Jan Resseger remembers a film made in a school in Ohio about 20 years ago, by Bill Moyers, before testing became our national obsession.
She writes:
In one of the film’s memorable scenes, a stalwart music teacher leads a school orchestra rehearsal—string instruments and classical music, I think—in a rural high school where the music room is directly under the gymnasium and where the basketball team is practicing at the same time. The cameraman stood somehow on the stairway and let the camera catch both activities happening simultaneously. As we hear the music, we watch the ceiling of the band room shake and feel the blows as the athletes’ feet hit the floor and the basketball bounces. Today here in Ohio the facilities would be better, but the school would likely not have a music program. Cuts in state funding in recent years would likely have left the district without elementary school instrumental music, which means that even if the high school tried to have a complete band or orchestra, not enough children would have learned to play the instruments needed to make up a full ensemble. And the pressure to raise test scores in the required language arts and math would likely have reduced the time for music and art.

Here’s what we’re headed toward:
And even in such circumstances, there will be teachers like this one, who will refuse to give up on providing hope to kids.
LikeLike
¡Qué increíble!
Gracias, Roberto y
¡QGEE!
(TAGO in Spanish)
LikeLike
LOL
LikeLike
I just retired as a reading teacher from a school in which I had to conduct reading classes in the music wing. I had the choir on one side, the band/orchestra on the other, and the school auditorium right across the hall. Not conducive to concentrating on silent reading or focusing on other reading activities for 7th graders! Of course, my state evaluations from Ohio were low. I wonder why?
LikeLike
Because the state evaluations are 100% Grade AA Pure Bovine Excrement.
LikeLike
I teach in a music room at the end of the hallway that leads to the playground. When students come in from recess throughout the day, it is in the middle of a class period. Yet, they are noisy, and if the line is stopped in the hall, the students rudely plaster their faces to the windows of my doors when their teachers are not looking. They also like to bump the doors as they walk by so that they shake thus disrupting my students’ concentration. All of these actions are extremely disturbing for my students. How ever will they be able to concentrate so they they can show learning during their assessments, and how will my evaluation reflect their level of focus with all the noise and nonsense of their passing in the hallway during my daily lessons? Recess literally outside my door is not conducive to training young ears to carefully concentrate on the discrimination of sounds that is necessary for music study. Should I parade my students up and down the hallways noisily outside of the other students’ classrooms so they can see what it is like or should I just suck it up and be a team player?
LikeLike
Jan is one of the champions for children and public schools writing out of Ohio, but her blog keeps her readers informed on what is occurring in and to our public schools nationwide. Thank you Jan, Diane, and to the others who are keeping our hopes alive to revive the public schools our children have a right to attend.
LikeLike
Children in Americas Schools was produced by Patrick Baker. It was true years ago and even truer now. Why is it so difficult to provide a quality education for our country’s children? Who do we hold accountable for this failure?
LikeLike
Tragically the aforementioned problems do not occur JUST in Ohio. Politicians have no idea what real education is about. One wonders if they ever took a course in philosophy or logic.
LikeLike
To all readers who treasure music:
The young girl in “Landfill Harmonic” candidly said that her life would be WORTHLESS if it is WITHOUT MUSIC.
I profoundly confuse at DOE, all States Governors who intentionally replace Languages, literature, Arts, Music and Sports programs with inappropriate testing so that testing would bring young America citizens to be soulful/fearful or WORTHLESS whatever DOE and States Governors don’t know or don’t really care for within a decade later.
However, I know, all conscientious teachers know, and most of caring parents know that sports nurture BODY, literature nurtures MIND, and music nurture SOUL/SPIRIT.
It is time for all American citizens, young and old, blue and white collars to unite into ONE FORCE to demand COMMON CORE STATES STANDARDS which provide sports, literature and music, besides STEM so that students in Public or Private educational environment can grow confidently and thrive freely with multitude aspects of learning.
LikeLike
I regularly show this to my oldest music students, especially the ones who complain about having to “find time out of their video gaming and sports schedule” to actually practice their beautiful new, rented instruments.
LikeLike