Here is the response of the National School Boards Association to the bill approved unanimously by the Senate committee. It must now be endorsed by the Senate, then be merged with a bill from the House of Representatives.
NSBA contact: Linda Embrey, Communications Office
703-838-6737; lembrey@nsba.org
National School Boards Association Calls ECAA Vote ‘A Great Victory’
April 16, 2015 – By unanimous vote, the Senate HELP Committee today reported out the Every Child Achieves Act (ECAA), as amended. The three-day mark-up of the Senate’s legislation to modernize and reauthorize the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) allowed committee members to consider and debate more than 50 amendments, with 29 adopted, 8 defeated, and 20 withdrawn.
Committee Chairman Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.) encouraged a ‘yes’ vote on ECAA due to its bipartisan approach and “because the process was fair,” stating that “if you like the fact that we have the Department of Education running schools through waivers in 42 states, vote no.” Moments later, the Committee’s final vote was 22 to 0.
“Today marks a great victory for local and community leadership in public education,” said Thomas J. Gentzel, Executive Director, National School Boards Association. “Though there is much more work to be done, today’s powerful vote demonstrates that we are one step closer to rewriting the broken No Child Left Behind Act and modernizing ESEA.”
Selected highlights from this week’s mark-up of interest to local school board members include:
A voucher amendment withdrawn, but expected to be discussed during the Senate’s floor debate on the bill (Sen. Tim Scott, R-S.C.)
Grants to states to improve the quality and reliability of state assessments (Sen. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wisc.)
An amendment to improve data collection methods and systems, intended to reduce the burden on school districts (Sen. Michael Bennet, D-Colo.)
A change of the funding formula ratio, to 80 percent poverty, 20 percent population, regarding funding for high-quality teachers, principals and other school leaders (Sen. Richard Burr, R-N.C.)
Related to the Burr amendment, a “hold harmless” provision for states that would lose funding due to the change in the funding formula (Sen. Bob Casey, D-Penn.)
Related to the Casey amendment, a gradual decrease of “hold harmless” funding, phasing out the provision in seven years (Sen. Richard Burr, R-N.C.)
Some of the more contentious amendments – a voucher amendment introduced by Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.), and an anti-bullying measure introduced by Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) – were withdrawn, and are expected to resurface on the Senate floor.
While the Senate bill is “imperfect,” according to Gentzel, “it is something NSBA and our strong base of public school advocates can work to perfect moving forward.” Gentzel also noted that NSBA is prepared to remain steadfast in its opposition to privatization – vouchers, tuition tax credits, and non-locally authorized charters.
While the Senate HELP Committee action is another big step in the legislative process, Senators must agree to move ECAA to the Senate floor for an up-or-down vote. Also still on the horizon is the House version (H.R. 5) which has been debated on the House Floor, with no final votes yet taken.
# # #
The National School Boards Association (NSBA) is the leading advocate for public education and supports equity and excellence in public education through school board leadership. NSBA represents state school boards associations and their more than 90,000 local school board members throughout the U.S. Learn more at http://www.nsba.org.
Contact:
Linda Embrey, Communications Office
National School Boards Association
(703) 838-6737; lembrey@nsba.org
http://www.nsba.org

The big idea left to all of us – whether it was intentionally planned by the government or not – was that NOW that states have had a taste of charter expansion, CCSS and APPR, they will be left trained, inculcated, and oriented to be authorized what the feds want them to do, but, under this new bill, are no longer authorized to do.
There’s nothing so great about that. In fact, it’s still a very bad situation.
However, getting the feds OUT of the picture and defanging their legal authority and power inside the states is definitely a step in a better direction because one’s voice is barely heard on a federal level but can be better and more greatly amplified at the state level.
Too bad. I believe in big government, but only when it serves the interests of populism and the true core will of the people. It does not serve the citizenry in the Unites States the way it does in Western and Northern Europe.
The glass is half full in this case, and let’s keep on building our movement to protect public education and fund it properly. Protect public education. Protect Medicare. Protect Social Security. Protect equality.
Protect democracy . . . . .
LikeLike
Robert Rendo, I would go one step further to say that one’s voice is NEVER heard at the federal level, but you have a chance at the state level. I agree, however, that many states have been well trained to do the wrong thing for 13 years, and it is hard to break bad habits.
