definition, the latter carry no information at all.
In the current thinking, all the information that goes “into” a black hole ends up as a kind of hologram on the surface and eventually is realeased back to the outside world as the black hole “evaporates.”
It is an underappreciated fact that many physicists have a very wholistic way of looking at things that sometimes comes very close to a mystical or even spiritual view of the universe.
LikeLike
Fourier Analysis
No one who exists
Ever ceases to exist.
It’s just one’s vision —
Temporarily obscured.
LikeLike
Diane,
So true. Thank you. Reading keeps authors alive by breathing the spirit of their ideas into us. Caveat: Common Core-style close reading does not keep authors alive. Quite the opposite! Reading and rereading and rereading short snippets of confounded, argumentative, expository text out of context does not authors alive keep. David Coleman kills authors. He doesn’t “give a shit was you think or what you feel.” It’s murder. High stakes testing is an act of poeticide. By ditching the competency based online textbook and teaching with my heart, I am proudly saving a life, keeping Robert Frost alive this week. I will take the road less traveled by, thank you very much.
LikeLike
“Better Read”
Better read
Than on a Fox
Better said
Than pundit talks
Better dead
Than in a box
LikeLike
“Better dead/ Than in a box”. Got that right.
LikeLike
As long as they are read; the operative words. Such GREAT thoughts from great minds are available to all who will search and devote the time to read and study them.
I mentioned this and someone else also.
George Orwell’s 1984 is flying off the shelves.
People, some, many remember]
Would that there were more..
LikeLike
How breathtakingly present Millay’s voice is! Her shade sits across the table, reading this to me. The poem is an existence proof of its central contention.
Teachers, too, live on in their students. How grateful I am for the teachers I have had.
What most endures in me from their teaching? Their passion. I cannot read Robert Browning without hearing the voice of Mr. Long, the high-school teacher who threw the fat volume of Browning’s poetry open in front of me and shoved me down that rabbit hole. A teacher’s reach exceeds his grasp.
LikeLike
Thank you, Bob. I miss your voice here.
LikeLike
How beautiful is this:
“Read me, do not let me die…”
LikeLike