A group called the “Hedge Clippers” organized a protest in front of the building where hedge fund manager Dan Loeb lives, to protest his funding of Republican control of the state senate, as well as charter schools. This is the kind of political activism that was common in the late 1960s to protest the war in Vietnam, but has seldom been seen in this country since then.
A story on WBAI reported the protest rally:
Shame the hedge fund billionaires, go where they live and demonstrate. This is a technique used in Latin America called escrache, but it’s also being used in New York City.
“Hedge Clippers, I guess you can kind of consider everything we do as part of Occupy Wall Street.” Activist Nick McMurray says Hedge Clippers keep the movement going.
“You can call us radicals, but at the end of the day we’re just people putting our foot down and we’re trying to stand up for what’s right and for what we really need in the world and in New York State.”
Zachary Lerner with NY Communities for Change @nychange led Hedge Clippers in a mic check: “Dan Loeb’s politics demonize the immigrants. Dan Loeb’s politics are hostile. Dan Loeb’s politics are powerful. Dan Loeb’s money is massive, so We the People are fighting back.”
Over the weekend, the Hedge Clippers chose the Central Park West residence of hedge fund billionaire Dan Loeb as their target. The hedge fund mogul gave over a million dollars to a super pac, New Yorkers for a Balanced Albany. According to a Nation Magazine expose, it poured $4.3 million into six senate races. This helped tip the balance in favor of Senate Republicans here in New York State, where we have six times as many registered Democrats as Republicans. And Dan Loeb sits on the board of Success Academy, Eva Moskowitz’s charter schools
“There’s a paper trail for everything.” says Nilsa Toledo, a hedge clipper with New York Communities for Change. “He has given mega money to Success Academy and all these pacs for charter schools, on top of giving mega millions to our Senate and our Governor who is supposed to be representing the people, not just the people with a lot of zeros in their bank accounts. That’s really unfair. That’s why we’re standing together against it.”
Toledo has children in public schools in Flatbush, Brooklyn. She says billionaire hedge funders like Dan Loeb, behind charter school funding and lobbying efforts, hurt public schools forced to co-locate, to share their space. “I think that they should pay their own way. They shouldn’t co-locate in public schools. It happened to my son’s school and the quality is so different. In the charter side they have flat screen tvs. Every kid has a laptop and meanwhile I’m paying for that, but in my son’s school, they are lacking. Textbooks are still from 1998. lt’s really disgusting. The teacher’s have to pay out of their own pocket, just to make sure the kid’s have basic education and it’s not right. Our public schools are already owed billions of dollars. Public schools in the city have been underfunded and our government is ignoring that, but meanwhile they are passing policies that benefit the few. All these tax breaks and all these loopholes that are being exploited by these guys are not being closed, but meanwhile our kids are suffering, our communities are suffering and we need to stand up together to make a change.
Mindy Rosier teaches Special Education at a Special Needs School in Harlem. She came out to protest the hedge fund billionaire: “For Daniel Loeb to pay his fair share, to pay his taxes. He’s a contributor to Eva Moskowitz’s Success Academy which has been stealing from my school for eight years and tried to kick us out, so I’m here to stand up for my community, for my students, for public schools. If you’re not helping the public schools out, you’re not a friend to the City as far as I’m concerned.”
Protesters chant, “Pay your taxes, Dan Loeb. Pay your taxes, Dan Loeb.”

Ever notice how these vexed articles and protests about how schools are being starved of funding never mention how much funding the schools get, never mind how it compares to other public schools?
I wonder why that is.
LikeLike
Help us out then, Tim! Get us those figures.
LikeLike
Duane, system wide, the NYC DOE is spending about $24,400 per student: http://schools.nyc.gov/AboutUs/funding/overview/default.htm
There is some variation among schools, of course. District 75 schools (self-contained schools for children with severe disabilities) can spend $85,000 or more per student. Schools like PS 321, which have negligible numbers of economically at-risk kids and which funnel any kids in their catchment area who require self-contained services to other schools, might spend “only” $15,000 per student.
It could very well be the case that hedge fund billionaires should pay more in local, state, and (especially) Federal taxes. If a school in a $24,400/student system has 20-year-old textbooks, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to wonder whether that’s a separate issue.
LikeLike
And once you get those numbers Tim, I would like the education spending itemized so that we can see what the money is being spent on. It is certainly not getting to the classroom level where the teachers and the students are.
LikeLike
Below were the biggest line items as of fiscal 2013. This gets you to around $16 billion. If you listed debt service, it might get you to around $19 billion.
Gen ed salaries: $5.5 billion
Employee benefits: $2.8 billion
Pensions: $2.8 billion
Special ed salaries: $2 billion
“Categorical Program” salaries: $1.2 billion (mainly federal and state funds allocated for specifical purposes, like professional development, bilingual instruction, universal pre-K, etc.)
Charter and contract schools: $1.4 billion (about $1 billion of that is charter schools)
Pupil Transportation: $1.1 billion
Pre-K contracts: $941 million
LikeLike
Districts only truly control 10-15% of their budgets because of mandated expenditures.
LikeLike
Your premises reveal your covert bias, since “the (charter) schools” you refer to are not public schools.
LikeLike
I was thinking more of traditional public schools in other states and in other high cost of living areas, actually.
True, New York City does not spend as much as some surrounding districts where the cost of operating the schools has been inflated as part of the system that keeps minorities out. Compared to everyone else . . .
LikeLike
Tim, allow me to help you out out by sending you here:
http://www.statewideonline.org/wordpress/
I just wish that Dr. Timbs had more recent data on his website, but it’s a place to start. Saying that schools get “a lot of funding” tells us nothing about the problems created by the freezing of the Foundation Aid (which amounts to a cut), the Gap Elimination Adjustment (enacted to close now moot budget deficits), and the effect of the tax levy cap (made much harder for districts to override than for municipalities, btw). These state aid cuts have disproportionately hit poor and rural districts Upstate.