LikeLike
My goodness! Heavens to Betsy. Good golly, and holy moly, cannoli!
From such a statement, this is not the Diane I first knew. It is the one I wanted to know. Now, it is the only one I do know.
Excellent point!
I have been saying that in so many major ways, the federal government is the biggest den of thieves.
And where are Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand in all of this, besides no where to be found?
LikeLike
“Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.) encouraged a ‘yes’ vote on ECAA due to its bipartisan approach and “because the process was fair,” stating that “if you like the fact that we have the Department of Education running schools through waivers in 42 states, vote no.”
And not a single no vote. Bipartisanship = no democracy!
LikeLike
Follow the money:
NSBA ‘who are we’ includes:
State School Boards Associations
Center for Public Education
COSA
CUBE
National Connection
Technology Leadership Network
– See more at: https://www.nsba.org/corporate-partnerships/1680-club#sthash.KdmcGgMC.dpuf This link takes you back to the SNBA 1680 Club info-in other words their corporate funders most of whom are on the list below.
The funders of Center for Public Education:
Foundations
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation: supported the development of Data First training and outreach
Pew Charitable Trusts: supported CPE’s five-year pre-kindergarten initiative
Pearson Foundation: supported the development of Students on Board school climate guide
Sponsors
President’s Circle — $500,000+
Brokers’ Risk Placement Service, Inc.
Ambassador’s Circle — $250,000+
ARAMARK Education
State Farm Insurance Companies
Texas Association of School Boards
Director’s Circle — $100,000+
Apple, Inc.
Arizona School Boards Association
California School Boards Association
The Coca-Cola Foundation
Illinois Association of School Boards
Kansas Association of School Boards
Munich Reinsurance America, Inc.
Pearson Education
Sodexo School Services
Patron’s Circle — $50,000+
ACT, Inc.
Cisco Systems, Inc.
The College Board
Microsoft Corporation
Scholastic, Inc.
Benefactor’s Circle — $10,000+
Arkansas School Boards Association
Dr. Anne L. Bryant
Connecticut Association of Boards of Education
DeJong Inc.
Georgia School Boards Association
H.O.P.E. Foundation Inc.
Iowa Association of School Boards
Mrs. Susan Kellner in honor of the Spring Branch ISD Board/Superintendent
LeapFrog Enterprises
New Jersey School Boards Association
McGraw-Hill Education
Missouri School Boards’ Association
Nebraska Association of School Boards
Ohio School Boards Association
Oklahoma State School Boards Association
Oregon School Boards Association
Pennsylvania School Boards Association
SchoolNet, Inc.
Virginia School Boards Association
Sponsor’s Circle – $5,000+
Aon Consulting
Alabama Association of School Boards
Association of Alaska School Boards
Audio Enhancement
Florida School Boards Association
Mrs. Martha Fluor
The Fluor Foundation
Mr. Jonathan T. Howe
Dr. Kathy E. Kinley
Minnesota School Boards Association
Montana School Boards Association
New York State School Boards Association
Mr. Robin D. Richards
South Carolina School Boards Association
Mr. Joseph S. Villani
Wyoming School Boards Association
Mr. William H. Zaggle
Current as of September 30, 2011
LikeLike
Why would the US Army be a “1680” sponsor for the NSBA????
LikeLike
“Grants to states to improve the quality and reliability of state assessments (Sen. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wisc.)
An amendment to improve data collection methods and systems, intended to reduce the burden on school districts (Sen. Michael Bennet, D-Colo.)”
We’re still going to pour tons of federal $ into testing and data collection. Who do they think they’re fooling?
LikeLike
There is movement. Not as much as we want, but it is a start. We still have a long way to go.
LikeLike
I’m so impressed with Lamar Alexander right now! Thank God for straight talkers like him. I’d like to see Diane and Lamar on the same stage. I think they would actually hit it off.
LikeLike
“I’m so impressed with Lamar Alexander right now! Thank God for straight talkers like him.”
Ah, sarcasm so early in the morning. It jump starts my day!
LikeLike
Not a victory as far as I am concerned. Just more marketing and political NON-WORDS.
LikeLike