Yesterday, the Chicago Teachers Union rejected the city’s contract offer. This is the CTU explanation:
CHICAGO – After much deliberation, the Chicago Teachers Union has rejected the Board of Education’s most recent contract proposal because it does not address the difficult conditions in the schools, the lack of services to our neediest students or address the long-term fiscal crisis that threatens to gut public education in the city. Moreover, educators do not believe the Board will honor its promises because it has lacked the will to join with parents, students, community and others in identifying existing revenue solutions that can stabilize the district.
“Chicago Public Schools (CPS) challenges are a revenue-based problem because two of the three biggest cost drivers are things that have to be paid: pensions and debt service (which includes the swap termination payments),” said CTU President Karen Lewis. “The third biggest cost driver is charter school proliferation—and though they’ve promised to halt charter expansion there is a state commission that can override their decision. There are no guarantees.”
Lewis said CTU members have given more than $2 billion back to the district over the last five years, including $500 million from the 4 percent raise that was rescinded in 2011; $500 million from layoffs over this period, including from the school closings; and $1.2 billion from the three- year partial pension holiday between 2011 to 2013.
“Simply signing a contract with CPS will not bring them a windfall of resources from the state,” Lewis said. “We have to exhaust every option available, which includes terminating those swap deals, returning the TIFs to the schools and a financial transaction tax that could bring hundreds of millions of dollars to the city. Without some real movement on the revenue problems, we can’t trust that they will honor any words offered in a four-year contract deal.”
It should be noted that the CPS bond sale went south last week because investors are skittish about the real financial challenges the district faces. The downgrades came after investors’ concerns about the city’s inability to raise revenue. Also, the district is using short-term credit lines to manage cash flow because its cash flow is so limited. The money from property taxes is already spent – those short-term lines have to be repaid.
“CPS has been living on borrowing for too long,” said CTU Vice President Jesse Sharkey. “Now to turn around and blame teachers and staff for that debt while letting bankers off the hook is not acceptable. We think bankruptcy is a bluff, but if it isn’t, the mayor and his handpicked school board need to examine our commitments to progressive revenue.”
CPS’ uses this math to plug its budget hole:
· $200 million from the state for pensions
· $150 million from the state in a school aid formula change
· $170 million from a new local property tax levy for pensions
· $150 to $175 million from eliminating the teacher’s pension pickup and from increased healthcare costs.
“That’s about $700 million of the claimed $800 million deficit,” said Sharkey. “They want us to foot two chunks of that through property tax increases and classrooms cuts. We need a big fix to school funding at the state level through progressive taxes on wealthy people. The Board cannot continue to balance its budget on teachers and students by cutting our compensation and eliminating vital education services such as special education.”
Today, CTU took action to protest the city’s actions:
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: Stephanie Gadlin
Feb. 2, 2016 312-329-6250
CTU to close Bank of America account and challenge City of Chicago and CPS to do the same
News conference and action at 10:00 a.m. Wednesday
CHICAGO – The day after the Chicago Public Schools CEO Forrest Claypool declared war on public school educators by threatening another $100 million in classroom cuts and the snatching of their pension pick-up benefit, the Chicago Teachers Union will engage in a series of non-violent direct actions to call attention to Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s refusal to explore every revenue option available to him to stabilize the school district. Instead of working with the CTU to return toxic swap payments, tax the wealthy and restore the TIFS to the school district, the mayor would rather have Governor Bruce Rauner send in the Illinois National Guard to take over CPS.
WHO:
CTU Officers; toxic swap experts; community allies and others
WHAT:
Will close its account with Bank of America in the amount of over $700,000 and redirect those monies to Amalgamated Bank
WHEN:
Wednesday, February 3, 2016
10:00 a.m.
WHERE:
Bank of America
35 S. LaSalle Street, Chicago
WHY:
Bank of America and other financial institutions that sold CPS toxic interest rate swaps are demanding a payout of at least $228 million, which is almost the exact same amount as the recent cuts enacted by the Board to our schools and special education at the same time. In total, the City and CPS is expecting to lose $1.2 billion on the swaps. CTU has asked the Board to be a partner in challenging these rip off, toxic swap deals for years.
