We all would like to believe in miracles.

There aren’t many, especially with reference to schools that miraculously “turn around” in one year.

It is comforting to believe that a school can change from the worst to the best almost overnight. It is a made-for-Hollywood scenario.

Last night at the Democratic convention, Governor Deval Patrick talked about the one-year turnaround of a school named Orchard Gardens.

Gary Rubinstein checked and learned that 80% of the teachers were fired. Then he went to the Massachusetts Department of Education website. Not exactly one of the best schools in the state.

Why do so many politicians think that the best way to fix a school is to fire almost everyone (or everyone) and start over?  Wouldn’t it be more productive to help the school, add resources where needed, remove those who are truly incompetent, do whatever it takes to make the school work well for its students? Why is mass firing the preferred solution?