Happy number-crunching, Tim!
LikeLike
It’s about time someone got a gut check and went into the streets. All the work we put into the teaching profession in obtaining rights, benefits and respect has been pissed away without a whimper from the current generation. As far as the “powerful teachers unions” go they have been shown to be a bunch of cowards cringing before every anti-middle class politician from NJ to CA.
Additionally, let me add a comment pertaining to the lack of public protest about the ongoing, life sacrificing, resource consuming wars. These are wars which have been conjured up and propagandized by the Military Industrial Complex of which Eisenhower warned. Where are all the protesters of the 60s? They can’t all be dead can they? The only thing I can suspect is that if other people’s children and grandchildren are doing dying it’s A okay with them? Now that the government has developed a “professional army” to fight their inane wars apathy reigns supreme and we continue towards the abyss that swallowed the USSR – going broke with unchecked arms conflicts and military spending. Let’s call out the “bumper sticker patriots” who would refuse to send their kin to these and other futile wars. Sign my petition: http://www.thepetitionsite.com/987/015/323/re-institutie-the-military-draft-with-no-deferments-help-to-stop-endless-war/
LikeLike
Cross-posted at OEN
http://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/Shades-of-the-1960s-Prote-in-Best_Web_OpEds-Activism_Diane-Ravitch_Hedge-Funds_Protester-150324-891.html#comment538410
with this comment :
“Way to go Diane. Tell us what people are doing to take back our schools, because the media reports only what the oligarchs (who own the press) allow.”
LikeLike
It’s about time people responded to the true
“takers” in our society.
LikeLike
A billion dollars of public tax levies going to private charter schools?? That’s what this private war on public education is all about–to funnel tax levies to religious and non-religious private units, financed at public expense without public oversight, or to put it simply, the private looting of public taxes. Shame on Cuomo and all govt officials enabling Eva and her cronies to loot the funds needed for the public sector.
LikeLike
That billion dollars is used to educate 70,000 children. Soup to nuts, essentially: all salaries and fringe benefits, books, supplies, food, computers, rent (where applicable), and so forth.
LikeLike
And as for charter schools’ ROI, I mean “their closing of the achievement gap”, Tim? Are we New Yorkers getting our money’s worth there?
LikeLike
It sure seems that we are in New York City, which is home to the vast majority of the charter schools in New York State. CREDO’s got a new report out, and [SPOILERS!!!] 64% of NYC charters outperform their district counterpart, 22% perform about the same, and only 14% are worse. Kids attending NYC charters are making substantial, sustained gains in reading and math:
http://urbancharters.stanford.edu/news.php
How many charters are in your district, Sharon?
LikeLike
Zero charters, and we mean to keep it that way.
Tim, you are not so naive as that, I’m sure. You know how the NYC charters get their numbers up. They totally game the system.
LikeLike
@Sharon in NYS. No, Tim is really that naive. He thinks charter schools want the best for every child. That’s not what I’ve heard from people who have taught at charter schools.
LikeLike
You can complain about the money given to them “crazy right winged” rerpublicums, but last time I checked Cuomo is a Democrat. The reason people with money are trying to influence our politics is rooted, yes in self-interest, but also with a deep felt concern that we are all headed in the wrong direction.
Paying your taxes won’t help if the politicians keep spending it the way they do.
It’s not Democrats or Republicans that are the problem, it is the apathetic, complacent, compliant citizens who have surrendered their power in return for comfort.
I was 17 in ’68 and grew up in SF, the rebellious spirit has withered and tye-died pursuing epicurean life over fighting for liberty and limiting government.
Where is Benjamin to tell us how they’ve changed the rules on the side of the barn?
LikeLike
Regarding the “Shades of the 1960s; The April edition of The Atlantic has an interesting article: Why Workers Won’t Unite. Many of you would find it very interesting reading AND it has a direct bearing on the “Shades of the 1960s.
LikeLike
Loeb probably took his private elevator to the roof where he flew out in a chopper, and as he flew away, he looked down at the ant sized protestors and thought, “I’ll step on them.”
To discover what most of the 1% thinks about the rest of us, you might be interested in reading this from Business insider:
http://www.businessinsider.com/the-collapse-of-the-middle-class-will-be-felt-around-the-world-2015-3
LikeLike
Thank you Dr. Ravitch to present this thread “Shades-of-the-1960s”
Thank you Mr. Lloyd Lofthouse for the interesting link
IMHO, there are only two kinds of humankind – the kind and the unkind- or the noble and the snobbish- or the leader and the follower regardless of how poor, how rich, how sick, how healthy, how educated from self-taught or from appropriate schooling-
For this reason, there will be always some collapse and some survive – or most collapse and few survive dependent on the majority or minority of who is unkind or kind accordingly.
Historically, I have learned that human beings have progressed from self-reflection towards self-awareness through millions of years on this dichotomous earth.
For self-reflection type, people only react according to their WANTS more than their needs. For this reason, people of self-reflection type are easily lured into trap of emotion, and they become coward, controlled, and manipulated by THE master.
For self-awareness type, people have strong will, endurance, and perseverance to pursue their NEEDS more than their wants. For this reason, people of self-awareness type are difficult to fall into any trap of emotion, BUT easily fall into trap of EGO that is set up by THE very clever master.
The background of any master will reveal their true character of kind (nurturing) or unkind (controlling) action towards society and people. Back2basic
LikeLike
Well, according to Evita Moskowitz, she and her pals built the charter schools in NYC. She doesn’t mention stealing the space and shoving aside the kids who were already there to make room: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ewqR12szOTM
LikeLike