###
And Gov. Rauner is moving to take over the Chicago Schools even though the state does not have a budget and is over $ 6 billion in debt. He doesn’t pay his bills and he wants CPS.
Is the CTU under the impression that it can negotiate a tax increase through a labor contract? The situation seems a bit odd.
Are there laws prohibiting proposing one? This seems the complement to companies negotiating tax cuts and abatements as part of negotiations with a state or local government. Is there a difference other than one increases taxes and another reduces them?
You can ask the city to support a tax increase, and the city can agree to make good faith efforts to do so. But you can’t actually change tax laws in a private negotiation with the mayor. The best result you can hope for is one that relies on trusting the city to exercise good faith, which is precisely what the CTU says it can’t do. So it’s not clear to me what the CTU is aiming for.
In a sensible universe, I’d agree with you FLERP! But in Chicago, “the mayor”, “the city” and “CPS” are all the same person – Rahm Emanuel.
It’s not my impression that Rahm Emanuel controls the state legislature (note CTU’s apparent demand for “school funding at the state level through progressive taxes on wealthy people”). And even assuming he did, CTU says he can’t be trusted, so presumably CTU wouldn’t trust a commitment by Emmanuel to change Illinois state tax law in the future. And CTU knows that a collective bargaining agreement can’t increase taxes on the wealthy. Hence my confusion about what it is CTU is seeking. Although I’m probably making the mistake of taking their statement literally. More likely it’s strategic rhetoric and the real goal is a contract that doesn’t increase pension and healthcare contributions for members.
Seems inconsistent. If a company can negotiate a new tax abatement without voter approval or a sports team increase taxes without a vote (our Blue Jackets), then the same concept holds for other organizations negotiating with the city for any change in taxation. Plus a tax abatement, all things being equal, is a tax increase on everyone else or a decrease in government service levels. Money doesn’t just appear at state and local levels. If the law was consistent and reasoned rather than biased and arbitrary, perhaps people would have more faith in government institutions.
I’m not sure I agree with the premise that companies negotiate tax abatements without voter approval. I believe tax abatements, credits, etc. must be enacted into law by legislative vote.
Wow, Chicago is a total mess. Rahm has driven the windy city into oblivion and I really feel sorry for the hard working people of the Chicago public schools. Wow, a great city is now becoming a third world hell hole due to out of control immigration, illegal and other, which has turned the system into a complete shit house of over population where the money cannot keep up with the immigration seekers who clean house with all the freebies. Can you believe what it has come down to?? All the people of the CTU want is to educate their kids but Rahm is destined to create havoc and boy oh boy has he ever. Lets not forget the other problems of the windy city like shootings all over the city, a police force under the scrutiny of idiot politicians who have destroyed this once great city in America.
Really? After everything Rahm has done to suck up all the public money and hand it over to his corporate cronies, you’re blaming Chicago’s problems on immigrants??? And what do you mean by “illegal and other”? Do you just have a problem with them furriners now matter how they came here? Do you have any idea how difficult it is to immigrate here legally?
We should put blame where it squarely deserves to be, on the bad, corporatist policies of Rahm Emanuel. He is out of touch with what needs to be done. He has attempted to force all types of failed privatization on the residents. Those are the real problems. Instead of scapegoating vulnerable groups, we should analyze the cause and effect of reality.
Dienne, sorry you are for immigrants but to answer your question of how hard it is to come here legally my answer is all you have to do is marry someone here. People are using fake marriages and alike to get into the country then they go their separate ways. Further, people are just walking across the border, get a summons and then never show up for the summons hearing with no consequences. Sorry but the tremendous flow of immigrants to the US has now caused a glut financially – 20 trillion in debt yet everyone immigrant and their grand mothers are getting…free rent, free food, free education, free bus and train rides to school, free school, free breakfast in school, free lunch in school,free tests, free books, free library cards and you do not even have to return anything anymore, free health care, free medical, omg i am getting tired of typing….remember 20 trillion in debt